麻醉医师对产生气溶胶操作的实际做法与认知:一项混合方法研究
多数人知晓并支持英国指南,但个体与医院层面存在显著差异,如12%要求呼吸防护装备、52%在置入声门上气道装置时使用呼吸防护装备。受访者普遍感知呼吸防护装备降低效率、影响团队合作与沟通,但对风险平衡看法分化。
要点
- 多数麻醉医师知晓并支持英国指南,但个体和医院层面存在明显偏离。
- 12%受访者要求呼吸防护装备,20%所在医院要求SARS-CoV-2阴性患者插管时佩戴。
- 52%在置入声门上气道装置时使用呼吸防护装备。
核心结论
- 麻醉医师对产生气溶胶操作的认知与做法正在演变,多数支持指南但存在显著实践差异。
- 研究信息可用于促进修订指南的成功采纳。
研究设计与样本
- 定量分析333份问卷回复,并对18名目的抽样受访者进行访谈及主题分析。
- 样本广泛代表英国麻醉 workforce。
主要发现
- 40名(12%)受访者要求呼吸防护装备,63名(20%)所在医院要求SARS-CoV-2阴性患者插管时佩戴。
- 173名(52%)在置入声门上气道装置时佩戴呼吸防护装备。
- 305名(92%)感知效率降低,376名(83%)感知团队合作负面 impact,201名(64%)担忧环境影响,255名(77%)报告沟通显著问题。
- 269名(63%)认为呼吸防护装备的负面影响与SARS-CoV-2传播风险平衡适当。
- 对逐步取消呼吸防护装备的态度分化;感知COVID-19风险与降级担忧相关(Spearman R=0.36,p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 应关注个体与医院层面偏离指南的实践差异,促进循证指南的一致落实。
- 制定策略时需考虑呼吸防护装备对效率、团队合作、沟通和环境的影响。
- 针对态度分化,可通过沟通感知风险与降级担忧的相关性来引导指南修订采纳。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The evidence base surrounding the transmission risk of 'aerosol-generating procedures' has evolved primarily through quantification of aerosol concentrations during clinical practice. Consequently, infection prevention and control guidelines are undergoing continual reassessment. This mixed-methods study aimed to explore the perceptions of practicing anaesthetists regarding aerosol-generating procedures. An online survey was distributed to the Membership Engagement Group of the Royal College of Anaesthetists during November 2021. The survey included five clinical scenarios to identify the personal approach of respondents to precautions, their hospital's policies and the associated impact on healthcare provision. A purposive sample was selected for interviews to explore the reasoning behind their perceptions and behaviours in greater depth. A total of 333 survey responses were analysed quantitatively. Transcripts from 18 interviews were coded and analysed thematically. The sample was broadly representative of the UK anaesthetic workforce. Most respondents and their hospitals were aware of, supported and adhered to UK guidance. However, there were examples of substantial divergence from these guidelines at both individual and hospital level. For example, 40 (12%) requested respiratory protective equipment and 63 (20%) worked in hospitals that required it to be worn whilst performing tracheal intubation in SARS-CoV-2 negative patients. Additionally, 173 (52%) wore respiratory protective equipment whilst inserting supraglottic airway devices. Regarding the use of respiratory protective equipment and fallow times in the operating theatre: 305 (92%) perceived reduced efficiency; 376 (83%) perceived a negative impact on teamworking; 201 (64%) were worried about environmental impact; and 255 (77%) reported significant problems with communication. However, 269 (63%) felt the negative impacts of respiratory protection equipment were appropriately balanced against the risks of SARS-CoV-2 transmission. Attitudes were polarised about the prospect of moving away from using respiratory protective equipment. Participants' perceived risk from COVID-19 correlated with concern regarding stepdown (Spearman's test, R = 0.36, p < 0.001). Attitudes towards aerosol-generating procedures and the need for respiratory protective equipment are evolving and this information can be used to inform strategies to facilitate successful adoption of revised guidelines.
引用
- Shrimpton AJ, Osborne CED, Brown JM, et al. Anaesthetists' current practice and perceptions of aerosol-generating procedures: a mixed-methods study. Anaesthesia. 2022. PMID: 35864419. doi:10.1111/anae.15803
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。