血管外科大截肢围术期疼痛管理:英国麻醉与血管外科Delphi共识
本研究针对血管疾病所致大下肢截肢的围术期疼痛管理,在英国麻醉与血管外科顾问医师中开展三轮改良Delphi共识。12条未达成共识。
要点
- 跨专科共同负责大截肢围术期疼痛管理。
- 区域阻滞镇痛是主要手段,可用神经周围导管并采用阿片节约策略。
- 推荐流程化决策辅助,同时个体化调整镇痛方案。
核心结论
- 首次形成大下肢截肢围术期疼痛管理的操作特异性多学科共识,明确 agreed 原则与优选镇痛方法。
- 未达成共识的领域提示未来研究、服务组织与指南制定方向。
研究设计与样本
- 三轮在线改良Delphi共识研究,专家为英国麻醉与血管外科顾问医师。
主要发现
- 44条陈述中32条达成强共识同意,无陈述达成强共识不同意。
- 共识包括跨专科共担疼痛管理责任、区域阻滞镇痛为主要手段、使用神经周围导管、阿片节约策略及流程化决策辅助并个体化。
- 实践障碍包括资源限制和直接证据缺乏。
- 12条未达成共识,涉及截肢前启动区域阻滞、超声引导神经导管置入及外科医师实施区域阻滞。
关键数值与推荐
- 强共识阈值:≥75%评分同意或不同意,且轮间评分变化<10%。
- 共识同意:跨专科共担疼痛管理责任。
- 共识同意:区域阻滞镇痛为主要手段,可使用神经周围导管。
- 共识同意:采用阿片节约策略及流程化决策辅助并个体化镇痛。
临床怎么用
- 大截肢围术期应采用跨专科协作疼痛管理,以区域阻滞镇痛为主并考虑神经周围导管。
- 优先采用阿片节约策略,使用流程化决策辅助同时个体化调整。
- 截肢前启动区域阻滞、超声引导神经导管置入及外科医师实施区域阻滞尚存不确定性,需结合个案决策。
局限性
- 证据基础异质且有限,共识受资源限制影响。
- 12条陈述未达成共识,部分实践问题仍不确定。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Major lower extremity amputations occurring secondary to vascular disease remain prevalent worldwide. Pain surrounding these procedures is complex, multifactorial and associated with poor functional and psychosocial outcomes. The evidence base informing pain management approaches in major lower extremity amputations remain largely heterogeneous and limited. This study aimed to establish procedure-specific, multispeciality consensus on the ideal principles and practices required to optimise pain management for vascular surgical patients undergoing major lower extremity amputations. METHODS: A three-round online modified Delphi consensus process was undertaken, with consultant anaesthetists and consultant vascular surgeons across the UK forming the expert panel. Structured statements were assessed on a 5-point Likert scale against a strong consensus threshold of ≥ 75% ratings in agreement or disagreement, and a rating stability criterion of < 10% change between rounds. Free-text responses were thematically analysed at each round to iteratively modify or generate new statements. RESULTS: Seventy-two panellists participated in the study. Of the 44 consensus statements assessed, 32 reached strong consensus agreement. These included: shared cross-speciality responsibility for pain management; the mainstay role of locoregional analgesia; use of perineural catheters; opioid-sparing approaches; and protocolised decision aids with individualisation of analgesia. Barriers to practices identified included resource constraints and the paucity of direct evidence. There was non-consensus in 12 statements, notably on pre-amputation initiation of locoregional analgesia; ultrasound-guided nerve catheter placement; and surgeon-delivered regional analgesia. No statement reached strong consensus disagreement. DISCUSSION: This study provides the first procedure-specific consensus, delineating agreed principles and preferred pharmacological and locoregional analgesic approaches to peri-operative pain management in patients undergoing major lower extremity amputations. The areas of non-consensus expose key uncertainties that may inform future research, service organisation and guideline development agendas. WHAT WE DID: Groups of expert doctors from across the UK worked together online to agree on the best ways to manage pain for patients who need to have their leg removed. They answered questions over three rounds and rated how much they agreed with different statements. The goal was to see which ideas most experts supported. WHY WE DID IT: Some people need to have part of their leg removed because of problems with their blood vessels. These operations can cause different kinds of pain, which can make it harder for patients to move, heal and recover emotionally. Doctors use many methods to help with pain, but the research about the best ways to do this is mixed and not always clear. WHAT WE FOUND: Seventy‐two doctors took part. They looked at 44 statements and strongly agreed on 32 of them. They agreed that doctors from different specialities should share responsibility for pain care, that numbing certain nerves is very helpful, that small tubes can be placed near nerves to give pain medicine and that treatment should try to reduce the need for strong opioid drugs. They also agreed that pain plans should be guided by clear rules but still be flexible for each patient. Some things did not reach agreement, such as starting nerve‐numbing treatments before surgery and which doctors should place nerve catheters. This study is the first to create clear, shared guidance on how to manage pain for people having major leg amputations. The areas where the experts did not agree show where more research and clearer rules are still needed.
引用
- Ekkunagul T, MacLeod CS, Celnik A, et al. Peri-operative pain management in major lower extremity amputation in vascular Surgery: a UK anaesthetic and vascular surgery Delphi consensus study. Anaesthesia. 2025. PMID: 41408655. doi:10.1111/anae.70107
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。