环状软骨与气管旁按压在麻醉诱导及视频喉镜下闭塞上食管的随机交叉研究
这项随机交叉研究在40例全麻成人患者中比较环状软骨按压与气管旁按压(各30 N)在视频喉镜下闭塞食管的效果。
要点
- 视频喉镜下环状软骨按压食管闭塞率100%,高于气管旁按压的58%
- 两种按压在麻醉肌松状态下均显著减小食管外径
- 气管旁按压下17/40例食管在视频喉镜时部分释放致闭塞失败
核心结论
- 以食管听诊器无法置入定义的上食管闭塞,在视频喉镜下环状软骨按压比气管旁按压更有效,尽管两者在麻醉肌松状态下均使超声所测食管外径减小。
研究设计与样本
- 随机交叉研究,纳入40例成人患者,麻醉诱导后先超声评估食管位置与直径,再在30 N环状软骨按压与气管旁按压下分别行视频喉镜检查,以食管听诊器能否置入判定食管闭塞。
主要发现
- 超声显示气管旁按压下被压缩的食管在视频喉镜时于17/40例(即闭塞失败者)部分释放。
关键数值与推荐
- 按压压力均为30 N。
- 食管闭塞判定标准:食管听诊器无法置入食管。
- 喉视野采用百分比声门开放评分系统评估。
临床怎么用
- 在视频喉镜插管时,若需按压闭塞食管以防反流误吸,环状软骨按压较气管旁按压更可能实现食管闭塞。
- 气管旁按压虽可减小食管外径,但视频喉镜操作时可能部分释放而致闭塞失败,需注意其局限性。
- 两种按压对最佳喉视野评分无显著影响,可结合临床情境选用。
局限性
- 原文摘要未报告研究局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Maneuvers for preventing passive regurgitation of gastric contents are applied to effectively occlude the esophagus throughout rapid sequence induction and intubation. The aim of this randomized, crossover study was to investigate the effectiveness of cricoid and paratracheal pressures in occluding the esophagus through induction of anesthesia and videolaryngoscopy. METHODS: After the induction of anesthesia in 40 adult patients, the location of the esophageal entrance relative to the glottis and location of the upper esophagus relative to the trachea at the low paratracheal region were assessed using an ultrasonography, and the outer diameter of the esophagus was measured on ultrasound before and during application of cricoid and paratracheal pressures of 30 N. Then, videolaryngoscopy was performed with the application of each pressure. During videolaryngoscopy, location of the esophageal entrance relative to the glottis under cricoid pressure was examined on the screen of videolaryngoscope, and the upper esophagus under paratracheal pressure was evaluated using ultrasound. The occlusion rate of the esophagus, and the best laryngeal view using the percentage of glottic opening scoring system were also assessed during videolaryngsocopy. Esophageal occlusion under each pressure was determined by inserting an esophageal stethoscope into the esophagus. If the esophageal stethoscope could not be advanced into the esophagus under the application of each pressure, the esophagus was regarded to be occluded. RESULTS: During videolaryngoscopy, esophagus was occluded in 40 of 40 (100%) patients with cricoid pressure and 23 of 40 (58%) patients with paratracheal pressure (difference, 42%; 95% confidence interval, 26-58; P < .001). Both cricoid and paratracheal pressures significantly decreased the diameter of the esophagus compared to no intervention in the anesthetized paralyzed state ( P < .001, respectively). Ultrasound revealed that the compressed esophagus by paratracheal pressure in the anesthetized paralyzed state was partially released during videolaryngoscopy in 17 of 40 patients, in whom esophageal occlusion was unsuccessful. The best laryngeal view was not significantly different among the no intervention, cricoid pressure, and paratracheal pressure (77 [29] % vs 79 [30] % vs 76 [31] %, respectively; P = .064). CONCLUSIONS: The occlusion of the upper esophagus defined by inability to pass an esophageal stethoscope was more effective with cricoid pressure than with paratracheal pressure during videolaryngoscopy, although both cricoid and paratracheal pressures reduced the diameter of the esophagus on ultrasound in an anesthetized paralyzed state.
引用
- Kim H, Chang JE, Won D, et al. Effectiveness of Cricoid and Paratracheal Pressures in Occluding the Upper Esophagus Through Induction of Anesthesia and Videolaryngoscopy: A Randomized, Crossover Study. Anesth Analg. 2022. PMID: 35913721. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000006154
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。