文献速递气道管理

气道管理导引器性能评估:实验室与模拟人研究

An assessment of introducers used for airway management.
PubMed 文献 · Anaesthesia · 2021-12-03

本研究通过实验室设计特征评估与30名麻醉医师参与的模拟人随机放置试验,比较六种气管插管导引器。首次插入成功率随导引器不同而显著差异(p=0.0016),范围47%(Armstrong和P3)至77%(Intersurgical和Frova)。Armstrong和P3可接受性较差,在未显著改进设计前,对其开展患者研究存疑。

要点

  • 不同导引器首次插入成功率差异显著(p=0.0016),Armstrong和P3仅47%。
  • 中位置入时间(含食管置入)10秒(Eschmann和Frova)至20秒(P3)(p=0.0025)。
  • 研究方案可用于区分不同导引器,为评估其他类型设备提供基础。

核心结论

  • Armstrong和P3导引器可接受性不如其他导引器,在未显著改进设计前,对其开展患者研究存疑。
  • 研究方案适用于区分不同导引器,可作为评估其他类型设备的基础。

研究设计与样本

  • 实验室与模拟人研究,纳入六种不同导引器进行设计特征评估。
  • 30名麻醉医师参与模拟人试验,按随机顺序用每种导引器尝试置入气管。

主要发现

  • 首次插入成功率显著取决于所用导引器(p=0.0016),范围47%(Armstrong和P3)至77%(Intersurgical和Frova)。
  • 中位置入时间(包括食管置入)范围10秒(Eschmann和Frova)至20秒(P3)(p=0.0025)。
  • 中位成功置入气管时间范围9秒(Frova)至22秒(Armstrong)(p=0.037)。

临床怎么用

  • 选择导引器时应考虑首次插入成功率和置入时间等性能差异。
  • 对Armstrong和P3导引器开展患者研究前需评估其设计改进情况。

局限性

  • 研究为实验室与模拟人试验,非患者临床研究。
  • 样本为30名麻醉医师,结果外推需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Different introducers are available to assist with tracheal intubation. Subtle differences in the design of introducers can have a marked effect on safety and performance. The Difficult Airway Society's Airway Device Evaluation Project Team proposal states that devices should only be purchased for which there is at least a case-control study on patients assessing airway devices. However, resources are not currently available to carry out a case-control study on all introducers available on the market. This study comprised a laboratory and manikin-based investigation to identify introducers that could be suitable for clinical investigation. We included six different introducers in laboratory-based assessments (design characteristics) and manikin-based assessments involving the participation of 30 anaesthetists. Each anaesthetist attempted placement in the manikin's trachea with each of the six introducers in a random order. Outcomes included first-time insertion success rate; insertion success rate; number of attempts; time to placement; and distance placed. Each anaesthetist also completed a questionnaire. First-time insertion success rate depended significantly on the introducer used (p = 0.0016) and varied from 47% (Armstrong and P3) to 77% (Intersurgical and Frova). Median time to placement (including oesophageal placement) varied from 10 s (Eschmann and Frova) to 20 s (P3) (p = 0.0025). Median time to successful placement in the trachea varied from 9 s (Frova) to 22 s (Armstrong) (p = 0.037). We found that the Armstrong and P3 devices were not as acceptable as other introducers and, without significant improvements to their design and characteristics, the use of these devices in studies on patients is questionable. The study protocol is suitable for differentiating between different introducers and could be used as a basis for assessing other types of devices.

来源:Anaesthesia,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Price L, Carter P, Hodzovic I, et al. An assessment of introducers used for airway management. Anaesthesia. 2021. PMID: 34861743. doi:10.1111/anae.15624

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。