在低收入糖尿病受访者中,高免赔额与无免赔额保险相比大幅减少医疗服务使用
研究利用2011-2013年医疗支出面板调查比较私人保险及免赔额大小对成年糖尿病受访者医疗服务使用、健康状况和医疗债务的影响,按收入和免赔额分组(N=1461)。结果显示,低收入受访者中,低免赔额与无免赔额相比,初级保健、体检和专科就诊分别降低27%、39%和77%,高免赔额则分别降低42%、65%和86%;医疗债务相似,但低收入且负债者延迟服务使用是无负债者的两倍。
要点
- 低收入糖尿病受访者中,高免赔额与无免赔额相比,初级保健、体检和专科就诊分别降低42%、65%和86%。
- 低免赔额与无免赔额相比,低收入受访者初级保健、体检和专科就诊分别降低27%、39%和77%。
- 医疗债务在不同收入间相似,但低收入且负债者延迟服务使用是无负债者的两倍。
核心结论
- 私人保险附带免赔额会大幅减少低收入投保糖尿病受访者的医疗服务使用,高免赔额时尤为明显;这些患者更可能报告放弃所需医疗服务。
研究设计与样本
- 利用2011-2013年医疗支出面板调查,对18-64岁私人保险成年糖尿病受访者(N=1461)按收入(低于联邦贫困线200%与不低于200%)和免赔额(无、低免赔额1000/2400美元、高免赔额>1000/2400美元)进行双变量和回归分析。
- 利用2012-2014年全国健康访谈调查分析成年糖尿病受访者(n=4058)按收入的医疗债务和延迟/避免所需医疗服务的差异。
主要发现
- 与无免赔额相比,低免赔额低收入受访者初级保健、体检和专科就诊分别降低27%、39%和77%,高免赔额分别降低42%、65%和86%。
- 高收入受访者中,低免赔额与无免赔额相比,专科就诊降低28%,急诊就诊降低37%。
- 糖尿病护理措施在不同收入和保险间相似,身体健康状况无变化。
- 医疗债务在不同收入间相似,但低收入且负债者延迟服务使用是无负债者的两倍。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To contrast the effect of private insurance and deductibles (by size) on medical service use, health status, and medical debt for adult respondents with diabetes with low and high incomes. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS: Using the 2011-2013 Medical Expenditure Panel Survey, bivariate and regression analyses were conducted to compare demographic characteristics, medical service use, diabetes care, and health status among privately insured adult respondents with diabetes, aged 18-64 years (N = 1,461) by lower (<200% of the federal poverty level) and higher (≥200% of the federal poverty level) income and deductible vs. no deductible (ND), low deductible ($1,000/$2,400) (LD), and high deductible (>$1,000/$2,400) (HD). The National Health Interview Survey 2012-2014 was used to analyze differences in medical debt and delayed/avoided needed care among adult respondents with diabetes (n = 4,058) by income. RESULTS: Compared with privately insured respondents with diabetes with ND, privately insured lower-income respondents with diabetes with an LD report significant decreases in service use for primary care, checkups, and specialty visits (27%, 39%, and 77% lower, respectively), and respondents with an HD decrease use by 42%, 65%, and 86%, respectively. Higher-income respondents with an LD report significant decreases in specialty (28%) and emergency department (37%) visits. Diabetes care measures are similar by income and insurance; there were no changes in physical health status. Medical debt is similar by income, but deferred service use is two times greater for those indebted and with lower income. CONCLUSIONS: Private insurance with a deductible substantially and problematically reduces medical service use for lower-income insured respondents with diabetes who have an HD; these patients are more likely to report forgoing needed medical services.
引用
- Rabin DL, Jetty A, Petterson S, et al. Among Low-Income Respondents With Diabetes, High-Deductible Versus No-Deductible Insurance Sharply Reduces Medical Service Use. Diabetes Care. 2016. PMID: 27956384. doi:10.2337/dc16-1579
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。