产科麻醉基于操作的工作量与设施利用:SOAP卓越中心调查
结果显示学术中心全体人员Stanford工作指数中位数工作日0.20、非学术中心0.33(P<.001);产科套房总房间数与分娩量强相关(R²=0.55)。结论可为产科麻醉人员配置提供参考。
要点
- 非学术中心全体人员工作指数高于学术中心(工作日0.33 vs 0.20,P<.001)。
- 仅主治医师的工作指数在学术与非学术中心间相似。
- 产科套房总房间数与分娩量强相关(R²=0.55)。
核心结论
- SOAP卓越中心的基于操作的工作量比率和设施利用数据可指导产科麻醉人员配置。
- 需考虑不同班次及学术与非学术中心之间的工作量差异。
研究设计与样本
- 经IRB豁免后,通过REDCap在线问卷(1次初始+2次提醒)发送给所有SOAP产科麻醉卓越中心。
主要发现
- 学术中心全体人员(含受训人员和注册麻醉护士)Stanford工作指数中位数:工作日0.20,夜班和周末0.19。
- 非学术中心全体人员Stanford工作指数中位数:工作日0.33(P<.001 vs 学术),夜班0.23(P=.009 vs 学术),周末0.23(P=.03 vs 学术)。
- 仅主治医师的Stanford工作指数在学术与非学术中心间相似。
- 产科套房总房间数(手术室、产房或分诊室)与分娩量强相关(R²=0.55)。
关键数值与推荐
- Stanford工作指数1.0表示值班期间每分钟均临床工作。
- 学术中心全体人员工作指数中位数工作日0.20、夜班和周末0.19。
- 非学术中心全体人员工作指数中位数工作日0.33、夜班0.23、周末0.23。
- 产科套房总房间数与分娩量R²=0.55。
临床怎么用
- 其他提供产科麻醉服务的机构可参考这些工作量比率和设施利用数据指导人员配置。
- 配置时应考虑不同班次以及学术与非学术中心之间的工作量差异。
局限性
- 未测量麻醉医师作为围产期医师的其他任务(如管理危重孕产妇、术前术后评估或紧急意外操作)。
- 需未来研究确定这些任务所需时间及最佳人员配置模型以应对工作量波动并改善结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Optimal workload and staffing for obstetric anesthesia services have yet to be determined. We surveyed Society of Obstetric Anesthesia and Perinatology (SOAP) Centers of Excellence (COE) for Obstetric Anesthesia Care institutions to evaluate procedure-based obstetric anesthesia workload and facility use. METHODS: After institutional review board (IRB) exemption, an online survey instrument (REDCap) was sent by email (1 initial and 2 reminders) to all SOAP COEs. Survey data included the number of deliveries, cesarean delivery rate, neuraxial labor analgesia rate, the number of labor and operating rooms, and the number of in-house and backup obstetric anesthesia providers. Obstetric anesthesia activity was estimated using a time-based workload ratio per provider (Stanford Work Index, 1.0 = clinically working every minute of every hour on duty) during weekday, weeknight, and weekend shifts. We compared workload between academic and nonacademic centers and correlated operating and labor rooms with cesarean and vaginal delivery volume. RESULTS: Fifty-one of 53 surveys were returned (96% response rate). Data from 33 academic and 14 nonacademic US institutions were analyzed. For academic centers, median Stanford Work Index for all staff (included trainees and Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetists) was 0.20 (weekday) and 0.19 (weeknight and weekends); nonacademic centers were 0.33 (weekday, P < .001 versus academic), 0.23 (weeknight, P = .009 versus academic), and 0.23 (weekends, P = .03 versus academic practices). Attending-only Stanford Work Indices were similar between academic and nonacademic centers. Total number of rooms on the obstetric suite (operating, labor, or triage room) was strongly correlated with delivery volume ( R2 = 0.55). CONCLUSIONS: The results outline staffing procedure-based workload ratios and facility utilization at SOAP COEs in the United States. These data can be used by other institutions that provide obstetric anesthesia services to guide their obstetric anesthesia staffing. The importance of considering the workload associated with different shifts and between academic and nonacademic centers is also highlighted. The results show that approximately one-third of an obstetric anesthesiologist's workload is spent on performing procedures. We did not, however, measure the other tasks anesthesiologists practice as peripartum physicians (eg, managing critically ill parturients, doing pre- and postprocedural evaluations, or performing emergent and unexpected procedures), and future studies are required to determine the time required to perform these tasks. Studies to determine the optimal staffing models to handle workload fluctuations and improve outcomes are also required.
引用
- Im M, Riley ET, Hoang D, et al. Obstetric Anesthesia Procedure-Based Workload and Facility Utilization of Society of Obstetric Anesthesia and Perinatology Centers of Excellence Designated Institutions. Anesth Analg. 2022. PMID: 35759390. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000006112
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。