甲状腺相关患者报告结局测量工具ThyPRO缩短回忆期未改变经重复瞬时测量评估的准确性
本研究纳入122例新诊断甲状腺毒症患者,在28天内每日三次通过智能手机回答瞬时问题,并每周回答1周回忆版ThyPRO、第28天回答原始4周回忆版ThyPRO。结果显示瞬时评分与回忆评分高度相关,1周与4周回忆期的平均差异相似,缩短回忆期未减少回忆偏倚,也未损害ThyPRO的准确性,两种版本均可用于未来研究。
要点
- 瞬时评分与1周及4周回忆版ThyPRO评分均高度相关。
- 将回忆期从4周缩短至1周未减少回忆偏倚,也未损害准确性。
- 瞬时评分 consistently 低于回忆评分,提示回忆评分可能高估症状。
核心结论
- 将ThyPRO的回忆期从4周缩短至1周在该子集条目中未减少回忆偏倚,1周回忆版也未损害ThyPRO的准确性,因此两种版本均可用于未来研究。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入122例新诊断甲状腺毒症患者,在28天研究期内每日三次通过智能手机回答瞬时问题,每周回答1周回忆版调查,第28天回答原始4周回忆版调查,使用来自4个多条目量表的12个ThyPRO条目。
主要发现
- 瞬时评分的均值与回忆评分高度相关,将报告期从4周改为1周时保持相当恒定。
- 瞬时评分 consistently 低于回忆评分(即甲状腺相关生活质量更好),两种回忆期的瞬时与回忆评分平均差异相似。
- 原始4周ThyPRO准确汇总了所有1周ThyPRO的均值。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,1周或4周回忆版的ThyPRO均可用于未来研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Background: The thyroid-related patient-reported outcome measure ThyPRO has become the gold standard for measuring thyroid-related quality of life and uses a 4-week recall period. The impact of the length of recall is unresolved. To minimize recall bias, the US Food and Drug Administration has argued in favor of short recall periods or measures describing current states. We investigated whether a 1-week recall version of ThyPRO was less prone to recall bias than the original ThyPRO, using averaged momentary ThyPRO measurements as the hypothesized true mean of patients' symptoms. Methods: Patients newly diagnosed with thyrotoxicosis were included (N = 122). During a 28-day study period, participants answered momentary questions three times daily via a smartphone, weekly retrospective surveys with a 1-week recall period, and the original survey with a 4-week recall period on day 28. Twelve ThyPRO items from four multi-item scales were used. Mean momentary ratings for each scale were compared with recall ratings of 1- and 4-week periods, respectively. Results: The mean momentary ratings were highly correlated with retrospective ratings and remained rather constant when altering the reporting period from four weeks to one week. We found consistently lower scores (i.e., better thyroid-related quality of life) on momentary ratings compared with retrospective ratings. The mean differences between momentary ratings and retrospective ratings were similar for both recall periods. The original 4-week ThyPRO accurately summarized the mean of all 1-week ThyPROs. Conclusions: Shortening the recall period of ThyPRO from four weeks to one week was not associated with less recall bias within this subset of items. Nor did 1-week recall seem to compromise the accuracy of ThyPRO. Thus, either version of ThyPRO can be used in future studies.
引用
- Boesen VB, Feldt-Rasmussen U, Bjorner JB, et al. Shorter Recall Period for the Thyroid-Related Patient-Reported Outcome Measure ThyPRO Did Not Change the Accuracy as Evaluated by Repeated Momentary Measurements. Thyroid. 2020. PMID: 31928182. doi:10.1089/thy.2019.0380
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。