高角度视频喉镜刀片气管插管的掌握所需尝试次数:随机对照试验的子分析
该研究为随机对照试验的计划子分析,纳入223名熟悉直接喉镜和Macintosh视频喉镜但不熟悉高角度视频喉镜的临床医生,共实施4312次气管插管。采用累积和统计生成学习曲线,以首次插管成功率85%为可接受边界、70%为不可接受边界。结果显示60%的医生在约12次尝试后达到可接受成功率,提示掌握高角度视频喉镜约需12次尝试。
要点
- 熟悉直接喉镜的医生掌握高角度视频喉镜约需12次尝试。
- 首次插管失败率低,共72次失败,不同医生组间相当。
- 40%医生未达到可接受或不可接受成功率边界。
核心结论
- 熟悉直接喉镜但不熟悉高角度视频喉镜的医生,约12次尝试后可达到可接受的首插成功率。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验的计划子分析,纳入223名临床医生(25名顾问、35名注册护士麻醉师、36名学生注册护士麻醉师、46名研究员、81名住院医师),共4312次气管插管。
主要发现
- 每名医生插管中位数15次(IQR 8-25,范围1-77)。
- 首次插管失败共72次,总体失败率低,各医生组间相当。
- 133名(60%)医生越过可接受成功率边界,90名(40%)医生未越过可接受或不可接受边界。
- 越过可接受边界的医生学习所需尝试次数中位数12次(IQR 12-12,范围12-26)。
关键数值与推荐
- 首次插管成功率的可接受边界为85%,不可接受边界为70%。
临床怎么用
- 对于熟悉直接喉镜的医生,高角度视频喉镜培训可设定约12次插管尝试作为掌握目标。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The number of tracheal intubation attempts required to reach proficiency in videolaryngoscopy with hyperangulated blades is unknown. Understanding this training requirement might guide training for clinicians who perform laryngoscopy. We therefore performed a planned sub-analysis of a randomised controlled trial comparing tracheal intubation success with videolaryngoscopy vs. direct laryngoscopy to determine the number of tracheal intubations with a hyperangulated videolaryngoscope blade needed to provide an acceptable first-attempt success rate. METHODS: We included clinicians from a randomised controlled trial who were familiar with direct laryngoscopy and Macintosh-blade videolaryngoscopy but inexperienced with hyperangulated videolaryngoscopy. Cumulative sum statistics were used to generate learning curves with acceptable success rates of 85% and unacceptable success rates of 70% for the primary outcome of first-attempt tracheal intubation success. RESULTS: We included 223 clinicians (25 consultants; 35 certified registered nurse anaesthetists; 36 student registered nurse anaesthetists; 46 fellows; and 81 residents) who attempted tracheal intubation in 4312 procedures. The median (IQR [range]) number of tracheal intubations per clinician was 15 (8-25 [1-77]). First-attempt failure was low, with only 72 failed first attempts overall, and was comparable across clinician groups. In total, 133 (60%) clinicians crossed the acceptable success rate boundary while the remaining 90 (40%) clinicians crossed neither the acceptable nor unacceptable success rate boundaries. Among clinicians who crossed the acceptance boundary, the median (IQR [range]) number of attempts for learning was 12 (12-12 [12-26]). DISCUSSION: Clinicians experienced in tracheal intubation with direct laryngoscopy but unfamiliar with hyperangulated-blade videolaryngoscopy can achieve proficiency after approximately 12 attempts.
引用
- Ott S, Müller-Wirtz LM, Bustamante S, et al. Learning tracheal intubation with a hyperangulated videolaryngoscopy blade: sub-analysis of a randomised controlled trial. Anaesthesia. 2024. PMID: 39604038. doi:10.1111/anae.16491
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。