气道管理研究核心结局集
该研究通过系统综述和改良德尔菲调查,由患者、临床医生及其他利益相关者共同参与,制定了气道管理研究的核心结局集。最终达成共识的11个结局包括死亡、心跳骤停、严重并发症等,并为所有结局提出了测量工具建议。
要点
- 核心结局集包含11个结局,涵盖安全性、并发症和操作成功率。
- 所有结局均提出了推荐的测量工具。
- 该结局集旨在标准化未来气道管理研究的结局报告。
核心结论
- 提出了首个基于共识的气道管理研究核心结局集,包含11个结局及推荐的测量工具。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述随机抽取100项研究,从4368项研究中识别候选结局。
- 改良德尔菲调查涉及三个利益相关者组:有气道管理经历的患者、临床医生及其他人员。
- 两轮德尔菲调查分别有453人和155人完成,来自六大洲。
- 两次虚拟会议分别有62人和44人参加。
主要发现
- 系统综述从100项随机样本研究中列出68个候选结局。
- 最终共识核心结局集包括:死亡、心跳骤停、严重并发症、肺部并发症、神经系统并发症、气道创伤、未识别的食管插管、低氧血症、无并发症的首次尝试成功、无并发症的总体成功、困难气道。
- 所有纳入结局均达成了推荐的测量工具。
临床怎么用
- 未来气道管理研究应纳入并报告这11个核心结局,以促进证据合成和临床转化。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Airway management research has historically incorporated heterogeneous outcome selection and definitions. This impedes evidence synthesis and hinders advances in patient care. We aimed to develop a core outcome set to standardise airway management research and improve outcome reporting. METHODS: We performed a systematic review of outcomes reported in airway management studies to identify candidate outcomes from a random sample of eligible studies. We used a modified Delphi survey of three key stakeholder groups: patients with experience of airway management; clinicians engaged in airway management; and others (including researchers, device manufacturers and policymakers). Outcomes were classified into five domains: procedural effectiveness; physiological parameters; adverse events; patient-reported outcomes; and other. Outcomes were presented in random order in two sequential virtual Delphi surveys and rated by each respondent. Candidate outcome measurement instruments were identified through included studies and targeted literature searches. Subsequently, a core outcome set with suggested outcome measurement instruments was discussed and agreed. RESULTS: The systematic review identified 4368 studies, with 68 candidate outcomes longlisted from a random sample of 100 studies. Rounds one and two Delphi surveys were completed by 453 and 155 participants, respectively, from six continents. First and second virtual panels were attended by 62 and 44 participants, respectively. The final agreed core outcome set included 11 outcomes: death; cardiac arrest; serious complications; pulmonary complications; neurological complications; airway trauma; unrecognised oesophageal intubation; hypoxaemia; first attempt success without complications; overall success without complications; and difficult airway. Proposed outcome measurement instruments were agreed for all included outcomes. DISCUSSION: We present the first consensus-based core outcome set for airway management research, with agreed definitions and measurement instruments. Incorporation of these outcomes into future airway management studies will harmonise evidence synthesis and improve the translatability of findings to improve clinical care. Patients often have airway management for a planned general anaesthetic or as a result of a medical emergency. Procedures or devices are used to make sure that oxygen is safely delivered to the lungs at all times. Research studies of airway management look at different outcomes to see if a treatment works well and is safe. An outcome is a way of measuring how well a treatment works or how it affects a patient's health. An outcome might be something patients can feel, like pain, or something that can be seen by a healthcare professional, such as wound healing, or a test result, such as a blood pressure reading. The aim of the Airway Terminology and Outcome Measures (ATOM) project was to find the most important outcomes for airway management studies and agree how to define them. We looked at relevant studies to see what outcomes were reported in the past. We then used two surveys to ask patients with personal experience of airway management, as well as healthcare professionals and researchers, which outcomes were the most important to them. After the surveys, two online meetings with patients and airway management experts took place to agree on the final 11 outcomes. These related to patient safety and other clinical procedures and the best methods of measuring them. We hope that future studies will use these outcomes to help healthcare professionals improve patient care.
引用
- Hansel J, Fuchs A, Cornwell B, et al. A core outcome set for airway management research. Anaesthesia. 2025. PMID: 41199615. doi:10.1111/anae.70026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。