文献速递气道管理术前评估与围术期医学

择期手术预期困难气道管理中的临床决策与过程并发症

Clinical Decision-Making and Process Complications During Anticipated Difficult Airway Management for Elective Surgery.
PubMed 文献 · Anesth Analg · 2024-12-17

该前瞻性观察研究纳入1245例择期非急诊手术成人患者,共1295次预期困难气道管理。所有插管最终成功,无因气道管理失败取消或推迟手术。清醒插管者首次成功率49%、30%需≥3次尝试、50%发生低氧血症;麻醉插管者首次成功率64%、20%需≥3次尝试、30%发生低氧血症。

要点

  • 所有预期困难气道管理最终插管成功,无因气道失败取消或推迟手术。
  • 清醒插管者气道困难指标更多,首次成功率49%,50%发生低氧血症。
  • 麻醉插管者首次成功率64%,20%需≥3次尝试,30%发生低氧血症。

核心结论

  • 所有患者气道管理均成功,过程并发症发生率高于常规气道管理。
  • 尽管困难气道风险高,87%患者仍在麻醉下插管,清醒与麻醉方式转换罕见。
  • 清醒插管者气道困难指标更多,提示临床医生将清醒插管保留给特别困难的气道。
  • 清醒插管者多次尝试、低氧血症和心血管不稳发生率高,提示清醒气道管理仍具挑战。
  • 首次麻醉插管失败且面罩通气困难者低氧血症风险特别高。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性观察研究,2009至2014年便利样本纳入1245例择期非急诊手术成人,共1295次预期困难气道管理。
  • 受训观察员记录气道管理决策及过程并发症。

主要发现

  • 1295次气道管理中166次(13%)为清醒插管。
  • 清醒插管者首次成功率49%,30%需≥3次尝试,4%需更换装置,50%发生低氧血症,29%发生心血管不稳。
  • 麻醉插管者(1129例)首次成功率64%,20%需≥3次尝试,11%需更换装置,30%发生低氧血症,20%发生心血管不稳。
  • 1例(0.08%)从麻醉方式转为清醒方式。
  • 首次麻醉插管失败且面罩通气困难者多次尝试风险67%,低氧血症风险100%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 清醒插管者首次成功率49%,30%需≥3次尝试,4%需更换装置,50%低氧血症,29%心血管不稳。
  • 麻醉插管者首次成功率64%,20%需≥3次尝试,11%需更换装置,30%低氧血症,20%心血管不稳。
  • 首次麻醉插管失败且面罩通气困难者多次尝试风险67%,低氧血症风险100%。

临床怎么用

  • 预期困难气道管理中应警惕多次尝试、低氧血症和心血管不稳的高发生率。
  • 清醒插管者气道困难指标更多,临床决策需权衡清醒与麻醉插管的风险。
  • 首次麻醉插管失败且面罩通气困难者应高度警惕低氧血症风险。

局限性

  • 便利样本,非随机抽样,可能存在选择偏倚。
  • 观察性研究,无法推断因果关系。
  • 研究时间为2009至2014年,临床实践可能已变化。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Difficult airway management (DAM) is a challenging aspect of anesthetic care. Although nearly all DAM episodes result in successful intubation, complications are common and clinical decision-making may be complex. In adults with anticipated DAM scheduled for nonemergent surgery, we prospectively observed clinical decisions made during DAM such as awake/sedated versus anesthetized, choice of initial and subsequent devices, case cancellation/postponement, conversions between awake and anesthetized approaches, and process complications such as multiple intubation/supraglottic airway (SGA) insertion attempts, difficult bag-mask ventilation (BMV), hypoxemia, and cardiovascular destabilization. METHODS: From 2009 to 2014, we prospectively observed 1295 episodes of anticipated DAM in a convenience sample of 1245 adults scheduled for nonemergent surgery. Trained observers recorded airway management decisions and process complications during DAM. We described clinical decisions made during DAM and outcomes including number of attempts, need for BMV, hypoxemia, and cardiovascular destabilization. RESULTS: No cases were canceled/postponed for airway management failure and all intubations were eventually successful. Of the 1295 episodes of airway management in our study cohort, 166 (13%) were intubated awake. Patients intubated awake had more difficult airway indicators than those intubated anesthetized, their first-pass success rate was 49%, 30% required ≥3 attempts, 4% required a device change, 50% experienced hypoxemia, and 29% experienced cardiovascular destabilization. Among the 1129 patients intubated while anesthetized, first-pass success rate was 64% and 20% required ≥3 attempts, 11% required a device change, hypoxemia occurred in 30%, and cardiovascular destabilization in 20%. One patient (0.08%) was converted from an anesthetized to an awake approach. Patients with a failed anesthetized intubation attempt and difficult BMV between attempts were at high risk for multiple attempts (67%) and hypoxemia (100%). CONCLUSIONS: Airway management was successful in all patients and the incidence of process complications was higher than in routine airway management. Despite a high risk of DAM, 87% of patients were intubated anesthetized and conversions between awake and anesthetized approaches were rare. That patients intubated awake had more difficult airway indicators implies that clinicians reserve awake intubation for particularly difficult airways. The high incidence of multiple attempts, hypoxemia, and cardiovascular destabilization in patients intubated awake suggests that awake airway management remains challenging. We found no clear pattern in device choices after a first failed attempt. Patients with a first failed anesthetized intubation attempt and difficult BMV were at particularly high risk for hypoxemia.

来源:Anesth Analg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Yang IT, Tung A, Flores KS, et al. Clinical Decision-Making and Process Complications During Anticipated Difficult Airway Management for Elective Surgery. Anesth Analg. 2024. PMID: 39689002. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000007049

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。