欧洲四国围术期疼痛管理模式:差异、相似与未来方向的叙述性综述
该叙述性综述以Donabedian框架比较欧洲四国围术期疼痛管理的结构、过程与结局,发现急性疼痛服务结构各异且缺乏统一定义与标准,各国有方案而部分有指南,结局评估多限于疼痛强度,建议制定欧洲共同质量指标、指南与急性疼痛服务标准并统一培训。
要点
- 四国急性疼痛服务结构不同,缺乏统一定义与照护标准。
- 结局评估多仅测疼痛强度,疼痛相关身体功能评估未充分实施。
- 建议制定欧洲共同质量指标、围术期疼痛管理指南与急性疼痛服务标准。
核心结论
- 四国围术期疼痛管理存在诸多相似、差异与空白,需通过共同质量指标、欧洲指南与急性疼痛服务标准推进改进。
研究设计与样本
- 叙述性综述,以Donabedian框架为指导,描述并比较四个欧洲国家医疗体系围术期疼痛管理的结构、过程与结局。
主要发现
- 四国急性疼痛服务结构不同,无统一定义与照护标准。
- 所有国家已实施方案,部分国家有指南。
- 若评估结局,主要为疼痛强度;疼痛更剧烈的患者常见风险因素包括术前疼痛、术前阿片摄入、女性与年轻年龄。
- 超出疼痛强度的结局评估(如疼痛相关身体功能)目前未充分实施。
关键数值与推荐
- 建议制定共同质量指标、欧洲围术期疼痛管理指南(如针对严重疼痛高风险患者及其他结局参数)与急性疼痛服务共同标准。
- 建议在欧洲统一普通与专科人员教育,例如使用欧洲疼痛联合会(EFIC)课程。
临床怎么用
- 临床可参照风险因素(术前疼痛、术前阿片摄入、女性、年轻年龄)识别严重疼痛高风险患者。
- 除疼痛强度外,应关注疼痛相关身体功能等结局以支持早期康复。
局限性
- 原文未报告
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
There is general agreement that acute pain management is an important component of perioperative medicine. However, there is no consensus on the best model of care for perioperative pain management, mainly because evidence is missing in many aspects. Comparing the similarities and differences between countries might reveal some insights into different organisational models and how they work. Here, we performed a narrative review to describe and compare the structures, processes and outcomes of perioperative pain management in the healthcare systems of four European countries using Donabedian's framework as a guide. Our comparison revealed many similarities, differences and gaps. Different structures of acute pain services in the four countries with no common definition and standards of care were found. Protocols have been implemented in all countries and guidelines in some. If outcome is assessed, it is mainly pain intensity, and many patients experiencing more intense pain than others have common risk factors (e.g. preoperative pain, preoperative opioid intake, female sex and young age). Outcome assessment beyond pain intensity (such as pain-related physical function, which is important for early rehabilitation and recovery) is currently not well implemented. Developing common quality indicators, a European guideline for perioperative pain management (e.g. for patients at high risk for experiencing severe pain and other outcome parameters) and common criteria for acute pain services might pave the way forward for improving acute pain management in Europe. Finally, the education of general and specialist staff should be aligned in Europe, for example, by using the curricula of the European Pain Federation (EFIC).
引用
- van den Heuvel SA, van Boekel RL, Cox FJ, et al. Perioperative pain management models in four European countries: A narrative review of differences, similarities and future directions. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 2023. PMID: 37889549. doi:10.1097/EJA.0000000000001919
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。