双人口头核对确认气管插管:实践变革评估
该研究在两家医院引入双人口头核对气管插管(一家采用一步法,另一家采用两步法),通过匿名在线问卷收集麻醉医师及助手的意见。结果显示多数操作者认为该核对可降低未识别食管插管风险,并改善沟通与团队协作,多数人计划未来所有插管继续使用。
要点
- 双人口头核对气管插管被多数操作者和助手认为可降低未识别食管插管风险。
- 该核对改善沟通与团队协作,助手感到更有发言权、团队层级更扁平且更受重视。
- 多数操作者和助手计划未来所有插管继续使用双人核对。
核心结论
- 双人口头核对气管插管对插管团队所有成员均可行且可接受。
研究设计与样本
- 在两家医院引入双人口头核对气管插管,一家采用一步法(确认持续呼出二氧化碳),另一家采用两步法(增加视频喉镜下确认气管导管通过声带)。
- 采用匿名在线问卷在变革前、中、后收集麻醉医师及其助手的意见。
主要发现
- 116/149(78%)操作者和70/72(97%)助手报告双人口头核对将降低未识别食管插管可能性。
- 118/149(79%)操作者认为核对改善沟通与团队协作。
- 69/72(96%)助手报告感到更有发言权提出担忧,53/72(74%)报告团队层级更扁平,64/72(89%)感到作为团队成员更受重视。
- 122/149(82%)操作者和68/72(94%)助手计划未来所有插管继续使用双人核对。
临床怎么用
- 在气管插管确认中可引入双人口头核对,由操作者与助手共同执行,以降低未识别食管插管风险。
- 可根据机构情况选择一步法或两步法双人核对流程。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Deaths from unrecognised oesophageal intubation continue despite national campaigns emphasising the importance of capnography to confirm tracheal intubation. A two-person verbal intubation check is recommended in consensus guidelines intended to prevent such deaths. This check can be performed by the intubator with their assistant, either as a one-step process (identification of sustained exhaled carbon dioxide) or as a two-step process (adding identification of the tracheal tube passing through the vocal cords during videolaryngoscopy). METHODS: In two hospitals we introduced two-person checking of tracheal intubation. In one hospital this involved the one-step process and in the other the two-step process. We used anonymous online questionnaires before, during, and after these changes to collect opinions from anaesthetists and their assistants regarding the feasibility and acceptability of these changes. RESULTS: Most intubators (116/149, 78%) and intubators' assistants (70/72, 97%) reported that the two-person verbal intubation check would reduce the likelihood of unrecognised oesophageal intubation. Benefits and lack of negative aspects were reported for both one-step and two-step two-person intubation checks in both centres. Intubators judged that the checks improved communication and teamwork (118/149, 79%); intubators' assistants reported feeling more empowered to voice concerns if needed (69/72, 96%), a flattened team hierarchy (53/72, 74%), and feeling more valued as team members (64/72, 89%). Most intubators (122/149, 82%) and intubators' assistants (68/72, 94%) planned to continue using the two-person intubation check for all future intubations. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that a two-person verbal intubation check is feasible and acceptable to all members of the intubating team.
引用
- Cloke T, Ross C, Joy P, et al. A two-person verbal check to confirm tracheal intubation: evaluation of practice changes to prevent unrecognised oesophageal intubation. Br J Anaesth. 2024. PMID: 39426919. doi:10.1016/j.bja.2024.09.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。