门诊膝关节镜术中1%2-氯普鲁卡因腰麻ED90:随机偏币上下序贯分配试验
该研究在两家医院分两队列进行,队列I采用随机偏币上下序贯设计纳入40例患者估算1%2-氯普鲁卡因腰麻的ED90,队列II以开放标签设计在50例患者中验证。结果表明ED90为27.8 mg,固定28 mg在队列II中49例(98%,95%CI 89%~100%)麻醉成功,运动阻滞完全恢复中位时间60分钟,感觉阻滞90分钟,平均出院时间2.9小时。
要点
- 1%2-氯普鲁卡因腰麻用于45分钟内膝关节镜的ED90为27.8 mg。
- 固定28 mg在外部人群麻醉成功率为98%(95%CI 89%~100%)。
- 运动阻滞完全恢复中位60分钟,感觉阻滞90分钟,利于门诊流转。
核心结论
- 1%2-氯普鲁卡因腰麻用于门诊膝关节镜术的ED90估计为27.8 mg。
- 在外部人群中,该ED90剂量麻醉成功率为98%(95%CI 89%~100%)。
研究设计与样本
- 两队列研究,在两个不同医院进行。
- 队列I采用随机偏币上下序贯设计,40例患者,测试25、30、35、40 mg四个剂量水平以估算ED90。
- 队列II采用开放标签设计,50例患者,以固定28 mg验证ED90。
主要发现
- 队列I最终分析40例,ED90估计为27.8 mg,38例(95%)腰麻成功。
- 队列II最终分析50例,固定28 mg时49例麻醉成功。
- 队列II感觉阻滞峰值达T10/T11(范围L4-T4)。
- 运动阻滞完全恢复中位时间60分钟(45-60),感觉阻滞完全恢复中位时间90分钟(75-105)。
- 平均出院时间2.9小时(标准差0.7)。
关键数值与推荐
- 队列I测试的1%2-氯普鲁卡因剂量水平为25、30、35、40 mg。
- 队列I ED90为27.8 mg,麻醉成功率95%(38/40例)。
- 队列II固定28 mg,麻醉成功率98%(95%CI 89%~100%,49/50例)。
临床怎么用
- 门诊膝关节镜术可参考1%2-氯普鲁卡因腰麻ED90约27.8 mg,固定28 mg在验证队列中成功率高。
- 该方案运动阻滞恢复较快(中位60分钟),感觉阻滞中位90分钟,平均出院时间2.9小时,适合日间手术流转。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入膝关节镜术患者,结论外推至其他门诊手术需谨慎。
- 队列II为开放标签设计,非随机盲法验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A short acting spinal anesthetic facilitates smooth flow since quick recovery of motor function will facilitate unassisted ambulation. The aim of this study was to estimate the effective dose (ED90) of intrathecal 2-chloroprocaine 1% in outpatient knee arthroscopy. METHODS: Two cohorts were included in two different hospitals. In cohort I, a randomized biased-coin up-and-down design with 40 patients was used to find the ED90. Four dose-levels of plain 2-chloroprocaine 1% were used: 25, 30, 35 and 40 mg. The identified primary outcome, the ED90, was validated in 50 patients in cohort II with an open label design. Secondary outcomes included time to complete recovery from motor and sensory block with spinal injection as time zero, peak sensory block level, urine retention and time until hospital discharge. RESULTS: Forty patients were included in the final analysis in cohort I. The ED90 was estimated at 27.8 mg, successful spinal anesthesia was obtained in 38 patients (95%). Fifty patients were included in the final analysis in cohort II, 49 patients had successful anesthesia with a fixed round dose of 28 mg. In this Cohort, peak sensory block was T10/T11 (range: (L4-T4)). The median time to full recovery of the motor block was 60 min (45-60) and 90 min (75-105) for the sensory block. The mean time to hospital discharge was 2.9 hours (0.7). CONCLUSION: The ED90 of 2-chloroprocaine 1% in knee arthroscopy was estimated to be 27.8 mg. In an external population, the ED90 resulted in successful anesthesia in 98% of the patients (95% CI 89% to 100%). TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: Netherlands Trial Registry (NL6769).
引用
- Wesselink EJ, Koopman SJ, Vegt RV, et al. ED90 of spinal 2-chloroprocaine 1% in ambulatory knee arthroscopy up to 45 min: a randomized biased-coin- up-and-down sequential allocation trial. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2022. PMID: 35027477. doi:10.1136/rapm-2021-103089
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。