文献速递术前评估与围术期医学疼痛医学

正反辩论:所有全麻是否都应采用靶控丙泊酚输注并以客观麻醉深度监测指导?

Pro-Con Debate: Should All General Anesthesia Be Done Using Target-Controlled Propofol Infusion Guided by Objective Monitoring of Depth of Anesthesia?
PubMed 文献 · Anesth Analg · 2023-08-17

本文以正反辩论形式讨论是否所有全麻都应采用靶控丙泊酚输注并以客观麻醉深度监测指导。正方认为全静脉麻醉术后恶心更少、患者满意度更高,靶控输注(TCI)联合脑电监测可个体化药代-药效并减少职业与环境危害;反方指出挥发性麻醉药在缺血再灌注、严重炎症、药物短缺及无静脉通路诱导时可能更优。作者建议根据患者与环境权衡利弊选择。

要点

  • 正方称全静脉麻醉较挥发性麻醉术后恶心更少、满意度更高。
  • 正方称TCI联合脑电监测可建立个体化药代-药效 profile。
  • 反方称挥发性麻醉在缺血再灌注、严重炎症或药物短缺时可能更优。

核心结论

  • 作者不建议一刀切,应基于现有文献权衡两种技术的利弊,为每位患者个体化选择麻醉方式。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为Pro-Con辩论评论文章,围绕全麻是否应采用靶控丙泊酚输注联合客观麻醉深度监测展开正反论证。

主要发现

  • 正方指出全静脉麻醉较挥发性麻醉术后恶心更少、患者满意度更高。
  • 正方指出靶控输注(TCI)可借助药代动力学模型更好地滴定静脉麻醉。
  • 正方指出处理脑电监测(如双频谱指数监测)较仅评估心电图或血压等临床参数能更好地评估TCI麻醉效果。
  • 反方指出对于伴器官或组织缺血再灌注损伤及严重炎症的患者,挥发性麻醉药可能优于丙泊酚。
  • 反方指出药物突然短缺时挥发性麻醉药可克服手术室甚至重症监护室的使用限制。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议在定制麻醉方案时仔细考虑每种技术的优缺点以满⾜患者需求。
  • 在适当情况下,麻醉提供者被鼓励在选择两种技术时考虑麻醉药物行为的独特特征、患者报告和观察到的术后结局以及经济与环境因素。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

In this Pro-Con commentary article, we discuss whether all general anesthesia should be done using target-controlled propofol anesthesia guided by monitoring of depth of anesthesia. This is an ongoing debate since more than 25 years, representing a scientific, cultural as well as geographical divide in the anesthesia community. The Pro side argues that total intravenous anesthesia causes less postoperative nausea and higher patient satisfaction than anesthesia using volatile anesthetics. Target-controlled infusion (TCI) of anesthetic agents allows for better titration of intravenous anesthesia using pharmacokinetic models. Processed EEG monitors, such as bispectral index monitoring, allows for better assessing the effect of TCI anesthesia than solely assessment of clinical parameters, such as ECG or blood pressure. The combination of TCI propofol and objective depth of anesthesia monitoring allows creating a pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic profile for each patient. Finally, anesthesia using volatile anesthetics poses health risks for healthcare professionals and contributes to greenhouse effect. The Con side argues that for procedures accompanied with ischemia and reperfusion injury of an organ or tissue and for patients suffering from a severe inflammation' the use of volatile anesthetics might well have its advantages above propofol. In times of sudden shortage of drugs, volatile anesthetics can overcome the restriction in the operating theater or even on the intensive care unit, which is another advantage. Volatile anesthetics can be used for induction of anesthesia when IV access is impossible, end-tidal measurements of volatile anesthetic concentration allows confirmation that patients receive anesthetics. Taking environmental considerations into account, both propofol and volatile anesthetics bear certain harm to the environment, be it as waste product or as greenhouse gases. The authors therefore suggest to carefully considering advantages and disadvantages for each patient in its according environment. A well-balanced choice based on the available literature is recommended. The authors recommend careful consideration of advantages and disadvantages of each technique when tailoring an anesthetic to meet patient needs. Where appropriate, anesthesia providers are encouraged to account for unique features of anesthetic drug behavior, patient-reported and observed postoperative outcomes, and economic and environmental considerations when choosing any of the 2 described techniques.

来源:Anesth Analg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Schnider TW, Nieuwenhuijs-Moeke GJ, Beck-Schimmer B, et al. Pro-Con Debate: Should All General Anesthesia Be Done Using Target-Controlled Propofol Infusion Guided by Objective Monitoring of Depth of Anesthesia? Anesth Analg. 2023. PMID: 37590801. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000006293

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。