基于模拟掌握学习的麻醉主治医师紧急声门下气道培训及技能保持评估
初始测试成功率TTJV为14.8%、BC为19.7%、Melker环甲膜切开术(MC)为25%,掌握学习后所有医师均成功置入,15个月后TTJV和BC的成功保持率分别为80.4%和82.6%。
要点
- 掌握学习培训后所有麻醉医师均能成功完成TTJV、BC和MC置入。
- TTJV和BC在15个月后的技能保持成功率分别为80.4%和82.6%。
- BC为最快完成的技术,MC因安全性、置入时间和成本在初始训练后被弃用。
核心结论
- 使用基于模拟的掌握学习教学法可在2.5小时课程内将紧急声门下气道置入成功率从约20%提升至100%。
- 所学气道技能在15个月时保持约80%的成功率,提示技能至少维持一年后再培训。
研究设计与样本
- 培训针对经气管喷射通气(TTJV)和探条环甲膜切开术(BC)两项紧急声门下气道技术。
- 评估包括前测、后测、具体技能步骤错误追踪以及15个月后的复测。
- 所有前测评估、培训、后测和15个月复测均由单一专家临床与教育气道管理教员完成。
主要发现
- 初始测试成功率:TTJV为14.8%,BC为19.7%,Melker环甲膜切开术(MC)为25%。
- 掌握学习练习后,所有麻醉医师均成功完成TTJV、BC和MC的侵入性气道置入。
- 重复操作提高了速度且无安全违规,BC为最快完成的技术。
- 15个月后复测,TTJV和BC的成功气道固定率分别为80.4%和82.6%。
- MC因安全性、平均置入时间和成本在初始训练结果后被弃用。
关键数值与推荐
- 掌握学习后所有医师成功置入TTJV、BC和MC。
- 15个月复测TTJV成功率为80.4%,BC为82.6%。
- TTJV平均通气成功时间为32秒,BC为29秒。
临床怎么用
- 可采用移动模拟在科室会议室进行2.5小时掌握学习培训,提升紧急声门下气道置入成功率。
- 培训后技能可保持至少15个月,支持每年复训一次的策略。
局限性
- 研究为单中心模拟环境,样本为学术麻醉主治医师,结果外推需谨慎。
- 所有评估由单一专家完成,可能存在评估偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Although included within the American Society of Anesthesiologists difficult airway algorithm, the use of "invasive airway access" is rarely needed clinically. In conjunction with highly associated morbidity and liability risks, it is a challenge for the average anesthesiologist to develop and maintain competency. The advancement of high-fidelity simulators allows for practice of rarely encountered clinical scenarios, specifically those requiring invasive subglottic airway techniques. METHODS: Sixty board-certified academic anesthesiologists were enrolled and trained in dyads in a simulation-based, mastery-based learning (MBL) course directed at 2 emergency airway subglottic techniques: transtracheal jet ventilation (TTJV) and bougie cricothyrotomy (BC). Performance metrics included: pretest, posttest, specific skill step error tracking, and 15-month period retest. All were pretested and trained once on the Melker cricothyrotomy (MC) kit. All pretest assessment, training, posttesting, and 15-month retesting were performed by a single expert clinical and educational airway management faculty member. RESULTS: Initial testing showed a success rate of 14.8% for TTJV, 19.7% for BC, and 25% for MC. After mastery-based practice, all anesthesiologists achieved successful invasive airway placement with TTJV, BC, and MC. Repeated performance of each skill improved speed with zero safety breaches. BC was noted to be the fastest performed technique. Fifteen months later, retesting showed that 80.4% and 82.6% performed successful airway securement for TTJV and BC, respectively. For safety, average placement time and costs, MC was discarded after initial training results. CONCLUSIONS: We discovered that only ~20% of practicing anesthesiologists were able to successfully place an invasive airway in a simulated life or death clinical setting. Using mobile simulation (training performed in department conference room) during a 2.5-hour session using mastery-based training pedagogy, we increased our success rate of invasive airway placement to 100%, while also increasing the successful speed to ventilation (TTJV, 32 seconds average; BC, 29 seconds average). Finally, we determined that there was a 15-month 80% retention rate of the airway skills learned, indicating that skills last at least a year before retraining is required using this training methodology.
引用
- Clark CA, Mester RA, Redding AT, et al. Emergency Subglottic Airway Training and Assessment of Skills Retention of Attending Anesthesiologists With Simulation Mastery-Based Learning. Anesth Analg. 2022. PMID: 35147576. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000005928
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。