硬膜外镇痛与硬膜穿刺硬膜外镇痛在分娩产妇中的比较:随机对照试验的荟萃分析
DPE镇痛略微缩短起效时间(平均差3.4分钟,95%CI 2.1-4.7,P<0.01,I²=97%;中等确定性),并减少单侧阻滞、运动阻滞、改善骶部覆盖、提高充分镇痛率。但部分结局异质性高,需谨慎解读。
要点
- DPE分娩镇痛较传统硬膜外镇痛起效稍快(平均差3.4分钟),但临床意义有限。
- DPE可减少单侧阻滞和运动阻滞,改善骶部覆盖,提高充分镇痛率。
- 剖宫产/器械阴道分娩、额外剂量及低血压方面无统计学差异。
核心结论
- DPE分娩镇痛较传统硬膜外镇痛起效稍快,并减少运动阻滞和单侧阻滞的发生率。
- 部分结局异质性高,可能源于临床和给药方案差异,需谨慎解读。
- 尽管DPE起效快的临床相关性可能不大,但结合次要结局的获益,支持使用DPE而非传统硬膜外镇痛。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型:随机对照试验的荟萃分析。
- 统计方法:采用逆方差随机效应模型合并结果,计算95%预测区间;使用GRADE评估证据确定性,并根据局麻药类型进行亚组分析。
- 主要结局:镇痛起效时间;次要结局包括单侧阻滞、运动阻滞、骶部遗漏、充分镇痛、剖宫产/器械阴道分娩、额外剂量和低血压。
主要发现
- DPE分娩镇痛略微缩短起效时间(平均差3.4分钟,95%CI 2.1-4.7,P<0.01,I²=97%;中等确定性)。
- 所有具统计学显著性的结果均显示DPE镇痛的临床优势,包括更少的单侧阻滞、减少的运动阻滞、改善的骶部覆盖和更高的充分镇痛率。
- 起效时间、单侧阻滞和骶部遗漏的结局数据存在显著异质性。
- 剖宫产/器械阴道分娩、额外剂量和低血压的合并结果未达到统计学显著性。
- 许多结局的插补预测区间跨越零,进一步研究可能改变这些发现。
关键数值与推荐
- DPE较硬膜外镇痛起效时间平均差3.4分钟(95%CI 2.1-4.7,P<0.01,I²=97%;中等确定性)。
- DPE在单侧阻滞、运动阻滞、骶部覆盖和充分镇痛方面均显示临床优势。
- 剖宫产/器械阴道分娩、额外剂量和低血压无统计学显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 对于分娩产妇,DPE镇痛可作为传统硬膜外镇痛的替代选择,以加快起效并减少运动阻滞和单侧阻滞。
- 需注意部分结局异质性高,临床决策时应结合具体给药方案和患者情况。
- DPE起效快的临床相关性可能有限,应综合考虑次要结局的获益。
局限性
- 起效时间、单侧阻滞和骶部遗漏的结局数据存在显著异质性。
- 许多结局的插补预测区间跨越零,进一步研究可能改变这些发现。
- 异质性可能源于临床和给药方案的差异,需谨慎解读结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Epidural analgesia and dural puncture epidural (DPE) analgesia are widely used techniques for alleviating labour pain. This meta-analysis compared clinical outcomes between parturients receiving epidural analgesia vs DPE analgesia for labour pain. METHODS: Medical databases were searched to identify randomised controlled trials comparing epidural analgesia with DPE analgesia in labouring parturients published up to October 2024. Results were pooled using an inverse variance random-effects model, and 95% prediction intervals were calculated. Clinical outcomes were used as defined by individual trials. The primary outcome was time to onset of analgesia. Secondary outcomes were unilateral block, motor block, sacral sparing, adequate analgesia, Caesarean/operative vaginal delivery, additional doses, and hypotension. The certainty of evidence was assessed using Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation guidelines, and subgroup analyses were performed based on the types of local anaesthetics used. RESULTS: Eighteen trials involving 2144 parturients were included. DPE labour analgesia slightly reduced the time to onset (mean difference: 3.4 min, 95% confidence interval: 2.1-4.7, P<0.01, I2=97%; moderate certainty). All statistically significant results demonstrated clinical advantages for DPE analgesia, including fewer unilateral blocks, reduced motor block, improved sacral coverage, and higher rates of adequate analgesia. Substantial heterogeneity was observed in the outcome data for time to onset of analgesia, unilateral block, and sacral sparing. Pooled results for Caesarean/operative vaginal delivery, additional doses, and hypotension failed to achieve statistical significance. CONCLUSIONS: DPE labour analgesia offers a slightly faster onset and reduced incidence of motor and unilateral blocks compared with traditional epidural analgesia. However, high heterogeneity in some outcomes, likely attributable to clinical and dosing variability, requires cautious interpretation. Although the clinical relevance of the faster onset with DPE analgesia might be modest, when considered alongside its benefits in secondary outcomes it supports the use of DPE analgesia over traditional epidural analgesia. Imputed prediction intervals cross zero for many outcomes, and further studies might alter these findings. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: PROSPERO- CRD42024602115.
引用
- Singh PM, Monks DT, Bhat AD, et al. Epidural analgesia versus dural puncture epidural analgesia in labouring parturients: a meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. Br J Anaesth. 2025. PMID: 40121178. doi:10.1016/j.bja.2025.01.033
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。