颈椎关节疼痛干预多学科国际工作组共识实践指南
美国区域麻醉与疼痛医学学会和美国疼痛医学学会于2020年8月批准成立颈椎关节工作组,采用改良德尔菲法制定颈椎关节疼痛干预指南。工作组选定20个问题,其中17个主题达成100%共识,15个参与组织中有14个投票批准或支持该指南。结论认为颈椎内侧支射频消融可能对经过良好选择的个体有益,内侧支阻滞比关节内注射更具预测价值。
要点
- 颈椎内侧支射频消融可能对经过良好选择的个体有益。
- 内侧支阻滞对射频消融效果的预测价值优于关节内注射。
- 更严格的选择标准可能改善去神经治疗效果,但会增加假阴性。
核心结论
- 颈椎内侧支射频消融可能对经过良好选择的个体有益,内侧支阻滞比关节内注射更具预测价值。
- 更严格的选择标准可能改善去神经治疗效果,但以假阴性(即总体成功率降低)为代价。
- 临床试验应根据目的量身定制,某些试验的选择标准可能比临床实践中的理想标准更严格。
研究设计与样本
- 美国区域麻醉与疼痛医学学会和美国疼痛医学学会于2020年8月批准并委托颈椎关节工作组制定颈椎疼痛指南。
- 参与实体选择小组成员,特设指导委员会选择初步问题,后由全体委员会修订。
- 每个问题分配给由4-5名成员组成的模块,模块成员与小组委员会负责人和委员会主席合作完成初步版本,修订后发送给全体委员会。
- 采用改良德尔菲法,问题整体发送给委员会,评论以非盲方式返回给主席,主席整合评论并发送修订版本直至达成共识。
主要发现
- 选定了20个问题,委员会在17个主题上达成100%共识。
- 在参与组织中,15个投票的组织中有14个整体批准或支持该指南,14个问题在无异议或弃权的情况下获得批准。
- 具体问题涉及临床 presentation 和影像学在选择患者进行手术中的价值、注射前是否应使用保守治疗、阻滞是否需要影像学、内侧支阻滞和关节内注射的诊断和预后价值、镇静和注射量对有效性的影响、关节突阻滞是否有治疗价值、判定阻滞阳性的理想截断值、射频消融前应进行多少次阻滞、电极方向、更大的损伤是否转化为更高的成功率、射频消融前是否应使用刺激、如何最好地减轻并发症风险、临床实践和试验是否应采用不同标准以及重复射频消融的指征。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐需要委员会成员>50%同意,共识推荐需要≥75%同意。
- 选定了20个问题,委员会在17个主题上达成100%共识。
- 15个参与组织中有14个投票批准或支持该指南,14个问题在无异议或弃权的情况下获得批准。
临床怎么用
- 颈椎内侧支射频消融可能对经过良好选择的个体有益。
- 内侧支阻滞比关节内注射更具预测价值。
- 更严格的选择标准可能改善去神经治疗效果,但会增加假阴性。
- 临床试验应根据目的量身定制,某些试验的选择标准可能比临床实践中的理想标准更严格。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The past two decades have witnessed a surge in the use of cervical spine joint procedures including joint injections, nerve blocks and radiofrequency ablation to treat chronic neck pain, yet many aspects of the procedures remain controversial. METHODS: In August 2020, the American Society of Regional Anesthesia and Pain Medicine and the American Academy of Pain Medicine approved and charged the Cervical Joint Working Group to develop neck pain guidelines. Eighteen stakeholder societies were identified, and formal request-for-participation and member nomination letters were sent to those organizations. Participating entities selected panel members and an ad hoc steering committee selected preliminary questions, which were then revised by the full committee. Each question was assigned to a module composed of 4-5 members, who worked with the Subcommittee Lead and the Committee Chairs on preliminary versions, which were sent to the full committee after revisions. We used a modified Delphi method whereby the questions were sent to the committee en bloc and comments were returned in a non-blinded fashion to the Chairs, who incorporated the comments and sent out revised versions until consensus was reached. Before commencing, it was agreed that a recommendation would be noted with >50% agreement among committee members, but a consensus recommendation would require ≥75% agreement. RESULTS: Twenty questions were selected, with 100% consensus achieved in committee on 17 topics. Among participating organizations, 14 of 15 that voted approved or supported the guidelines en bloc, with 14 questions being approved with no dissensions or abstentions. Specific questions addressed included the value of clinical presentation and imaging in selecting patients for procedures, whether conservative treatment should be used before injections, whether imaging is necessary for blocks, diagnostic and prognostic value of medial branch blocks and intra-articular joint injections, the effects of sedation and injectate volume on validity, whether facet blocks have therapeutic value, what the ideal cut-off value is for designating a block as positive, how many blocks should be performed before radiofrequency ablation, the orientation of electrodes, whether larger lesions translate into higher success rates, whether stimulation should be used before radiofrequency ablation, how best to mitigate complication risks, if different standards should be applied to clinical practice and trials, and the indications for repeating radiofrequency ablation. CONCLUSIONS: Cervical medial branch radiofrequency ablation may provide benefit to well-selected individuals, with medial branch blocks being more predictive than intra-articular injections. More stringent selection criteria are likely to improve denervation outcomes, but at the expense of false-negatives (ie, lower overall success rate). Clinical trials should be tailored based on objectives, and selection criteria for some may be more stringent than what is ideal in clinical practice.
引用
- Hurley RW, Adams MCB, Barad M, et al. Consensus practice guidelines on interventions for cervical spine (facet) joint pain from a multispecialty international working group. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2021. PMID: 34764220. doi:10.1136/rapm-2021-103031
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。