超低、低与高浓度局麻药用于分娩硬膜外镇痛的系统评价与网状Meta分析
该系统评价与网状Meta分析比较了高(>0.1%)、低(>0.08%至≤0.1%)和超低(≤0.08%)浓度局麻药用于分娩硬膜外镇痛的效果,共纳入32项随机对照试验(3665名产妇)。结果显示超低浓度相比高浓度可提高自然阴道分娩率、减少运动阻滞、缩短第二产程,且局麻药总剂量更低;与低浓度相比多数结局相似。
要点
- 超低浓度(≤0.08%)相比高浓度(>0.1%)提高自然阴道分娩率(OR 1.46)。
- 超低浓度相比高浓度减少运动阻滞(Bromage>0,OR 0.32)并缩短第二产程。
- 超低与低浓度在分娩方式、疼痛及满意度上差异无统计学意义。
核心结论
- 超低浓度局麻药用于分娩硬膜外镇痛可达到与低浓度或高浓度相似或更好的母婴结局,且局麻药用量更少。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与网状Meta分析,纳入32项随机对照试验,共3665名产妇,比较高(>0.1%)、低(>0.08%至≤0.1%)和超低(≤0.08%)浓度布比卡因或等效局麻药。
- 采用贝叶斯网状Meta分析随机效应模型,计算比值比或加权均数差及95%可信区间。
主要发现
- 局麻药总剂量随浓度升高而增加:超低比低浓度加权均数差-14.96 mg(95%可信区间[-28.38至-1.00]),低比高浓度-14.99 mg([-28.79至-2.04]),组间补救追加次数无差异。
- 超低浓度比高浓度自然阴道分娩OR 1.46([1.18至1.86]),运动阻滞(Bromage评分>0)OR 0.32([0.18至0.54]),第二产程加权均数差-13.02分钟([-21.54至-4.77])。
- 超低比低浓度第二产程加权均数差-1.92分钟([-14.35至10.20]),自然阴道分娩OR 1.07([0.75至1.56]),器械阴道分娩OR 1.35([0.75至2.26]),剖宫产OR 0.76([0.49至1.22]),疼痛评分(1-100)加权均数差-5.44([-16.75至5.93]),产妇满意度相似。
- 超低比低浓度1分钟Apgar评分<7的风险更低(OR 0.43 [0.15至0.79]),但5分钟未持续(OR 0.12 [0.00至2.10])。
临床怎么用
- 对于分娩硬膜外镇痛,可考虑使用超低浓度(≤0.08%)局麻药以减少局麻药总用量并改善部分母婴结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Lumbar epidural is the gold standard for labour analgesia. Low concentrations of local anaesthetic are recommended. This network meta-analysis investigated whether further reducing the concentration of local anaesthetic can improve maternal and neonatal outcomes without compromising analgesia. We conducted a systematic search of relevant databases for randomised controlled trials comparing high (>0.1%), low (>0.08% to ≤0.1%) or ultra-low (≤0.08%) concentration local anaesthetic (bupivacaine or equivalent) for labour epidural. Outcomes included mode of delivery, duration of labour and maternal/neonatal outcomes. Bayesian network meta-analysis with random-effects modelling was used to calculate odds ratios or weighted mean differences and 95% credible intervals. A total of 32 studies met inclusion criteria (3665 women). The total dose of local anaesthetic received increased as the concentration increased; ultra-low compared with low (weighted mean difference -14.96 mg, 95% credible interval [-28.38 to -1.00]) and low compared with high groups (weighted mean difference -14.99 [-28.79 to -2.04]), though there was no difference in the number of rescue top-ups administered between the groups. Compared with high concentration, ultra-low concentration local anaesthetic was associated with increased likelihood of spontaneous vaginal delivery (OR 1.46 [1.18 to 1.86]), reduced motor block (Bromage score >0; OR 0.32 [0.18 to 0.54]) and reduced duration of second stage of labour (weighted mean difference -13.02 min [-21.54 to -4.77]). Compared with low, ultra-low concentration local anaesthetic had similar estimates for duration of second stage of labour (weighted mean difference -1.92 min [-14.35 to 10.20]); spontaneous vaginal delivery (OR 1.07 [0.75 to 1.56]; assisted vaginal delivery (OR 1.35 [0.75 to 2.26]); caesarean section (OR 0.76 [0.49 to 1.22]); pain (scale 1-100, weighted mean difference -5.44 [-16.75 to 5.93]); and maternal satisfaction. Although a lower risk of an Apgar score < 7 at 1 min (OR 0.43 [0.15 to 0.79]) was reported for ultra-low compared with low concentration, this was not sustained at 5 min (OR 0.12 [0.00 to 2.10]). Ultra-low concentration local anaesthetic for labour epidural achieves similar or better maternal and neonatal outcomes as low and high concentration, but with reduced local anaesthetic consumption.
引用
- Halliday L, Kinsella M, Shaw M, et al. Comparison of ultra-low, low and high concentration local anaesthetic for labour epidural analgesia: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. Anaesthesia. 2022. PMID: 35607864. doi:10.1111/anae.15756
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。