增强现实在气道管理中的应用:范围综述
多数研究使用头戴式显示器辅助模拟培训或操作引导,结果不一;一项随机对照试验显示增强现实辅助视频喉镜较标准方法插管成功率更高、操作时间更短,另一项使用头戴式显示器提供操作清单的随机对照试验清单依从性更高但插管时间更长。现有证据受样本量小、研究设计异质性和缺乏标准化评估方案限制,尚无研究直接评估安全性或患者中心结局。
要点
- 增强现实辅助视频喉镜在随机对照试验中提高插管成功率并缩短操作时间。
- 头戴式显示器提供操作清单可提高清单依从性但延长插管时间。
- 现有证据样本量小、设计异质,且缺乏安全性与患者中心结局评估。
核心结论
- 增强现实有潜力改善气道管理中的解剖理解、操作准确性和教学参与度,但临床整合仍处于早期阶段。
- 需要更严格的大规模临床试验来确定其有效性、优化可用性并明确其在提升患者安全和培训中的作用。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,遵循PRISMA-ScR指南系统检索PubMed、Embase和IEEE数据库。
- 纳入标准为聚焦增强现实辅助气道培训或操作的研究,排除以虚拟现实为核心或缺乏操作相关性的研究。
主要发现
- 多数研究使用头戴式显示器支持模拟培训或操作引导,覆盖儿童和成人人群。
- 评估结局包括客观指标(插管成功、时间、操作准确性)和主观指标(用户信心、感知可用性、教育价值)。
- 一项随机对照试验显示增强现实辅助视频喉镜较标准方法插管成功率更高且操作时间更短。
- 另一项随机对照试验使用头戴式显示器提供操作清单,发现清单依从性更高但插管时间更长。
- 参与者主观反馈指出设备复杂性、学习曲线和装备限制等挑战。
关键数值与推荐
- 一项随机对照试验:增强现实辅助视频喉镜较标准方法插管成功率更高、操作时间更短。
- 另一项随机对照试验:头戴式显示器提供操作清单,清单依从性更高但插管时间更长。
临床怎么用
- 增强现实可辅助气道管理模拟培训和操作引导,但当前证据尚不足以支持常规临床整合。
- 使用时需考虑设备复杂性、学习曲线和装备限制对操作效率的影响。
局限性
- 样本量小。
- 研究设计存在变异性。
- 缺乏标准化评估方案。
- 无研究直接评估增强现实在气道管理中的安全性或对患者中心结局的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Augmented reality, which overlays virtual information onto the physical environment, is an emerging technology in health care with promising applications in education, diagnostics, and procedural support. Its use in airway management-an essential aspect of anesthesiology and critical care-remains underexplored. This scoping review evaluates the current literature on augmented reality in airway management, with the aim of identifying its benefits, limitations, and future potential. A systematic literature search was conducted using PubMed, Embase, and IEEE databases, after PRISMA-ScR guidelines. Studies were included if they focused on augmented reality-assisted airway training or procedures and excluded if they centered on virtual reality or lacked procedural relevance. Ten studies met inclusion criteria, including 8 observational studies and 2 randomized controlled trials. Most utilized head-mounted displays to support simulation-based training or procedural guidance across pediatric and adult populations. Outcomes assessed included objective measures-such as intubation success, timing, and procedural accuracy-and subjective metrics like user confidence, perceived usability, and educational value. Results varied across studies. Several reported enhanced anatomical visualization, improved procedural success, and increased realism in training. One randomized controlled trial demonstrated higher intubation success rates and reduced procedure times when augmented reality-assisted video laryngoscopy was compared to standard methods. Another randomized controlled trial using a head-mounted display to deliver a procedural checklist found greater checklist adherence but also longer intubation times. Subjective feedback from participants noted challenges including device complexity, learning curve, and equipment limitations. Despite these encouraging findings, the current evidence base is limited by small sample sizes, variability in study design, and a lack of standardized evaluation protocols. Importantly, no study directly assessed the safety profile of augmented reality in airway management or its impact on patient-centered outcomes. In conclusion, augmented reality has the potential to improve anatomical understanding, procedural accuracy, and educational engagement in airway management. However, its integration into clinical practice is still in early stages. More rigorous, large-scale clinical trials are needed to determine its efficacy, optimize usability, and clarify its role in enhancing patient safety and provider training in anesthesiology and critical care.
引用
- Hart A, Zemel M, Henson L, et al. Augmented Reality in Airway Management: A Scoping Review. Anesth Analg. 2025. PMID: 40763084. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000007633
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。