上肢区域麻醉对术后长期疼痛结局影响的系统综述
该系统综述评估择期上肢手术中区域麻醉相比全身麻醉是否降低术后>3个月疼痛强度。纳入14项研究(7项RCT和7项非随机研究),多数研究报告两组长期疼痛评分及次要结局相当,仅2项前瞻性观察研究报告臂丛麻醉后疼痛更轻且DASH评分更优。证据确定性为中至极低,结论认为上肢区域麻醉不太可能改变术后>3个月疼痛强度。
要点
- 上肢区域麻醉与全麻相比,术后>3个月疼痛评分无显著差异。
- 多数研究显示阿片处方、CRPS发生率、MWS和DASH评分两组相当。
- 证据确定性中至极低,非随机研究存在严重混杂偏倚风险。
核心结论
- 上肢区域麻醉相比全身麻醉不太可能改变术后>3个月疼痛强度。
- 多数研究显示长期疼痛及次要结局两组相当,仅2项前瞻性观察研究报告臂丛麻醉后疼痛更轻且DASH评分更优。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述纳入14项研究,包括7项随机对照试验(RCT)和7项非随机研究。
- 检索Embase、Medline ALL、Web of Science核心合集、Cochrane CENTRAL和Google Scholar数据库。
- 主要结局为术后>3个月疼痛数字评分或视觉模拟评分。
- 次要结局包括阿片处方填写、复杂区域疼痛综合征(CRPS)发生率、Mayo腕评分(MWS)和臂肩手功能障碍(DASH)问卷评分。
- 采用GRADE评估证据质量,RoB 2.0和ROBINS-I评估偏倚风险。
主要发现
- 7项使用主要结局的研究中6项(4项RCT,N=273;2项非随机研究,N=305)报告区域麻醉与全麻术后长期疼痛评分相当。
- 7项使用次要结局的研究中6项报告长期结局相当:阿片处方填写(2项回顾性队列研究[RCS],N=89,256)、CRPS发生率(1项RCT,N=301)、MWS(1项RCT和1项RCS,N=215)、DASH评分(1项RCT,N=36)。
- 全部7项RCT(N=778)和7项非随机研究中的5项(5项RCS,N=89,608)报告结局相当。
- 2项前瞻性观察研究(POSTs,共279例患者)报告臂丛麻醉后疼痛更轻且DASH评分更优,差异有统计学意义。
关键数值与推荐
- 全部14项研究提供中至极低确定性证据。
- 7项非随机研究中的5项(N=631)因混杂偏倚存在严重偏倚风险。
临床怎么用
- 基于现有证据,不应期望上肢区域麻醉能降低术后>3个月疼痛强度。
- 区域麻醉的选择应基于其他围术期获益而非长期疼痛预防。
局限性
- 纳入研究证据确定性为中至极低。
- 5项非随机研究(N=631)存在严重混杂偏倚风险。
- 仅2项前瞻性观察研究报告阳性结果,但样本量较小(共279例患者)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Chronic pain is a recognized complication of surgery, and it has been hypothesized that regional anesthesia might reduce the risk of development of chronic pain after upper extremity surgery. METHODS: A systematic literature review was performed to assess whether in patients undergoing elective upper extremity surgery (P), regional anesthesia (I), compared to general anesthesia (C), would result in lower long-term (>3 months) postoperative pain intensity (O). We included randomized and nonrandomized controlled trials (RCTs). Our primary outcome was numerical rating score or visual analogue scale for pain, at >3 months postoperatively. The Embase, Medline ALL, Web of Science Core Collections, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, and Google Scholar databases were searched for all reports assessing pain at >3 months after upper extremity surgery under general versus regional anesthesia. Secondary outcomes were: opioid prescription filling, complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) incidence, the Mayo Wrist Score (MWS), and scores on the Disability of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) questionnaire. Quality (or certainty) of evidence was evaluated using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE). Risk-of-bias was assessed using the Cochrane tool for randomized trials (RoB 2.0) and nonrandomized trials (ROBINS-I). RESULTS: This review included 14 studies, comprising 7 RCTs and 7 nonrandomized studies. Six of the 7 studies (4 RCTs, N = 273; 2 nonrandomized studies, N = 305) using a pain score, our primary outcome, report comparable long-term postoperative pain scores after regional and general anesthesia. Six of the 7 studies using our secondary outcomes report comparable long-term outcomes in terms of opioid prescription filling (2 retrospective cohort studies [RCSs], N = 89,256), CRPS incidence (1 RCT, N = 301), MWS (1 RCT and 1 RCS, N = 215), and DASH score (1 RCT, N = 36). Comparable outcomes were reported in all 7 RCTs (N = 778) and in 5 of the 7 nonrandomized studies, comprising 5 RCSs (N = 89,608). Two prospective observational studies (POSTs), comprising 279 patients, report a statistically significant difference in outcomes, with less pain and better DASH scores after brachial plexus anesthesia. All 14 studies provided moderate to very low certainty evidence, and there was a serious risk of bias due to confounding bias in 5 of the 7 nonrandomized studies (N = 631). CONCLUSIONS: The results of this review indicate that upper extremity regional anesthesia, compared to general anesthesia, is unlikely to change pain intensity at >3 months postoperatively.
引用
- Droog W, Walbeehm ET, Konijn JB, et al. A Systematic Review on Long-Term Postsurgical Pain Outcomes; What Is the Effect of Upper Extremity Regional Anesthesia? Anesth Analg. 2023. PMID: 37227939. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000006529
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。