文献速递甲状腺疾病

甲状腺结节超声特征及分类系统评估的观察者间与观察者内一致性:一项盲法多中心研究

Inter- and Intraobserver Agreement in the Assessment of Thyroid Nodule Ultrasound Features and Classification Systems: A Blinded Multicenter Study.
PubMed 文献 · Thyroid · 2020-01-01

该盲法多中心研究由三个大容量甲状腺中心的七名放射科和内分泌科医生对100幅甲状腺结节超声图像进行评估,4个月后重复评估。观察者间一致性Kappa系数在0.11至0.53之间,观察者内一致性在0.33至0.62之间,观察者内重复性尚可,但观察者间一致性低于单中心试验。

要点

  • 观察者间超声特征Kappa系数:成分0.53,回声0.47,边缘0.33。
  • 观察者间分类系统Kappa系数:AACE 0.44,ACR-TIRADS 0.42,EU-TIRADS 0.39,ATA 0.34。
  • 观察者内分类系统Kappa系数:AACE 0.54,ACR-TIRADS 0.49,ATA 0.38,EU-TIRADS 0.33。

核心结论

  • 甲状腺结节超声报告和超声分类系统的观察者内重复性尚可,但不同中心间的观察者间一致性低于单中心试验。

研究设计与样本

  • 盲法分析三个大容量甲状腺中心的100幅电子记录甲状腺结节超声图像,由七名放射科和内分泌科医生评估,4个月后随机重复评估。

主要发现

  • 观察者间超声特征Kappa系数:成分0.53,回声0.47,结节内血流0.46,边缘0.33。
  • 观察者间回声灶Kappa系数:微钙化0.47,粗钙化0.38,彗尾伪影亚类0.11,形状0.42。
  • 操作者在16%的病例中对高回声灶定义不确定,并将其描述为「意义不确定的高回声灶」。
  • 观察者间分类系统Kappa系数:AACE 0.44,ACR-TIRADS 0.42,EU-TIRADS 0.39,ATA 0.34。
  • 观察者内超声特征Kappa系数:结节内血流0.62,成分0.58,回声0.60,粗钙化0.54,微钙化0.55,彗尾0.47,边缘0.39,形状0.35。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Background: Single-center trials demonstrated moderate-substantial level of interobserver agreement in the evaluation of ultrasound (US) features of thyroid nodules. Multicenter studies on US agreement, however, are scanty, and data on intraobserver agreement are poor. Aim of the study was to assess inter- and intraobserver agreement between different thyroid centers and different specialists. Methods: A blinded analysis of 100 electronically recorded thyroid nodule US images was conducted in three large-volume thyroid centers by seven radiologists and endocrinologists. The evaluation was repeated after randomization 4 months later. The following US characteristics were evaluated: composition, echogenicity, margins, intranodular echogenic spots, vascularity, and shape. Thyroid nodules were also classified according to AACE/ACE/AME, EU-TIRADS, ATA, and ACR-TIRADS US classifications. Intra- and interobserver agreement was calculated using cross-tabulation expressed as mean Cohen's Kappa. Results: Interobserver agreement for US features: K-coefficient was 0.53 for composition, 0.47 for echogenicity, 0.46 for intranodular vascularity, and 0.33 for margins of the nodules. For echogenic foci, the K-coefficient was 0.47 for microcalcifications, 0.38 for macrocalcifications, 0.11 for the subcategory comet-tail artifacts, and 0.42 for shape. Operators resulted uncertain on hyperechoic foci definition in 16% of cases and described them as "hyperechoic foci of uncertain significance." Interobserver Cohen-K for US classification systems was 0.44 for AACE, 0.42 for ACR-TIRADS, 0.39 EU-TIRADS, and 0.34 for ATA. Intraobserver agreement: the K-coefficient for nodule US features was 0.62 for intranodular vascularity, 0.58 for composition, 0.60 for echogenicity, 0.54 for macrocalcifications, 0.55 for microcalcifications, 0.47 for comet tails, 0.39 for margins, and 0.35 for shape. Intraobserver Cohen-K for US classification systems was 0.54 for AACE, 0.49 for ACR-TIRADS, 0.38 for ATA, and 0.33 for EU-TIRADS. Conclusions: Intraobserver reproducibility for thyroid nodule US reporting and US classification systems appears fairly adequate, while the interobserver agreement between different centers is lower than that assessed in single-center trials. Reporting and rating ability of thyroid US examiners still appear not consistent. An unified lexicon of thyroid US features, a simplified method of classification, and a dedicated training in the description of thyroid US findings may increase the observers' agreement and the predictive value of US classification systems in real world practice.

来源:Thyroid,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Persichetti A, Di Stasio E, Coccaro C, et al. Inter- and Intraobserver Agreement in the Assessment of Thyroid Nodule Ultrasound Features and Classification Systems: A Blinded Multicenter Study. Thyroid. 2020. PMID: 31952456. doi:10.1089/thy.2019.0360

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。