术后恶心呕吐相关系统评价与Meta分析摘要中的spin现象评估
本研究检索MEDLINE和Embase,纳入130篇关于术后恶心呕吐(PONV)治疗的系统评价与Meta分析,由两名研究者盲法重复评估摘要中九种最严重spin形式及AMSTAR-2质量。结果显示29.2%(38/130)的摘要存在spin,最常见为类型3(选择性报告或过度强调疗效结局);spin与AMSTAR-2评级相关,低质量和极低质量研究较高质量研究更少出现spin。
要点
- 29.2%的PONV系统评价摘要存在spin,最常见为过度强调疗效结局。
- 低质量(OR 0.24)和极低质量(OR 0.21)研究较高质量研究更少出现spin。
- Spin与 funding source 的关联无统计学显著性。
核心结论
- 超过29%的PONV系统评价与Meta分析摘要存在spin,需采取步骤提高摘要报告质量。
研究设计与样本
- 制定MEDLINE和Embase检索策略,系统检索PONV相关系统评价。
- 由两名研究者盲法、重复评估纳入研究的spin及AMSTAR-2评级,并重复提取研究特征。
- 初始检索返回3513项研究,最终130篇系统评价与Meta分析符合条件纳入数据提取。
主要发现
- 29.2%(38/130)的纳入系统评价摘要存在spin。
- 九种spin类型中识别出八种,类型3(选择性报告或过度强调疗效结局或有利于实验干预的分析)最常见。
- 低质量研究较高质量研究更少出现spin,OR 0.24(95%CI 0.07至0.88)。
- 极低质量研究较高质量研究更少出现spin,OR 0.21(95%CI 0.07至0.65)。
- 私人资助较无资助研究更可能出现spin,OR 2.81(95%CI 0.66至11.98),未提及资助较无资助OR 2.30(95%CI 0.61至8.70),均无统计学显著性。
临床怎么用
- 阅读PONV系统评价摘要时需警惕spin,尤其应关注疗效结局的报告是否被选择性强调。
- AMSTAR-2高质量评级并不排除摘要存在spin的可能,需结合全文审慎判断。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Spin - the beautification of study results to emphasise benefits or minimise harms - is a deceptive reporting strategy with the potential to affect clinical decision-making adversely. Few studies have investigated the extent of spin in systematic reviews. Here, we sought to address this gap by evaluating the presence of the nine most severe forms of spin in the abstracts of systematic reviews on treatments for postoperative nausea and vomiting (PONV). PONV has the potential to increase hospital costs and patient burden, adversely affecting outcomes. METHODS: We developed search strategies for MEDLINE and Embase to identify systematic reviews focused on PONV. Following title and abstract screening of the reviews identified during the initial search, those that met inclusion criteria were evaluated for the presence of spin and received a revised AMSTAR-2 (A Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews) appraisal by two investigators in a masked, duplicate manner. Study characteristics for each review were also extracted in duplicate. RESULTS: Our systematic search returned 3513 studies, of which 130 systematic reviews and meta-analyses were eligible for data extraction. We found that 29.2% of included systematic reviews contained spin (38/130). Eight of the nine types of spin were identified, with spin type 3 ('selective reporting of or overemphasis on efficacy outcomes or analysis favouring the beneficial effect of the experimental intervention') being the most common. Associations were found between spin and funding source. Spin was more likely in the abstracts of privately funded than nonfunded studies, odds ratio (OR) 2.81 [95% confidence interval (CI), 0.66 to 11.98]. In the abstracts of studies not mentioning funding spin was also more likely than in nonfunded studies, OR 2.30 (95% CI, 0.61 to 8.70). Neither of these results were statistically significant. Significance was found in the association between the presence of spin and AMSTAR-2 ratings: 'low' quality studies were less likely to contain spin than 'high' quality, OR 0.24 (95% CI, 0.07 to 0.88): 'critically low' studies were also less likely to contain spin than 'high' quality studies, OR 0.21 (95% CI, 0.07 to 0.65). There were no other associations between spin and the remaining extracted study characteristics or AMSTAR-2 ratings. CONCLUSION: Spin was present in greater than 29% of abstracts of systematic reviews and meta-analyses regarding PONV. Various stakeholders must take steps to improve the reporting quality of abstracts on PONV.
引用
- Bruns M, Manojkumar A, Ottwell R, et al. Evaluation of spin in the abstracts of systematic reviews and meta-analyses relating to postoperative nausea and vomiting. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 2022. PMID: 35796313. doi:10.1097/EJA.0000000000001709
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。