虚拟现实比较颧上入路与两种颧下入路至翼腭窝的可行性与安全性
该研究利用3D虚拟现实分析100例脑动脉CT血管造影,比较颧上入路与两种颧下入路至翼腭窝的可行性与安全性。颧上入路可行性96.5%且全部安全,后颧下入路全部可行且73.5%安全,前颧下入路全部可行但仅38%安全。上颌动脉穿刺风险前颧下入路为14.7%±26.4%,后颧下入路为7.5%±17.2%。
要点
- 颧上入路最安全但可行性96.5%,非全部可行。
- 后颧下入路全部可行,针尖位于髁突前方时主要安全。
- 前颧下入路全部可行但安全性最低,即使最佳进针点。
核心结论
- 颧上入路被证明最安全,但并非总是可行。
- 后颧下入路总是可行,且当进针点恰在髁突前方时主要安全。
- 前颧下入路总是可行,但即使最佳进针点位于冠突前方,安全性也最低。
研究设计与样本
- 研究分析了100例脑动脉诊断性CT血管造影,使用3D虚拟现实技术。
- 每种入路均以翼上颌裂内一目标点及一系列最外侧边缘轨迹确定。
- 主要结局为各入路的可行性与安全性,次要结局为确定上颌动脉位置以识别最安全进针点。
主要发现
- 颧上入路可行性为96.5%,两种颧下入路可行性均为100%。
- 颧上入路安全性为100%,后颧下入路为73.5%,前颧下入路为38%。
- 前颧下入路上颌动脉穿刺风险为14.7%±26.4%,后颧下入路为7.5%±17.2%。
- 两种颧下入路的最安全进针点均位于上外侧象限。
临床怎么用
- 选择翼腭窝注射入路时,颧上入路安全性最高但需考虑可行性。
- 后颧下入路可作为可行且主要安全的备选,进针点应位于髁突前方。
- 前颧下入路虽可行但安全性最低,应谨慎使用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Injections of local anesthetics into pterygopalatine fossa gained popularity for treating acute and chronic facial pain and headaches. Injury of maxillary artery during pterygopalatine fossa injection can result in pseudoaneurysm formation or acute bleeding. We aimed to identify the optimal approach into pterygopalatine fossa by comparing feasibility and safety of suprazygomatic and two infrazygomatic approaches. METHODS: We analyzed 100 diagnostic CT angiographies of cerebral arteries using 3D virtual reality. Each approach was determined as a target point in pterygomaxillary fissure and an array of outermost edges trajectories leading to it. The primary outcomes were feasibility and safety for each approach. The secondary outcome was the determination of maxillary artery position for each approach to identify the safest needle entry point. RESULTS: Suprazygomatic approach was feasible in 96.5% of cases, while both infrazygomatic approaches were feasible in all cases. Suprazygomatic approach proved safe in all cases, posterior infrazygomatic in 73.5%, and anterior infrazygomatic in 38%. The risk of maxillary artery puncture in anterior infrazygomatic approach was 14.7%±26.4% compared to 7.5%±17.2%. in posterior infrazygomatic with the safest needle entry point in the upper-lateral quadrant in both approaches. CONCLUSION: The suprazygomatic approach proved to be the safest, however not always feasible. The posterior infrazygomatic approach was always feasible and predominantly safe if the needle entry point was just anterior to the condylar process. The anterior infrazygomatic approach was always feasible, however least safe even with an optimal needle entry point just anterior to the coronoid process.
引用
- Jerman A, Umek N, Cvetko E, et al. Comparison of the feasibility and safety of infrazygomatic and suprazygomatic approaches to pterygopalatine fossa using virtual reality. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2023. PMID: 36657956. doi:10.1136/rapm-2022-104068
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。