坦桑尼亚与刚果民主共和国短期手术任务中低资源医院麻醉相关 critical 事件观察研究
该观察性研究在刚果民主共和国3所医院和坦桑尼亚1所医院的6次手术任务中,纳入201例患者(192例可评估),由当地非医师麻醉提供者在麻醉医师监督下实施麻醉。结果显示54%患者发生至少1次麻醉相关 critical 事件,低氧血症最常见(29%),设备问题占24%,气道管理问题占23%,心动过缓占6%。
要点
- 低资源医院短期手术任务中麻醉相关 critical 事件发生率高,超半数患者至少发生1次。
- 低氧血症、设备故障和气道管理问题是主要 critical 事件类型。
- 多数 critical 事件需麻醉医师介入,提示当地团队应对能力有限。
核心结论
- 本研究低资源医院短期手术任务中麻醉相关 critical 事件发生率较高,但结果因多重局限不能推广至坦桑尼亚和刚果民主共和国所有医院。
研究设计与样本
- 观察性研究,在刚果民主共和国3所医院和坦桑尼亚1所医院的6次手术任务中收集数据,纳入所有计划手术患者,最终201例患者入组、192例完成评估,9例因方案不依从退出。
主要发现
- 192例可评估患者中104例(54%)发生至少1次 critical 事件,共计202次 critical 事件。
- 低氧血症最常见,29%患者(n=55)发生至少1次;设备问题(供氧和/或麻醉机故障)占24%(n=46);气道管理问题占23%(n=44);心动过缓占6%(n=12)。
- 超过60%的 critical 事件需要麻醉医师介入。
- 因缺乏监测,低血压和高血压未被记录。
关键数值与推荐
- 所有患者为ASA I级(62%,n=120)或ASA II级(38%,n=72)。
- 麻醉由当地非医师麻醉提供者(NPAP)在协会麻醉医师监督下使用当地资源实施。
- critical 事件从麻醉诱导至恢复室离室期间记录,包括心动过缓、低氧血症、气道管理失败和设备问题。
临床怎么用
- 在低资源医院开展短期手术任务时,应重点关注低氧血症、设备故障和气道管理问题的预防与应对。
- 需加强当地非医师麻醉提供者的培训与麻醉医师的现场监督,以提升患者安全。
局限性
- 结果因多重局限不能推广至坦桑尼亚和刚果民主共和国所有医院。
- 因缺乏监测,低血压和高血压未被记录。
- 9例患者因方案不依从退出评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Critical incidents and mortality related to anesthesia are more frequently observed in low- and middle-income countries in comparison to high-income countries. The difficulties linked to anesthesia in rural areas of the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) and Tanzania have limited documentation. The aim of this study was to comprehensively document anesthesia-related critical events that occurred during surgical missions organized by the nongovernmental organization 2 nd Chance in hospitals in DRC and Tanzania. METHODS: Data were collected during 6 surgical missions in 3 hospitals in the DRC and 1 in Tanzania. All scheduled surgery patients were included. Anesthesia was administered by a local Non-Physician Anesthesia Provider (NPAP), using local resources, under the supervision of an anesthesiologist from the association. The anesthesiologist reported critical events and collected data. Local teams managed critical events initially, with intervention by the anesthesiologist from 2 nd Chance on the local team's request, according to preestablished protocol or if the situation was considered dangerous. Critical incidents associated with anesthesia, including bradycardia, hypoxemia, airway management failure, and equipment problems, were documented from induction of anesthesia until discharge from the recovery room. RESULTS: We recruited 201 patients, of whom 192 were evaluated, with 9 patients dropping out due to protocol noncompliance. All patients were American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) I (62%; n = 120) or ASA II (38%; n = 72). Among them, 104 individuals (54%) experienced at least 1 critical event, totaling 202 critical events. Hypoxemia emerged as the most common event, affecting 29% of the patients (n = 55) with at least 1 episode. Equipment problems (oxygen supply and/or anesthesia machine failure) occurred in 24% of cases (n = 46), airway management issues in 23% (n = 44), and bradycardia in 6% (n = 12). Hypotension and hypertension were not documented due to the lack of monitoring. The majority of these events (over 60%) required intervention by the anesthesiologist. CONCLUSIONS: The occurrence of critical events related to anesthesia appears to be high in this study. Due to numerous limitations, these results cannot be generalized to all hospitals in Tanzania and the DRC. However, this study underscores the challenges faced by anesthesia teams, encompassing inadequate resources, equipment deficiencies, and varying levels of expertise among anesthesia personnel. The research further stresses the significance of addressing these challenges to enhance patient safety.
引用
- Ponthus S, Omari A, Tesha S, et al. Intraoperative Anesthesia-Related Critical Events in Low-Resource Hospitals During Short-Term Surgical Missions in Tanzania and Democratic Republic of the Congo: An Observational Study. Anesth Analg. 2024. PMID: 39466917. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000007317
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。