公众对术后认知功能障碍的视角:定性主题分析
该研究对英国《卫报》2022年4月一篇文章下84条公开用户评论(来自67名唯一用户)进行归纳性定性主题分析,探讨公众对术后认知功能障碍(POCD)的看法。结果显示公众与专业界对POCD的理解存在错位:公众强调症状的主观与功能影响、认为全身麻醉(而非保留意识的麻醉技术)是原因,并报告医疗提供者准备与回应不足。
要点
- 公众更关注POCD症状对工作与日常功能的主观影响。
- 部分评论者认为全身麻醉而非保留意识的麻醉技术是POCD原因。
- 部分受POCD影响的患者与照护者感到被医疗提供者抛弃。
核心结论
- 专业界与公众对POCD的理解存在错位,公众强调症状的主观与功能影响及麻醉的作用。
研究设计与样本
- 对英国《卫报》2022年4月一篇文章下公开提交的网站用户评论进行归纳性定性主题分析。
- 共分析来自67名唯一用户的84条评论。
主要发现
- 用户评论主题包括功能影响的重要性,如「无法工作……连阅读都吃力」。
- 用户将症状归因于多种原因,尤其提及全身麻醉而非保留意识的麻醉技术,并称「副作用未被充分理解」。
- 用户反映医疗提供者准备与回应不足,称「如果事先被警告我会受益」。
- 部分受POCD影响的患者与照护者报告感到被医疗提供者抛弃。
临床怎么用
- 术前与老年患者讨论神经认知风险时可参考公众关注的功能影响与主观体验。
- 2018年发布的手术后神经认知障碍新命名纳入主观抱怨与功能下降,更贴近公众视角。
局限性
- 分析仅基于单一英国新闻网站文章的公开用户评论,样本为67名唯一用户。
- 评论为非 solicited 的公开留言,不能代表全部患者群体。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Postoperative cognitive dysfunction (POCD) is a concern after anaesthesia and surgery, but preoperative discussion of neurocognitive risks with older patients rarely occurs. Anecdotal experiences of POCD are common in the popular media and may inform patient perspectives. However, the degree of alignment between lay and scientific perspectives on POCD is not known. METHODS: We performed inductive qualitative thematic analysis on website user comments publicly submitted under an article entitled, 'The hidden long-term risks of surgery: "It gives people's brains a hard time"', published by the UK-based news source The Guardian in April 2022. RESULTS: We analysed 84 comments from 67 unique users. Themes that emerged from user comments included the importance of functional impact ('Couldn't work … even reading was a struggle'), attribution to a range of causes but particularly the use of general, rather than consciousness-preserving, anaesthesia techniques ('side effects aren't fully understood'), and inadequate preparation and response by healthcare providers ('I would have benefited by being warned'). CONCLUSIONS: There is misalignment between professional and lay understandings of POCD. Lay people emphasise subjective and functional impact of symptoms, and express beliefs about the role of anaesthetics in causing POCD. Some patients and caregivers affected by POCD report feeling abandoned by medical providers. In 2018, new nomenclature for postoperative neurocognitive disorders was published, which better aligns with lay perspectives by including subjective complaints and functional decline. Further studies based on newer definitions and public messaging may improve concordance between different understandings of this postoperative syndrome.
引用
- Li L, Dohan D, Smith AK, et al. 'It was a great brain, and I miss it': lay perspectives on postoperative cognitive dysfunction. Br J Anaesth. 2023. PMID: 36868965. doi:10.1016/j.bja.2023.02.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。