文献速递气道管理

默认视频喉镜替代直接喉镜气管插管的实施:证据与经验叙述性综述

Implementation of default videolaryngoscopy instead of direct laryngoscopy for tracheal intubation: a narrative review of evidence and experiences.
PubMed 文献 · Anaesthesia · 2025-08-22

本文综述了视频喉镜作为默认插管工具的优势证据,讨论了不采用视频喉镜的常见理由并予以反驳,同时描述了五家英国NHS医院实施默认视频喉镜的经验及实用建议。

要点

  • 多项大型随机对照试验和荟萃分析支持视频喉镜的使用。
  • 2015年以来的指南推荐尽可能常规使用视频喉镜。
  • 实施默认视频喉镜需应对成本、消毒和培训等挑战。

核心结论

  • 证据支持将视频喉镜作为默认气管插管工具,但需克服实施障碍。

研究设计与样本

  • 叙述性综述,总结证据并描述五家英国NHS医院实施默认视频喉镜的经验。

主要发现

  • 多项大型随机对照试验和荟萃分析(纳入超过200项试验的数据)支持视频喉镜的使用。
  • 报告的优势包括技术优势(提高安全性、有效性和插管易用性,减少并发症)、非技术优势(改善团队合作和沟通)、改善直接喉镜培训和环境效益。
  • 不使用的理由包括认为不必要、导致直接喉镜技能退化或学习失败、视频喉镜失败、污染气道中无效、成本、可重复使用镜片消毒挑战。

关键数值与推荐

  • 2015年以来的指南和报告推荐立即获取视频喉镜并进行相关技术培训和技能获取。
  • 近期指南推荐尽可能常规使用视频喉镜。

临床怎么用

  • 为临床医生、管理者、采购团队和消毒服务部门提供证据和信息,以支持实施默认视频喉镜的商业论证。
  • 描述应对实施挑战的有效实用策略。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Default videolaryngoscopy - use of a videolaryngoscope in preference to a direct laryngoscope - remains a hotly debated topic. High-risk tracheal intubations performed during the COVID-19 pandemic added to the extensive existing evidence of advantages of videolaryngoscopy for patients and staff. Despite this, and calls for implementation of default videolaryngoscopy, it has not been adopted widely. METHODS: We summarise current evidence for the benefits of videolaryngoscopy and discuss (and where appropriate dispute) the common reasons given for not using videolaryngoscopy. The experiences of five UK NHS hospitals which have made a move to default videolaryngoscopy are described, with practical advice to assist other hospitals planning similar projects. RESULTS: Several recent large randomised controlled trials and meta-analyses, incorporating data from over 200 trials, support the use of videolaryngoscopes. Guidelines and reports published since 2015 have recommended immediate access to videolaryngoscopes plus training and skill acquisition in the required techniques. Recent guidelines have recommended the routine use of videolaryngoscopes whenever possible. Reported advantages include: technical benefits (improved safety, efficacy and ease of tracheal intubation plus fewer complications); non-technical benefits (including improved teamwork and communication); improved direct laryngoscopy training; and environmental benefits. Reasons cited for not using a videolaryngoscope include concerns that they: are unnecessary; lead to decay in or failure to learn direct laryngoscopy skills; videolaryngoscopy failure; ineffectiveness in a soiled airway; cost; and challenges relating to decontamination of reusable blades. We discuss these and, where appropriate, provide counter arguments. DISCUSSION: This narrative review provides the relevant evidence and information for clinicians, managers, procurement teams and sterile services departments to use, should a business case be proposed to implement default videolaryngoscopy. We describe effective practical strategies for addressing implementation challenges. Doctors often use a tool called a laryngoscope to help put a breathing tube into a person's throat. There are two kinds: a regular one (called a direct laryngoscope) and a video one (called a videolaryngoscope). Some doctors think the video one is better and safer, especially for hard cases. But even with lots of proof, many hospitals still don't use the video kind all the time. This report looks at the research showing why the video laryngoscope is useful. It also talks about common reasons people give for not using it and explains why those reasons might not be right. It shares what five hospitals in the UK did to start using the video kind as their first choice and gives tips for others who want to do the same. Big studies that looked at over 200 trials say the video laryngoscope works well. Since 2015, expert groups have said hospitals should have these tools ready and train doctors to use them. New rules even say they should be used as the normal choice when possible. The video laryngoscope helps doctors see better and avoid problems. It also helps teams work together better and makes training easier. Some people worry the video tool is too expensive, too hard to clean or won't work in certain situations. The report talks about these worries and gives reasons why they may not be true. This report gives useful facts and ideas to help doctors, hospital leaders and equipment teams decide if they want to switch to using the video laryngoscope as the first choice. It also gives helpful steps to make the change smoother.

来源:Anaesthesia,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kelly FE, Scholz A, Mayer J, et al. Implementation of default videolaryngoscopy instead of direct laryngoscopy for tracheal intubation: a narrative review of evidence and experiences. Anaesthesia. 2025. PMID: 40842319. doi:10.1111/anae.16731

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。