慢性疼痛医学专科培训申请者面试筛选与排名的影响因素
结果显示面试筛选最看重对专业的承诺、疼痛科教师推荐信、学术活动和领导经历;排名阶段最看重人际交往能力、面试印象和机构契合度。候选者应在住院医师阶段持续展示对慢性疼痛专业的真实兴趣与参与。
要点
- 面试筛选最重视对慢性疼痛专业的承诺、疼痛科教师推荐信、学术活动与领导经历。
- 完成疼痛轮转受重视,但操作经验重要性相对较低,轮转是否在本部门完成无偏好。
- 排名阶段最看重人际交往能力、面试印象与申请者与机构的契合度。
核心结论
- 多数项目主任优先考虑申请者对慢性疼痛专业的承诺、学术活动、疼痛轮转参与、疼痛相关会议及疼痛科教师推荐信。
- 评估申请者对慢性疼痛的承诺具有挑战性,候选者应在住院医师期间建立对该专业真实兴趣与参与的渐进模式。
研究设计与样本
- 评估各类申请者特征的重要性,并与近期匹配数据进行比较。
主要发现
- 面试筛选最重要的因素为对专业的感知承诺、疼痛科教师推荐信、学术活动和领导经历。
- 完成疼痛轮转受高度重视,但操作经验重要性相对较低;轮转是否在 responders 所在部门完成无偏好。
- 考虑内部申请者或申请者地理位置时存在差异性。
- 排名阶段多数应答者高度评价人际交往能力、面试印象和申请者与机构的契合度。
临床怎么用
- 慢性疼痛专科培训候选者应在住院医师阶段持续展示对专业的真实兴趣与参与,以优化匹配潜力。
- 申请者应重视获取疼痛科教师推荐信、参与疼痛轮转与疼痛相关会议、积累学术活动与领导经历。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Applicants to chronic pain medicine fellowship programs often express confusion regarding the importance of various selection criteria. This study sought to elucidate program directors' considerations in applicant selection for fellowship interviews and ranking and to correlate these criteria with match statistics to provide a guide for prospective candidates. METHODS: An electronic survey was sent to all Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education-accredited chronic pain fellowship directors. The importance of various applicant characteristics were evaluated and compared with recent match data. RESULTS: Fifty-seven program directors completed the survey. The most important factors involved in applicant interview selection were perceived commitment to the specialty, letters of recommendation from pain faculty, scholarly activities, and leadership experiences. Although completion of a pain rotation was valued highly, experience with procedures was of relatively low importance. There was no preference if rotations were completed within the responders' department. Variability was noted when considering internal applicants or the applicant's geographic location. When citing main factors in ranking applicants, interpersonal skills, interview impression and applicant's fit within the institution were highly ranked by most responders. DISCUSSION: Assessment of an applicant's commitment to chronic pain is challenging. Most responders prioritize the applicant's commitment to chronic pain as a specialty, scholarly activity, participation in chronic pain rotations, pain-related conferences and letters of recommendation from pain faculty. Chronic pain medicine fellowship candidates should establish a progressive pattern of genuine interest and involvement within the specialty during residency training to optimize their fellowship match potential.
引用
- Tieppo Francio V, Gill B, Hagedorn JM, et al. Factors involved in applicant interview selection and ranking for chronic pain medicine fellowship. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2022. PMID: 35760514. doi:10.1136/rapm-2022-103538
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。