引用撤稿文献:区域麻醉领域的警示
该研究通过 Scopus 数据库分析某麻醉科医生 2022 年多篇撤稿论文的被引情况,检索到 121 篇引用其工作的文章,其中 31 篇在撤稿通知后仍引用撤稿论文,共涉及 42 篇撤稿研究,表明区域麻醉文献中引用撤稿工作仍较常见。
要点
- 撤稿后引用现象在区域麻醉文献中依然常见。
- 多数撤稿引用出现在讨论部分,其次为引言。
- 无稿件使用有缺陷数据计算样本量。
核心结论
- 在区域麻醉文献中,引用撤稿工作的现象仍然常见。
研究设计与样本
- 利用 Scopus 数据库检索引用某麻醉科医生(2022 年多篇撤稿)工作的文章,分析撤稿通知后仍引用撤稿论文的文献。
主要发现
- 共检索到 121 篇引用该研究者工作的文章,其中 31 篇在撤稿通知后发表并引用了 42 篇撤稿论文。
- 没有稿件使用有缺陷数据计算样本量。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生和研究者引用文献时应核查撤稿状态,避免引用已撤稿研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Inappropriate citation of retracted literature is a common problem in the general medical literature. In 2020, more than 2300 articles were retracted, a dramatic increase from 38 in 2000. By exploring a contemporary series of retractions by one research group, we aimed to evaluate if citations of retracted articles is occurring in the area of regional anesthesiology. METHODS: Using the Scopus database, we examined the full text of all the articles citing research articles coauthored by an anesthesiologist who had multiple articles retracted in 2022. After excluding the research articles citing non-retracted articles authored by the above mentioned anesthesiologist, we included in our analysis all the articles containing a retracted citation and published after the retraction notice. RESULTS: The search was performed on October 30, 2022, retrieving a total of 121 articles citing the researcher's work. Among the retrieved articles, 53 correctly cited non-retracted research and 37 were published before the retraction notice. Among the 31 remaining articles, 42 retracted research papers were cited. Twenty-five of the retracted articles were cited in the Discussion section of the manuscripts, 15 in the Introduction section, 1 in the Methods section (description of a technique), and one was cited in a review. No manuscript used the flawed data to calculate the sample size. DISCUSSION: In this contemporary example from the regional anesthesia literature, we identified that citation of retracted work remains a common phenomenon.
引用
- De Cassai A, Volpe F, Geraldini F, et al. Citing retracted literature: a word of caution. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2023. PMID: 36650029. doi:10.1136/rapm-2022-104177
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。