BIS 麻醉深度算法开源重实现
该研究通过逆向工程解析 BIS A-2000 算法,用 12 例手术患者的 EEG 数据重实现为 ibis 和 openibis 算法。ibis 与原生 BIS 输出高度一致(r=0.9970),openibis 以 64 行可读代码达到 r=0.9395,揭示 BIS 评分主要依赖低γ波段而非双谱指数。
要点
- ibis 算法与原生 BIS A-2000 输出功能无法区分,r=0.9970。
- openibis 仅 64 行可读代码,与原生算法 r=0.9395。
- BIS 评分不依赖双谱指数,主要依赖低γ波段成分。
核心结论
- openibis 算法明确了 BIS 最重要信号成分依赖低γ波段及其加权方式。
- BIS 评分似乎完全不依赖双谱指数,与既往权威综述观点矛盾。
研究设计与样本
- 获取 12 例骨科、普外、血管及神经外科手术患者诱导、维持和苏醒期 EEG 数据。
- 用 EEG 数据触发 BIS Engine 各部分的受控执行,重实现为 ibis 算法。
- ibis 经简化和生理清晰化改写为完全白盒的 openibis 算法。
主要发现
- ibis 与原生 BIS A-2000 输出 r=0.9970(95%CI 0.9970-0.9971),Bland-Altman 平均差 -0.25±2.6(0-100 无量纲量表)。
- openibis 与原生算法输出 r=0.9395(95%CI 0.9390-0.9400),Bland-Altman 2.62±12.0。
- ibis 精度超过以往任何 BIS 算法重实现尝试。
临床怎么用
- 为麻醉深度评分提供生理基础,便于理解评分偏离的临床预后意义。
- 可用于闭环控制研究及避免术后认知功能障碍或幼年神经损伤的研究。
- 支持与其他动物模型比较以开展机制研究。
局限性
- EEG 数据仅来自 12 例患者。
- openibis 与原生算法一致性(r=0.9395)低于 ibis(r=0.9970)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: BIS (a brand of processed electroencephalogram [EEG] depth-of-anesthesia monitor) scores have become interwoven into clinical anesthesia care and research. Yet, the algorithms used by such monitors remain proprietary. We do not actually know what we are measuring. If we knew, we could better understand the clinical prognostic significance of deviations in the score and make greater research advances in closed-loop control or avoiding postoperative cognitive dysfunction or juvenile neurological injury. In previous work, an A-2000 BIS monitor was forensically disassembled and its algorithms (the BIS Engine) retrieved as machine code. Development of an emulator allowed BIS scores to be calculated from arbitrary EEG data for the first time. We now address the fundamental questions of how these algorithms function and what they represent physiologically. METHODS: EEG data were obtained during induction, maintenance, and emergence from 12 patients receiving customary anesthetic management for orthopedic, general, vascular, and neurosurgical procedures. These data were used to trigger the closely monitored execution of the various parts of the BIS Engine, allowing it to be reimplemented in a high-level language as an algorithm entitled ibis. Ibis was then rewritten for concision and physiological clarity to produce a novel completely clear-box depth-of-anesthesia algorithm titled openibis . RESULTS: The output of the ibis algorithm is functionally indistinguishable from the native BIS A-2000, with r = 0.9970 (0.9970-0.9971) and Bland-Altman mean difference between methods of -0.25 ± 2.6 on a unitless 0 to 100 depth-of-anesthesia scale. This precision exceeds the performance of any earlier attempt to reimplement the function of the BIS algorithms. The openibis algorithm also matches the output of the native algorithm very closely ( r = 0.9395 [0.9390-0.9400], Bland-Altman 2.62 ± 12.0) in only 64 lines of readable code whose function can be unambiguously related to observable features in the EEG signal. The operation of the openibis algorithm is described in an intuitive, graphical form. CONCLUSIONS: The openibis algorithm finally provides definitive answers about the BIS: the reliance of the most important signal components on the low-gamma waveband and how these components are weighted against each other. Reverse engineering allows these conclusions to be reached with a clarity and precision that cannot be obtained by other means. These results contradict previous review articles that were believed to be authoritative: the BIS score does not appear to depend on a bispectral index at all. These results put clinical anesthesia research using depth-of-anesthesia scores on a firm footing by elucidating their physiological basis and enabling comparison to other animal models for mechanistic research.
引用
- Connor CW. Open Reimplementation of the BIS Algorithms for Depth of Anesthesia. Anesth Analg. 2022. PMID: 35767469. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000006119
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。