预测并减少1型糖尿病驾驶者的驾驶事故
研究开发并验证了11条目《糖尿病驾驶者风险评估(RADD)》量表,用于识别1型糖尿病驾驶事故高危者;并对高危者随机给予常规护理或在线干预DiabetesDriving.com。RADD区分高低危驾驶者,DD.com减少低血糖相关驾驶事故,但未降至低危水平。
要点
- RADD量表以61%灵敏度和75%特异度识别未来12个月驾驶事故高危的1型糖尿病驾驶者。
- RADD高危者驾驶事故3.03次/人/年 vs 低危者0.87次/人/年(P<0.001)。
- DD.com在线干预使高危者低血糖相关驾驶事故较高危常规护理者减少(P=0.01),缩小高低危差距63%。
核心结论
- RADD可识别较高风险的驾驶者,且识别在不同时间、样本和流程间似乎相对稳定;该11条目问卷可告知较高风险患者及其临床医生应采取预防措施减少驾驶事故,这一目标在目标B中通过DD.com实现。
研究设计与样本
- 研究1:来自美国三个地区的371名1型糖尿病驾驶者完成问卷并记录随后12个月驾驶事故,用于构建RADD量表。
- 研究2:来自美国全部50个州的1737名1型糖尿病驾驶者在线完成RADD;其中118名低危和372名高危驾驶者符合条件并同意参加2个月治疗期及随后12个月每月记录驾驶事故。
- 研究2中高危参与者随机接受常规护理或在线干预DiabetesDriving.com;DD.com参与者中一半在治疗期开始和结束时接受动机性访谈;所有低危参与者分配至常规护理。
主要发现
- 研究1中RADD的灵敏度为61%,特异度为75%。
- 研究1中RADD分布上三分之一(高危)参与者 vs 下三分之一(低危)参与者驾驶事故分别为3.03 vs 0.87次/人/年(P<0.001)。
- 研究2中接受常规护理的高危和低危参与者驾驶事故分别为4.3和1.6次/人/年(P<0.001)。
- 研究2中动机性访谈未增强参与度或疗效,故将DD.com和DD.com+动机性访谈组合并;DD.com参与者报告的低血糖相关驾驶事故少于接受常规护理的高危参与者(P=0.01),但多于接受常规护理的低危参与者,使接受常规护理的高危与低危参与者之间的差异缩小63%。
- 高危驾驶者在基线时在多种低血糖和驾驶参数上与低危驾驶者不同。
关键数值与推荐
- RADD量表包含11个条目。
- RADD灵敏度61%,特异度75%。
- RADD高危者驾驶事故3.03次/人/年 vs 低危者0.87次/人/年(P<0.001)。
- 常规护理下高危者驾驶事故4.3次/人/年 vs 低危者1.6次/人/年(P<0.001)。
- DD.com vs 高危常规护理:低血糖相关驾驶事故P=0.01,高低危差距缩小63%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为RADD问卷可告知较高风险患者及其临床医生应采取预防措施减少驾驶事故。
- 作者在目标B中通过DD.com在线干预减少高危驾驶者的低血糖相关驾驶事故。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Two aims of this study were to develop and validate A) a metric to identify drivers with type 1 diabetes at high risk of future driving mishaps and B) an online intervention to reduce mishaps among high-risk drivers. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS: To achieve aim A, in study 1, 371 drivers with type 1 diabetes from three U.S. regions completed a series of established questionnaires about diabetes and driving. They recorded their driving mishaps over the next 12 months. Questionnaire items that uniquely discriminated drivers who did and did not have subsequent driving mishaps were assembled into the Risk Assessment of Diabetic Drivers (RADD) scale. In study 2, 1,737 drivers with type 1 diabetes from all 50 states completed the RADD online. Among these, 118 low-risk (LR) and 372 high-risk (HR) drivers qualified for and consented to participate in a 2-month treatment period followed by 12 monthly recordings of driving mishaps. To address aim B, HR participants were randomized to receive either routine care (RC) or the online intervention "DiabetesDriving.com" (DD.com). Half of the DD.com participants received a motivational interview (MI) at the beginning and end of the treatment period to boost participation and efficacy. All of the LR participants were assigned to RC. In both studies, the primary outcome variable was driving mishaps. RESULTS: Related to aim A, in study 1, the RADD demonstrated 61% sensitivity and 75% specificity. Participants in the upper third of the RADD distribution (HR), compared with those in the lower third (LR), reported 3.03 vs. 0.87 mishaps/driver/year, respectively (P < 0.001). In study 2, HR and LR participants receiving RC reported 4.3 and 1.6 mishaps/driver/year, respectively (P < 0.001). Related to aim B, in study 2, MIs did not enhance participation or efficacy, so the DD.com and DD.com + MI groups were combined. DD.com participants reported fewer hypoglycemia-related driving mishaps than HR participants receiving RC (P = 0.01), but more than LR participants receiving RC, reducing the difference between the HR and LR participants receiving RC by 63%. HR drivers differed from LR drivers at baseline across a variety of hypoglycemia and driving parameters. CONCLUSIONS: The RADD identified higher-risk drivers, and identification seemed relatively stable across time, samples, and procedures. This 11-item questionnaire could inform patients at higher risk, and their clinicians, that they should take preventive steps to reduce driving mishaps, which was accomplished in aim B using DD.com.
引用
- Cox DJ, Gonder-Frederick LA, Singh H, et al. Predicting and Reducing Driving Mishaps Among Drivers With Type 1 Diabetes. Diabetes Care. 2017. PMID: 28404657. doi:10.2337/dc16-0995
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。