理解基本服务的经济影响:将时间驱动作业成本法应用于医院气道应急团队
该研究利用时间驱动作业成本法(TDABC)分析某三级医疗中心24个月内气道应急团队(ART)的激活记录与计费数据,估算麻醉科为ART配备人员的经济成本。结果显示ART激活3368次,急诊气道计费1044例,每次气道平均收入198.45美元(95%CI 190-207),两年人员成本估计218,601美元,收入207,181美元,收入可能覆盖人员成本但不覆盖耗材成本。
要点
- TDABC可量化ART人员成本,两年人员成本218,601美元,收入207,181美元。
- 每次急诊气道平均收入198.45美元(95%CI 190-207),可能不覆盖耗材成本。
- 麻醉科可用TDABC向医院证明服务未获充分补偿并协商补贴。
核心结论
- ART激活产生的收入可能覆盖人员成本,但不覆盖消耗性设备成本。
- 当前按服务付费模式依赖团队在覆盖气道寻呼之外完成其他临床职责,传统自上而下成本法无法捕捉。
- TDABC可帮助麻醉组证明ART等服务未被现行报销模式完全覆盖,并用于协商补贴协议。
研究设计与样本
- 查询当地行政数据库获取急诊气道置入计费使用的CPT代码。
- ART多名成员召开会议,为不同类型ART激活创建过程图。
- 使用每种ART激活的估计时间及当地ART激活数据估算人员成本。
主要发现
- 从寻呼记录分析ART激活3368次。
- 研究期间使用急诊气道CPT代码计费的气道1044例。
- 每次气道平均收入198.45美元(95% CI,190-207美元)。
- 使用TDABC估算两年研究期间总人员成本218,601美元。
- ART在研究期间产生收入207,181美元。
临床怎么用
- 麻醉组可使用TDABC展示ART等服务未被现行报销模式完全覆盖。
- 了解真实成本有助于与医院协商补贴协议。
- 在向价值医疗转型中,理解并沟通医疗成本至关重要。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: As the United States moves toward value-based care metrics, it will become essential for anesthesia groups nationwide to understand the costs of their services. Time-driven activity-based costing (TDABC) estimates the amount of time it takes to perform a clinical activity by dividing complex tasks into process steps and mapping each step and has historically been used to estimate the costs of various health care services. TDABC is a tool that can be adapted for variable staffing models and the volume of service provided. Anesthesia departments often provide staffing for airway response teams (ART). The economic implications of staffing ART have not been well described. We present a TDABC model for ART activation in a tertiary-care center to estimate the cost incurred by an anesthesiology department to staff an ART. METHODS: Pages received by the Brigham and Women's Hospital ART over a 24-month time period (January 2019 to December 2020) were analyzed and categorized. The local administrative database was queried for the Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) code used to bill for emergency airway placements. Sessions were held by multiple members of the ART to create process maps for the different types of ART activations. We estimated the staffing costs using the estimated time it took for each type of ART activation as well as the data collected for local ART activations. RESULTS: From the paging records, we analyzed 3368 activations of the ART. During the study period, 1044 airways were billed for with emergency airway CPT code. The average revenue collected per airway was $198.45 (95% CI, $190-$207). For STAT/Emergency airway team activations, process maps and non-STAT airway team activations were created, and third subprocess map was created for performing endotracheal intubation. Using the TDABC, the total staffing costs are estimated to be $218,601 for the 2-year study period. The ART generated $207,181 in revenue during the study period. CONCLUSIONS: Our analysis of ART-activation pages suggests that while the revenue generated may cover the cost of staffing the team during ART activations, it does not cover consumable equipment costs. Additionally, the current fee-for-service model relies on the team being able to perform other clinical duties in addition to covering the airway pager and would be impossible to capture using traditional top-down costing methods. By using TDABC, anesthesia groups can demonstrate how certain services, such as ART, are not fully covered by current reimbursement models and how to negotiate for subsidy agreements.As the transition from traditional fee-for-service payments to value-based care models continues in the United States, improving the understanding and communication of medical care costs will be essential. In the United States, it is common for anesthesia groups to receive direct revenue from hospitals to preserve financial viability, and therefore, knowledge of true cost is essential regardless of payer model.1 With traditional payment models, what is billable and nonbillable may not reflect either the need for or the cost of providing the service. As anesthesia departments navigate the transition of care from volume to value, actual costs will be essential to understand for negotiations with hospitals for support when services are nonbillable, when revenue from payers does not cover anesthesia costs, and when calculating the appropriate share for anesthesia departments when bundled payments are distributed.
引用
- Stone AB, Dasani SS, Grant MC, et al. Understanding the Economic Impact of an Essential Service: Applying Time-Driven Activity-Based Costing to the Hospital Airway Response Team. Anesth Analg. 2022. PMID: 35180159. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000005838
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。