视频喉镜与Macintosh直接喉镜气管插管的排序系统评价与网络荟萃分析
该系统评价与网络荟萃分析纳入179项随机临床试验,比较不同视频喉镜与Macintosh直接喉镜在成人气管插管中的表现。结果显示C-MAC与C-MAC D-Blade在避免插管失败方面排名最高,但不同设备间无统计学显著差异;视频喉镜与Macintosh直接喉镜在插管时间上临床等效。总体证据质量低或极低,尚不足以确保某一设备显著优于其他设备。
要点
- C-MAC和C-MAC D-Blade在避免插管失败方面排名最高,但设备间无显著差异。
- C-MAC D-Blade在困难喉镜暴露方面显著优于C-MAC Macintosh镜片。
- 视频喉镜与Macintosh直接喉镜在插管时间上临床等效,证据质量低或极低。
核心结论
- 不同视频喉镜的插管性能存在差异,部分设备可能更受青睐,但现有证据不足以确保某一设备或少数设备显著优于其他设备。
- 视频喉镜与Macintosh直接喉镜在气管插管时间上可视为临床等效。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与网络荟萃分析,检索PubMed等六个数据库至2021年1月11日,纳入179项随机临床试验,患者年龄≥16岁。
- 比较不同视频喉镜或视频喉镜与Macintosh直接喉镜,结局包括插管失败、首次插管失败、两次尝试内插管失败、困难插管、声门开放百分比、困难喉镜暴露和插管时间。
- 采用GRADE方法评估证据质量。
主要发现
- C-MAC和C-MAC D-Blade在避免插管失败方面排名最高,但任何两种不同视频喉镜之间未发现统计学显著差异。
- C-MAC D-Blade在困难喉镜暴露方面显著优于C-MAC Macintosh镜片。
- 不同喉镜间插管时间存在统计学显著差异,但未被认为具有临床相关性。
- 总体证据质量 judged 为低或极低。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入179项随机临床试验,患者年龄≥16岁。
- C-MAC D-Blade在困难喉镜暴露方面显著优于C-MAC Macintosh镜片。
- 插管时间差异有统计学意义但无临床相关性。
- 总体证据质量低或极低。
临床怎么用
- 临床可考虑使用C-MAC或C-MAC D-Blade以减少插管失败,但需知晓设备间差异不显著。
- 视频喉镜与Macintosh直接喉镜在插管时间上临床等效,选择可基于其他因素。
- 现有证据质量低,设备选择应结合临床经验和具体场景。
局限性
- 总体证据质量 judged 为低或极低。
- 现有证据不足以确保某一设备或少数设备显著优于其他设备。
- 插管时间差异虽统计学显著但无临床相关性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Videolaryngoscopes are thought to improve glottic view and facilitate tracheal intubation compared with the Macintosh direct laryngoscope. However, we currently do not know which one would be the best choice in most patients undergoing anaesthesia. We designed this systematic review with network meta-analyses to rank the different videolaryngoscopes and the Macintosh direct laryngoscope. We conducted searches in PubMed and a further five databases on 11 January 2021. We included randomised clinical trials with patients aged ≥16 years, comparing different videolaryngoscopes, or videolaryngoscopes with the Macintosh direct laryngoscope for the outcomes: failed intubation; failed first intubation attempt; failed intubation within two attempts; difficult intubation; percentage of glottic opening seen; difficult laryngoscopy; and time needed for intubation. We assessed the quality of evidence according to GRADE recommendations and included 179 studies in the meta-analyses. The C-MAC and C-MAC D-Blade were top ranked for avoiding failed intubation, but we did not find statistically significant differences between any two distinct videolaryngoscopes for this outcome. Further, the C-MAC D-Blade performed significantly better than the C-MAC Macintosh blade for difficult laryngoscopy. We found statistically significant differences between the laryngoscopes for time to intubation, but these differences were not considered clinically relevant. The evidence was judged as of low or very low quality overall. In conclusion, different videolaryngoscopes have differential intubation performance and some may be currently preferred among the available devices. Furthermore, videolaryngoscopes and the Macintosh direct laryngoscope may be considered clinically equivalent for the time taken for tracheal intubation. However, despite the rankings from our analyses, the current available evidence is not sufficient to ensure significant superiority of one device or a small set of them over the others for our intubation-related outcomes.
引用
- de Carvalho CC, da Silva DM, Lemos VM, et al. Videolaryngoscopy vs. direct Macintosh laryngoscopy in tracheal intubation in adults: a ranking systematic review and network meta-analysis. Anaesthesia. 2021. PMID: 34855986. doi:10.1111/anae.15626
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。