儿科麻醉中吸入与全静脉麻醉碳足迹的建模研究
该建模研究模拟5-50 kg儿童四种麻醉技术的碳足迹,发现丙泊酚-瑞芬太尼全静脉麻醉在60分钟典型手术中碳足迹最低(20 kg儿童为1.26 kg CO2e),低于静脉诱导后吸入维持(2.58 kg CO2e)和全程吸入麻醉(2.98 kg CO2e);吸入诱导后静脉维持仅在较长手术中才优于全程吸入。
要点
- 儿科全静脉麻醉碳足迹低于吸入麻醉,60分钟手术中20 kg儿童为1.26 kg CO2e。
- 吸入诱导后静脉维持仅在较长手术中才比全程吸入更低碳。
- 研究为模拟研究,结论需真实世界数据验证。
核心结论
- 模拟研究显示儿科全静脉麻醉具有气候效益。
- 吸入诱导后静脉维持仅在较长手术中才实现碳减排。
研究设计与样本
- 采用数学模拟模型比较5-50 kg儿童四种全麻技术的碳足迹。
- 模拟技术包括全静脉麻醉、静脉诱导后吸入维持、吸入诱导后静脉维持、全程吸入麻醉。
- 吸入诱导模拟七氟烷单用或七氟烷联合氧化亚氮;静脉麻醉模拟瑞芬太尼-丙泊酚或丙泊酚单用。
- 基于已发表生命周期数据计算麻醉时长至480分钟的二氧化碳当量。
主要发现
- 60分钟典型麻醉中,20 kg儿童丙泊酚-瑞芬太尼全静脉麻醉碳足迹为1.26 kg CO2e。
- 同条件下静脉诱导后吸入维持为2.58 kg CO2e,全程吸入麻醉为2.98 kg CO2e。
- 吸入诱导后静脉维持仅在较长手术中碳足迹低于全程吸入:5-20 kg儿童>77分钟,30-50 kg儿童>105分钟。
临床怎么用
- 儿科麻醉可优先考虑全静脉麻醉以减少碳足迹。
- 若采用吸入诱导,静脉维持仅建议用于较长手术以体现气候效益。
- 研究结论需真实世界数据确认后方可用于临床决策。
局限性
- 研究为模拟建模,结论需真实世界数据验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Tackling the climate emergency is now a key target for the healthcare sector. Avoiding inhalational anaesthesia is often cited as an important element of reducing anaesthesia-related emissions. However, evidence supporting this is based on adult practice. The aim of this study was to identify the difference in carbon footprint of inhalational and i.v. anaesthesia when used in children. METHODS: We used mathematical simulation models to compare general anaesthetic techniques in children weighing 5-50 kg for TIVA, i.v. induction then inhalational maintenance, inhalational induction then i.v. maintenance, and inhalational induction and maintenance. We simulated inhalational induction with sevoflurane alone, and co-induction with sevoflurane and nitrous oxide, and both remifentanil-propofol and propofol-only i.v. anaesthesia. For each technique, we drew on previously published life-cycle data to calculate carbon dioxide equivalents for anaesthetic durations up to 480 min. RESULTS: TIVA with propofol and remifentanil had a smaller carbon footprint over a typical anaesthetic duration of 60 min (1.26 kg carbon dioxide equivalents [CO2e] for a 20 kg child) than i.v. induction followed by inhalational maintenance (2.58 kg CO2e) or inhalational induction and maintenance (2.98 kg CO2e). Inhalational induction followed by i.v. maintenance only had a lower carbon footprint than inhalational induction and maintenance when used in longer procedures (>77 min for children 5-20 kg; >105 min for children 30-50 kg). CONCLUSIONS: In a simulation study, i.v. anaesthesia had climate benefits in paediatric anaesthesia. However, when used after inhalational induction, benefits were only achieved in longer procedures. These findings provide evidence-based guidance for reducing the environmental impact of paediatric anaesthesia, but these will require confirmation using real-world data.
引用
- Narayanan H, Raistrick C, Tom Pierce JM, et al. Carbon footprint of inhalational and total intravenous anaesthesia for paediatric anaesthesia: a modelling study. Br J Anaesth. 2022. PMID: 35729012. doi:10.1016/j.bja.2022.04.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。