五种商业麻醉深度监测仪对相同脑电信号给出不一致的临床建议
该研究选取52段显示麻醉减浅(类似苏醒期)的术中脑电信号,分别用BIS、Entropy-SE、Narcotrend、qCON和Sedline五种监测仪分析。仅31%的病例五种监测仪结论一致,52%至少有一种监测仪提示催眠不足,31%至少有一种提示催眠过深,凸显个体化脑电解读的必要性。
要点
- 相同脑电信号下仅31%病例五种监测仪建议一致
- 52%病例至少一种监测仪提示催眠不足
- 31%病例至少一种监测仪提示催眠过深
核心结论
- 三分之二的病例在相同脑电数据下监测仪给出不一致建议,强调个体化脑电解读是必备临床技能。
研究设计与样本
- 研究对52段显示麻醉减浅(类似苏醒期)的术中脑电信号,分别用BIS、Entropy-SE、Narcotrend、qCON和Sedline五种商业监测仪分析。
主要发现
- 52例中27例(52%)至少有一种监测仪警告催眠可能不足(指数高于范围)。
- 52例中16例(31%)至少有一种监测仪提示催眠过深(指数低于临床范围)。
- 52例中仅16例(31%)五种监测仪结论一致。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生不应仅依赖监测仪指数和厂家推荐范围进行麻醉滴定决策。
- 应重视个体化脑电解读能力,结合脑电波形综合判断麻醉深度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: 'Depth of anaesthesia' monitors claim to measure hypnotic depth during general anaesthesia from the EEG, and clinicians could reasonably expect agreement between monitors if presented with the same EEG signal. We took 52 EEG signals showing intraoperative patterns of diminished anaesthesia, similar to those that occur during emergence (after surgery) and subjected them to analysis by five commercially available monitors. METHODS: We compared five monitors (BIS, Entropy-SE, Narcotrend, qCON, and Sedline) to see if index values remained within, or moved out of, each monitors' recommended index range for general anaesthesia for at least 2 min during a period of supposed lighter anaesthesia, as observed by changes in the EEG spectrogram obtained in a previous study. RESULTS: Of the 52 cases, 27 (52%) had at least one monitor warning of potentially inadequate hypnosis (index above range) and 16 of the 52 cases (31%) had at least one monitor signifying excessive hypnotic depth (index below clinical range). Of the 52 cases, only 16 (31%) showed concordance between all five monitors. Nineteen cases (36%) had one monitor discordant compared with the remaining four, and 17 cases (33%) had two monitors in disagreement with the remaining three. CONCLUSIONS: Many clinical providers still rely on index values and manufacturer's recommended ranges for titration decision making. That two-thirds of cases showed discordant recommendations given identical EEG data, and that one-third signified excessive hypnotic depth where the EEG would suggest a lighter hypnotic state, emphasizes the importance of personalised EEG interpretation as an essential clinical skill.
引用
- Hight D, Kreuzer M, Ugen G, et al. Five commercial 'depth of anaesthesia' monitors provide discordant clinical recommendations in response to identical emergence-like EEG signals. Br J Anaesth. 2023. PMID: 36894408. doi:10.1016/j.bja.2022.12.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。