区域麻醉与疼痛医学系统综述及荟萃分析(第一部分):综述方案制定指南
本文为区域麻醉与疼痛医学领域的系统综述方案制定提供指导,聚焦医疗干预的系统综述(含或不含聚合数据荟萃分析)。文章描述了作者应在方案中预先指定、计划并记录的方法学要素,包括PICO框架、主要结局定义与优先级、检索策略、偏倚与证据质量评估、异质性来源及数据合成方法等。
要点
- 综述方案应预先明确PICO框架及临床问题、标题、范围与检索策略。
- 需定义并优先排序主要结局,明确研究纳入标准及信息来源与检索策略。
- 方案应记录偏倚风险、证据质量(确定性)与结果异质性的评估方法。
核心结论
- 系统综述作者应在开始综述前于方案中预先指定、计划并记录方法学要素,并提供足够细节使读者能自行开展研究。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为区域麻醉与疼痛医学领域的指南类文章,聚焦医疗干预的系统综述(含或不含聚合数据荟萃分析)的方案制定。
主要发现
- 文章描述并讨论了综述作者应在方案中预先指定的系统综述方法学要素,包括PICO框架及相关要素、主要结局定义与优先级、纳入标准、信息来源与检索策略、偏倚风险与证据质量评估、异质性评估、数据管理、效应估计统计构建及证据合成方法。
关键数值与推荐
- 作者应解释规划系统综述的理由,并描述PICO框架(参与者、干预、对照、结局)及构建临床问题、拟定标题、确定范围、设计检索策略、指定纳入标准及识别异质性来源的相关要素。
- 作者应定义并优先排序主要结局,定义选择研究的纳入标准,并记录信息来源与检索策略。
- 综述方案应记录评估偏倚风险、证据质量(确定性)及结果异质性的方法。
- 作者应描述关键数据元素的管理计划、估计干预效应的统计构建、证据合成与荟萃分析方法,以及荟萃分析可能无法进行的条件及实用解决方案。
临床怎么用
- 区域麻醉与疼痛医学领域的系统综述作者可参照本指南制定综述方案,确保方案预先指定关键方法学要素并记录充分细节。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Comprehensive resources exist on how to plan a systematic review and meta-analysis. The objective of this article is to provide guidance to authors preparing their systematic review protocol in the fields of regional anesthesia and pain medicine. The focus is on systematic reviews of healthcare interventions, with or without an aggregate data meta-analysis. We describe and discuss elements of the systematic review methodology that review authors should prespecify, plan, and document in their protocol before commencing the review. Importantly, authors should explain their rationale for planning their systematic review and describe the PICO framework-participants (P), interventions (I),comparators (C), outcomes (O)-and related elements central to constructing their clinical question, framing an informative review title, determining the scope of the review, designing the search strategy, specifying the eligibility criteria, and identifying potential sources of heterogeneity. We highlight the importance of authors defining and prioritizing the primary outcome, defining eligibility criteria for selecting studies, and documenting sources of information and search strategies. The review protocol should also document methods used to evaluate risk of bias, quality (certainty) of the evidence, and heterogeneity of results. Furthermore, the authors should describe their plans for managing key data elements, the statistical construct used to estimate the intervention effect, methods of evidence synthesis and meta-analysis, and conditions when meta-analysis may not be possible, including the provision of practical solutions. Authors should provide enough detail in their protocol so that the readers could conduct the study themselves.
引用
- Barrington MJ, D'Souza RS, Mascha EJ, et al. Systematic reviews and meta-analyses in regional anesthesia and pain medicine (Part I): guidelines for preparing the review protocol. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2024. PMID: 37945065. doi:10.1136/rapm-2023-104801
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。