牙科X线与甲状腺癌及脑膜瘤风险:系统综述与荟萃分析
该研究检索Medline、Embase和Web of Science数据库,纳入26项研究共10,868例癌症患者,采用随机效应荟萃分析评估牙科X线与头颈部肿瘤风险的关联。结果显示,多次或反复牙科X线暴露与甲状腺癌风险升高(合并RR=1.87,95%CI 1.11-3.15)及脑膜瘤风险升高(合并RR=1.53,95%CI 1.26-1.85)显著相关,与胶质瘤无关联。
要点
- 多次或反复牙科X线暴露与甲状腺癌风险升高相关(合并RR=1.87)。
- 多次或反复牙科X线暴露与脑膜瘤风险升高相关(合并RR=1.53)。
- 牙科X线与胶质瘤无关联,其他头颈部肿瘤研究过少无法合并分析。
核心结论
- 基于回顾性病例对照研究的荟萃分析,多次或反复牙科X线暴露可能与甲状腺癌和脑膜瘤风险升高相关。
- 随着甲状腺屏蔽和技術设备改进,甲状腺所受辐射已大幅下降,个体层面风险可能很低,但暴露人群比例高。
- 需要基于牙科X线记录和患者随访的前瞻性研究进一步验证该假设。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与荟萃分析,检索Medline、Embase和Web of Science数据库。
- 检索共识别5537篇文献,最终纳入26项研究、10,868例癌症患者。
- 甲状腺癌分析基于7项研究(6项病例对照、1项队列),脑膜瘤分析基于8项病例对照研究。
- 采用随机效应荟萃分析计算合并风险比(RR)及95%置信区间。
主要发现
- 多次或反复牙科X线暴露与甲状腺癌风险升高显著相关,合并RR=1.87(95%CI 1.11-3.15)。
- 多次或反复牙科X线暴露与脑膜瘤风险升高显著相关,合并RR=1.53(95%CI 1.26-1.85)。
- 牙科X线与胶质瘤无关联。
- 其他头颈部肿瘤研究数量过少,无法进行有意义的荟萃分析。
关键数值与推荐
- 甲状腺癌合并RR=1.87(95%CI 1.11-3.15),基于7项研究。
- 脑膜瘤合并RR=1.53(95%CI 1.26-1.85),基于8项病例对照研究。
- 发达国家约三分之一的一般人群每年常规接受一次或多次牙科X线检查。
临床怎么用
- 提示临床应尽可能减少诊断性辐射暴露,牙科X线检查中注意甲状腺防护。
- 对多次或反复接受牙科X线暴露者,可将甲状腺癌和脑膜瘤风险纳入长期健康评估考量。
- 个体层面风险尤其在使用改进技术设备后可能很低,但人群暴露比例高,需关注公共卫生层面的辐射防护。
局限性
- 纳入研究未包含个体器官剂量和暴露时年龄。
- 研究存在回忆偏倚及其他局限性。
- 结论主要基于回顾性病例对照研究,需前瞻性研究进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Background: Exposure to moderate-to-high doses of ionizing radiation is the only established environmental risk factor for thyroid cancer and brain and central nervous system tumors. Considering the high lifetime prevalence and frequency of exposure to dental X-rays, the most common source of diagnostic radiation exposure in the general population, even a small associated increase in cancer risk would be of considerable public health importance. With the objective to inform clinical practice and guidelines, we synthesized the current epidemiological evidence on the association between dental X-rays and the risk of thyroid cancer, meningioma, and other cancers of the head and neck region. Methods: The Medline, Embase, and Web of Science databases were searched to identify eligible studies. Summary odds ratio/relative risk estimates and confidence intervals were extracted, and pooled risk ratios (RRs) for each cancer were calculated using random effects meta-analysis. Results: The literature search identified 5537 publications; of these, 26 studies including 10,868 cancer patients were included in the synthesis. The random effects meta-analyses, based on seven studies of thyroid cancer (six case/control, one cohort) and eight studies of meningioma (all case/control), showed that multiple (or repeated) exposures to dental X-rays were significantly associated with an increased risk of thyroid cancer (pooled RR = 1.87 [95% confidence interval, CI 1.11-3.15]) and meningioma (pooled RR = 1.53 [CI 1.26-1.85]). There was no association with glioma, and there were too few studies of other cancers of the head and neck region to conduct a meaningful meta-analysis. Conclusions: Based on a meta-analysis of retrospective case/control studies, these findings provide some support to the hypothesis that multiple (or repeated) exposures to dental X-rays may be associated with an increased risk of thyroid cancer and meningioma. These studies did not include individual organ doses and ages at exposure, and are subject to recall bias and other limitations. Furthermore, the thyroid exposure has decreased dramatically over time from the use of thyroid shields and improved technology/equipment. Prospective studies, based on dental X-ray records and patient follow-up, are needed to test the hypothesis further and clarify the possible cancer risk associated with dental radiography, as although the risk at the individual level, particularly with improved technology/equipment, is likely to be very low, the proportion of the population exposed is high. Considering that about one-third of the general population in developed countries is routinely exposed to one or more dental X-rays per year, these findings manifest the need to reduce diagnostic radiation exposure as much as possible.
引用
- Memon A, Rogers I, Paudyal P, et al. Dental X-Rays and the Risk of Thyroid Cancer and Meningioma: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Current Epidemiological Evidence. Thyroid. 2019. PMID: 31502516. doi:10.1089/thy.2019.0105
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。