文献速递气道管理

利弊辩论:视频喉镜应成为气管插管的标准操作吗

Pro-Con Debate: Videolaryngoscopy Should Be Standard of Care for Tracheal Intubation.
PubMed 文献 · Anesth Analg · 2023-03-16

本文以正反辩论形式讨论视频喉镜(VL)是否应成为气管插管的标准操作。正方强调VL可提高首次插管成功率、降低插管失败与食管内插管风险,并利于困难气道患者;反方指出VL并非100%成功、存在并发症,且过度依赖可能削弱其他气道技术的熟练度,成本与设备配置亦是障碍。

要点

  • VL可提高首次插管成功率并降低插管失败与食管内插管风险
  • VL并非100%成功,失败时需备好后备气道管理方案
  • 过度依赖VL可能削弱其他气道技术的临床熟练度

核心结论

  • 有有力证据支持VL改善首次插管成功率、降低插管失败与食管内插管风险,并对困难气道患者有益,但VL并非无并发症且非100%成功。
  • 若将VL采纳为标准操作,气道管理者可能不再练习和保留其他在VL失败时可能需要的气道技术能力。
  • 成本是VL广泛实施的障碍,但相关成本正在趋于正常化,机构为每个插管地点配备VL及后备气道设备仍可能困难。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为Pro-Con评论文章,由Dr Aziz陈述VL应成为标准操作的观点,随后Dr Berkow对该主张提出质疑。

主要发现

  • 有有力证据表明VL提高首次插管成功率、降低插管失败风险与食管内插管风险,并在困难气道患者中具有益处。
  • VL并非无并发症,且不具备100%的成功率。
  • VL失败时,备有气道管理的后备计划很重要。

临床怎么用

  • 从直接喉镜(DL)向VL过渡可能改善气道管理结局,但提供者应认识到这一实践转变的获益与风险。
  • VL失败时应备有气道管理后备计划。
  • 若VL成为标准操作,需关注其他气道技术的练习与能力保留,以应对VL失败情况。

局限性

  • VL并非无并发症且不具备100%成功率。
  • 成本仍是广泛实施VL的障碍,机构为每个插管地点配备VL及后备气道设备可能困难。
  • 依赖VL可能削弱其他重要临床技能,而这些技能在需要时最为关键。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

In this Pro-Con commentary article, we discuss whether videolaryngoscopy (VL) should be the standard of care for tracheal intubation. Dr Aziz makes the case that VL should be the standard of care, while Dr Berkow follows with a challenge of that assertion. In this debate, we explore not only the various benefits of VL, but also its limitations. There is compelling evidence that VL improves first-pass success rates, reduces the risk of intubation failure and esophageal intubation, and has benefits in the difficult airway patient. But VL is not without complications and does not possess a 100% success rate. In the case of failure, it is important to have back-up plans for airway management. While transition of care from direct laryngoscopy (DL) to VL may result in improved airway management outcomes, the reliance on VL may degrade other important clinical skills when they are needed most. If VL is adapted as the standard of care, airway managers may no longer practice and retain competency in other airway techniques that may be required in the event of VL failure. While cost is a barrier to broad implementation of VL, those costs are normalizing. However, it may still be challenging for institutions to secure purchase of VL for every intubating location, as well as back-up airway devices. As airway management care increasingly transitions from DL to VL, providers should be aware of the benefits and risks to this practice change.

来源:Anesth Analg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Aziz MF, Berkow L. Pro-Con Debate: Videolaryngoscopy Should Be Standard of Care for Tracheal Intubation. Anesth Analg. 2023. PMID: 36928154. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000006252

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。