文献速递糖尿病肥胖与代谢综合征

红肉与加工肉类及健康风险:证据强度如何?

Red and Processed Meats and Health Risks: How Strong Is the Evidence?
PubMed 文献 · Diabetes Care · 2020-01-01

本文评述NutriRECS consortium基于GRADE标准提出的红肉与加工肉类“新膳食指南”,认为其方法学存在缺陷且误读营养证据。作者引用NutriGRADE评级指出红肉与加工肉类和2型糖尿病关联的证据为高质量,与死亡率关联的证据为中等质量,并强调膳食指南应继续推荐低红肉与加工肉类、高低度加工植物性食物的膳食模式。

要点

  • NutriRECS基于GRADE“低确定性”证据建议维持当前肉类摄入,作者认为该推荐方法学有缺陷且不成立。
  • 按NutriGRADE评级,红肉与加工肉类和2型糖尿病关联的证据为高质量,与死亡率关联的证据为中等质量。
  • 作者认为膳食指南应继续强调低红肉与加工肉类、高低度加工植物性食物的膳食模式。

核心结论

  • 作者认为NutriRECS关于红肉与加工肉类的推荐存在重要方法学局限并误读营养证据,膳食指南应继续强调低红肉与加工肉类、高低度加工植物性食物的膳食模式。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为针对NutriRECS consortium所提“新膳食指南”的方法学评述,未报告系统检索范围与样本量。

主要发现

  • NutriRECS以证据“低确定性”、改变肉食者习惯与偏好困难及无需考虑红肉消费环境影响为由,鼓励个人维持当前肉类消费习惯。
  • 作者指出该证据评价主要基于GRADE标准,而GRADE主要设计用于评定临床干预尤其是药物治疗的证据强度。
  • 作者指出对多数膳食、生活方式和环境暴露而言,难以开展大型长期随机临床试验,使GRADE标准在这些领域不适用。
  • 作者引用另一研究组提出的改良并经验证的营养研究Meta证据评级系统NutriGRADE,以解决GRADE标准的若干局限。
  • 应用NutriGRADE,红肉与加工肉类和2型糖尿病正关联的证据被评为“高质量”,红肉与加工肉类和死亡率关联的证据被评为“中等质量”。

关键数值与推荐

  • 应用NutriGRADE,红肉与加工肉类和2型糖尿病正关联的证据评级为“高质量”。
  • 应用NutriGRADE,红肉与加工肉类和死亡率关联的证据评级为“中等质量”。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为膳食指南应继续强调低红肉与加工肉类、高低度加工植物性食物(如水果、蔬菜、全谷物、坚果和豆类)的膳食模式,以改善人类与地球健康。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Prevailing dietary guidelines have widely recommended diets relatively low in red and processed meats and high in minimally processed plant foods for the prevention of chronic diseases. However, an ad hoc research group called the Nutritional Recommendations (NutriRECS) consortium recently issued "new dietary guidelines" encouraging individuals to continue their current meat consumption habits due to "low certainty" of the evidence, difficulty of altering meat eaters' habits and preferences, and the lack of need to consider environmental impacts of red meat consumption. These recommendations are not justified, in large part because of the flawed methodologies used to review and grade nutritional evidence. The evidence evaluation was largely based on the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) criteria, which are primarily designed to grade the strength of evidence for clinical interventions especially pharmacotherapy. However, the infeasibility for conducting large, long-term randomized clinical trials on most dietary, lifestyle, and environmental exposures makes the criteria inappropriate in these areas. A separate research group proposed a modified and validated system for rating the meta-evidence on nutritional studies (NutriGRADE) to address several limitations of the GRADE criteria. Applying NutriGRADE, the evidence on the positive association between red and processed meats and type 2 diabetes was rated to be of "high quality," while the evidence on the association between red and processed meats and mortality was rated to be of "moderate quality." Another important limitation is that inadequate attention was paid to what might be replacing red meat, be it plant-based proteins, refined carbohydrates, or other foods. In summary, the red/processed meat recommendations by NutriRECS suffer from important methodological limitations and involve misinterpretations of nutritional evidence. To improve human and planetary health, dietary guidelines should continue to emphasize dietary patterns low in red and processed meats and high in minimally processed plant foods such as fruits and vegetables, whole grains, nuts, and legumes.

来源:Diabetes Care,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Qian F, Riddle MC, Wylie-Rosett J, et al. Red and Processed Meats and Health Risks: How Strong Is the Evidence? Diabetes Care. 2020. PMID: 31959642. doi:10.2337/dci19-0063

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。