共识驱动的小儿麻醉学毕业后医学教育重新设计:德尔菲研究
小儿麻醉学毕业后教育自1997年ACGME认证后需演进。小儿麻醉学会成立工作组,采用基于利益相关者的全国代表性德尔菲法,37名小儿麻醉医师参与2020年8月至2021年7月的迭代调查,就现状、缺陷、需求和改进策略达成共识,提出8个非临床领域及新病例日志系统等建议。
要点
- 德尔菲法在评估当前培训和推荐未来方向方面达成了稳健共识。
- 利益相关者一致认为所有小儿麻醉学fellow应接受8个非临床领域的教育。
- 建议创建新病例日志系统并开发标准化形成性与总结性评估工具。
核心结论
- 德尔菲过程在评估当前培训和推荐小儿麻醉学毕业后教育未来方向方面达成了稳健共识。
研究设计与样本
- 小儿麻醉学会工作组执行了全国代表性、基于利益相关者的德尔菲过程,主题为「什么造就一名小儿麻醉医师?」。
- 37名人口学和地理分布多样的小儿麻醉医师参与了2020年8月至2021年7月的迭代开放式和封闭式调查。
主要发现
- 参与度高,共识在第二轮几乎完全达成。
- SWOT分析提示当前小儿麻醉学毕业后教育项目的优势与机会多于劣势与威胁。
- 利益相关者一致认为fellow入学时存在一些临床知识和操作差距,但毕业时临床差距较少。
关键数值与推荐
- 利益相关者就8个非临床领域及具体基本和基础知识或技能达成一致,这些应教授给所有小儿麻醉学fellow,无论职业计划如何。
- 8个领域包括:(1)患者安全,(2)质量改进,(3)沟通技能,(4)监督技能,(5)领导力,(6)医学教育,(7)研究基础,(8)实践管理。
- 利益相关者同意应创建新的病例日志系统以更好地反映现代小儿麻醉实践。
- 利益相关者进一步指出需要开发标准化和经过验证的形成性与总结性评估工具,作为基于能力体系的一部分。
临床怎么用
- 在小儿麻醉学fellow培训中纳入8个非临床领域的教育。
- 创建新病例日志系统以反映现代实践。
- 开发标准化和经过验证的形成性与总结性评估工具以支持基于能力的教育。
局限性
- 实施具体建议需要显著的科室、机构和全国组织支持。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Pediatric anesthesiology fellowship education has necessarily evolved since Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) accreditation in 1997. Advancements in perioperative and surgical practices, emerging roles in leadership, increasing mandates by accreditation and certification bodies, and progression toward competency-based education-among other things-have created pressure to enrich the current pediatric anesthesiology training system. The Society for Pediatric Anesthesia (SPA) formed a Task Force for Pediatric Anesthesiology Graduate Medical Education that included key leaders and subject matter experts from the society. A key element of the Task Force's charge was to identify curricular and evaluative enhancements for the fellowship program of the future. METHODS: The Task Force executed a nationally representative, stakeholder-based Delphi process centered around a fundamental theme: "What makes a pediatric anesthesiologist?" to build consensus among a demographically varied and broad group of anesthesiologists within the pediatric anesthesiology community. A total of 37 demographically and geographically varied pediatric anesthesiologists participated in iterative rounds of open- and close-ended survey work between August 2020 and July 2021 to build consensus on the current state, known deficiencies, anticipated needs, and strategies for enhancing national educational offerings and program requirements. RESULTS: Participation was robust, and consensus was almost completely achieved by round 2. This work generated a compelling Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) analysis that suggests more strengths and opportunities in the current Pediatric Anesthesiology Graduate Medical Education program than weaknesses or threats. Stakeholders agreed that while fellows matriculate with some clinical knowledge and procedural gaps, a few clinical gaps exist upon graduation. Stakeholders agreed on 8 nonclinical domains and specific fundamental and foundational knowledge or skills that should be taught to all pediatric anesthesiology fellows regardless of career plans. These domains include (1) patient safety, (2) quality improvement, (3) communication skills, (4) supervision skills, (5) leadership, (6) medical education, (7) research basics, and (8) practice management. They also agreed that a new case log system should be created to better reflect modern pediatric anesthesia practice. Stakeholders further identified the need for the development of standardized and validated formative and summative assessment tools as part of a competency-based system. Finally, stakeholders noted that significant departmental, institutional, and national organizational support will be necessary to implement the specific recommendations. CONCLUSIONS: A Delphi process achieved robust consensus in assessing current training and recommending future directions for pediatric anesthesiology graduate medical education.
引用
- Ambardekar AP, Eriksen W, Ferschl MB, et al. A Consensus-Driven Approach to Redesigning Graduate Medical Education: The Pediatric Anesthesiology Delphi Study. Anesth Analg. 2023. PMID: 35777829. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000006128
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。