麻醉学医师科学家培养管道:现状与未来增长建议
2015至2020年麻醉学系NIH总经费和K系列导师制培训资助数量均增长72%,并提出五项战略建议以扩大和多样化麻醉学医师科学家管道。
要点
- 2015至2020年麻醉学系NIH经费和K系列资助数量均增长72%。
- 建议统一学术麻醉基金会和学会的多元项目以扩大研究管道。
核心结论
- 麻醉学医师科学家管道在规模与多样性上仍落后于多数专科,但NIH经费与K系列资助近年显著增长,需采取战略建议以持续扩大和多样化管道。
研究设计与样本
- 麻醉研究委员会工作组分析美国医学院协会和国家住院医师匹配项目2009至2019年数据,比较11个专科的研究型住院医师多样性和数量。
- 开展两项调查评估麻醉学系研究文化,并从NIH RePORTER和Blue Ridge Medical Institute收集NIH资助信息。
主要发现
- 麻醉学在女性进入住院医师比例上排名第8位,在自我认定为医学界 underrepresented 群体比例上排名第4位。
- 2015至2020年间,授予麻醉学系的NIH总经费和授予麻醉学医师科学家的NIH K系列导师制培训资助(如K08和K23)数量均增长72%。
关键数值与推荐
- 研究型住院医师定义为除MD外拥有高级学位(硕士或博士)或住院医师培训前发表至少3篇研究论文。
- 建议制定策略增加研究密集型麻醉学系数量。
- 建议统一学术麻醉基金会和学会中旨在促研究发展的多元项目。
- 建议调整美国麻醉医师学会成功指标,纳入拥有院外研究支持的麻醉学医师科学家数量。
- 建议增加FAER和IARS的导师制奖励数量,并支持在MSTP学生年会和美国医师科学家协会年会及机构MSTP项目中代表麻醉学专业。
临床怎么用
- 麻醉科可参照建议加强研究文化建设,鼓励住院医师参与科研并申请K系列资助。
- 学术麻醉学系应关注研究型住院医师的招募和多样性,利用FAER和IARS导师制奖励。
- 科室成功指标可纳入拥有院外研究支持的医师科学家数量,以促进管道建设。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The limited number and diversity of resident physicians pursuing careers as physician-scientists in medicine has been a concern for many decades. The Anesthesia Research Council aimed to address the status of the anesthesiology physician-scientist pipeline, benchmarked against other medical specialties, and to develop strategic recommendations to sustain and expand the number and diversity of anesthesiology physician-scientists. The working group analyzed data from the Association of American Medical Colleges and the National Resident Matching Program to characterize the diversity and number of research-oriented residents from US and international allopathic medical schools entering 11 medical specialties from 2009 to 2019. Two surveys were developed to assess the research culture of anesthesiology departments. National Institutes of Health (NIH) funding information awarded to anesthesiology physician-scientists and departments was collected from NIH RePORTER and the Blue Ridge Medical Institute. Anesthesiology ranked eighth to tenth place of 11 medical specialties in the percent of "research-oriented" entering residents, defined as those with advanced degrees (Master's or PhDs) in addition to the MD degree or having published at least 3 research publications before residency. Anesthesiology ranked eighth of 11 specialties in the percent of entering residents who were women but ranked fourth of 11 specialties in the percent of entering residents who self-identified as belonging to an underrepresented group in medicine. There has been a 72% increase in both the total NIH funding awarded to anesthesiology departments and the number of NIH K-series mentored training grants (eg, K08 and K23) awarded to anesthesiology physician-scientists between 2015 and 2020. Recommendations for expanding the size and diversity of the anesthesiology physician-scientist pipeline included (1) developing strategies to increase the number of research intensive anesthesiology departments; (2) unifying the diverse programs among academic anesthesiology foundations and societies that seek to grow research in the specialty; (3) adjusting American Society of Anesthesiologists metrics of success to include the number of anesthesiology physician-scientists with extramural research support; (4) increasing the number of mentored awards from Foundation of Anesthesia Education and Research (FAER) and International Anesthesia Research Society (IARS); (5) supporting an organized and concerted effort to inform research-oriented medical students of the diverse research opportunities within anesthesiology should include the specialty being represented at the annual meetings of Medical Scientist Training Program (MSTP) students and the American Physician Scientist Association, as well as in institutional MSTP programs. The medical specialty of anesthesiology is defined by new discoveries and contributions to perioperative medicine which will only be sustained by a robust pipeline of anesthesiology physician-scientists.
引用
- Emala CW, Tawfik VL, Lane-Fall MB, et al. The Anesthesiology Physician-Scientist Pipeline: Current Status and Recommendations for Future Growth-An Initiative of the Anesthesia Research Council. Anesth Analg. 2023. PMID: 37712462. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000006520
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。