ACGME病例日志系统的共识驱动修订:小儿麻醉专科培训教育
本研究通过两阶段方法修订小儿麻醉专科培训的病例日志系统:首先由病例日志工作组基于文献提出新分类,经PAPDA会员投票批准后,纳入SPA毕业后医学教育工作组的全国性德尔菲过程。37名参与者经过三轮调查,以三分之二同意为阈值,最终建议将总病例最低数从240例增至300例(300-370),并新增分类及推荐最低数量。
要点
- 建议将小儿麻醉专科培训总病例最低数从240例提高至300例(范围300-370)。
- 参与者同意现有病例日志覆盖的病例类型正确,但要求过低(82.75%)。
- 德尔菲过程就新分类和最低标准达成广泛共识,支持将病例日志用于基于能力的评估。
核心结论
- 小儿麻醉病例日志系统仍需用于专科培训评估,但需要更新。
- 德尔菲过程为新分类和基准最低数量建立了广泛支持,以确保培训项目的稳健性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究分两阶段:病例日志工作组(10名项目主任)基于文献提出新分类,经PAPDA会员投票批准后,纳入SPA毕业后医学教育工作组的全国性德尔菲过程。
- 37名参与者参与德尔菲过程,经过三轮迭代调查,以三分之二同意为纳入阈值。
主要发现
- 德尔菲参与度高,共识在第二轮(共三轮)几乎完全达成。
- 参与者建议总病例最低数从240例增至300例(300-370)。
- 75.86%的参与者同意当前病例日志针对的病例类型正确,但82.75%认为要求过低。
- 85.19%的参与者同意病例日志系统和最低标准需要更新,96%同意应将其作为小儿麻醉专科培训基于能力评估的一部分。
- 参与者支持新分类并提供了推荐的最低数量。
关键数值与推荐
- 总病例最低数建议从240例增加至300例(范围300-370)。
- 德尔菲共识阈值:三分之二同意。
- 75.86%同意当前病例类型正确;82.75%认为要求过低;85.19%同意系统需更新;96%同意用于基于能力的评估。
临床怎么用
- 小儿麻醉专科培训项目应参考新分类和最低数量标准更新病例日志要求。
- 病例日志系统可用于基于能力的评估,以更好地准备独立临床实践。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Clinical experiences, quantified by case logs, are an integral part of pediatric anesthesiology fellowship programs. Accreditation of pediatric anesthesiology fellowships by the Accreditation Council of Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) and establishment of case log reporting occurred in 1997 and 2009, respectively. The specialty has evolved since then, but the case log system remains largely unchanged. The Pediatric Anesthesiology Program Directors Association (PAPDA) embarked on the development of an evidence-based case log proposal through the efforts of a case log task force (CLTF). This proposal was part of a larger consensus-building process of the Society for Pediatric Anesthesia (SPA) Task Force for Pediatric Anesthesiology Graduate Medical Education. The primary aim of case log revision was to propose an evidence-based, consensus-driven update to the pediatric anesthesiology case log system. METHODS: This study was executed in 2 phases. The CLTF, composed of 10 program directors representing diverse pediatric anesthesiology fellowship programs across the country, utilized evidence-based literature to develop proposed new categories. After an approval vote by PAPDA membership, this proposal was included in the nationally representative, stakeholder-based Delphi process executed by the SPA Task Force on Graduate Medical Education. Thirty-seven participants engaged in this Delphi process, during which iterative rounds of surveys were used to select elements of the old and newly proposed case logs to create a final revision of categories and minimums for updated case logs. The Delphi methodology was used, with a two-thirds agreement as the threshold for inclusion. RESULTS: Participation in the Delphi process was robust, and consensus was almost completely achieved by round 2 of 3 survey rounds. Participants suggested that total case minimums should increase from 240 to 300 (300-370). Participants agreed (75.86%) that the current case logs targeted the right types of cases, but requirements were too low (82.75%). They also agreed (85.19%) that the case log system and minimums deserved an update, and that this should be used as part of a competency-based assessment in pediatric anesthesia fellowships (96%). Participants supported new categories and provided recommended minimum numbers. CONCLUSIONS: The pediatric anesthesiology case log system continues to have a place in the assessment of fellowship programs, but it requires an update. This Delphi process established broad support for new categories and benchmarked minimums to ensure the robustness of fellowship programs and to better prepare the pediatric anesthesiology workforce of the future for independent clinical practice.
引用
- Ambardekar AP, Furukawa L, Eriksen W, et al. A Consensus-Driven Revision of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education Case Log System: Pediatric Anesthesiology Fellowship Education. Anesth Analg. 2023. PMID: 35773224. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000006129
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。