指南与共识糖尿病

1型糖尿病胰岛素注射调整的医师间与医师内变异及与贝叶斯算法建议的比较

Inter- and intra-physician variability in insulin injection adjustments compared with Bayesian algorithm recommendations in type 1 diabetes.
指南 / 共识 · Diabetologia · 2025-12-15

该研究调查13名加拿大内分泌科医生对回顾性1型糖尿病数据做模拟胰岛素调整,比较医生间及医生自身前后调整方向的一致性,并与McGill决策支持系统的贝叶斯算法比较。结果显示算法与医生在餐时和大剂量胰岛素调整方向上的同意率非劣于医生彼此间,且医生自身重复决策一致性约66%–67%,提示胰岛素管理主观性较大。

要点

  • 算法与医生在餐时及基础胰岛素调整方向上的同意率非劣于医生间同意率。
  • 医生自身前后对相同数据集的完全同意率约66%–67%,提示医师内变异大。
  • 完全不同意率在餐时和基础胰岛素上算法与医生间相当。

核心结论

  • 医生与McGill算法在胰岛素调整方向上具有可比性,且医师内变异较大进一步强调胰岛素管理的主观性。

研究设计与样本

  • 对13名加拿大内分泌科医生进行问卷调查,基于回顾性参与者数据做模拟胰岛素调整,分三部分比较医生与算法建议及医生自身前后一致性。

主要发现

  • Part A中算法与医生在每周餐时大剂量调整方向上的同意率(均值[SD])为55%[5] vs 56%[7],非劣效p=0.006。
  • Part A中算法与医生在每周基础胰岛素调整方向上的同意率为48%[6] vs 51%[11],非劣效p=0.037。
  • Part A中餐时大剂量完全不同意率为3.9%[2.3] vs 4.1%[2.3](p=0.006),基础胰岛素为10.6%[4.6] vs 9.2%[7.1](p=0.23)。
  • Part C双周调整观察到类似比率;Part A与Part B比较,医生自身对餐时和基础胰岛素调整的完全同意率平均为66%[SD 7]和67%[SD 7]。

临床怎么用

  • McGill决策支持系统可能作为每日多次注射1型糖尿病患者的自动化调整辅助工具,但需注意医生决策本身的主观变异。

局限性

  • 原文未明确报告研究局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS/HYPOTHESIS: There is an unmet need for automated insulin adjustments for multiple daily injections in type 1 diabetes under unsupervised use. We aimed to assess the McGill decision support system (DSS), which comprises a Bayesian algorithm, by comparing its automated insulin adjustments with those made by endocrinologists. METHODS: We surveyed 13 Canadian endocrinologists who made mock insulin adjustments in three separate parts on retrospective participants' data. Part A (weekly data) and part C (biweekly data) compared the recommendations from physicians with those of the algorithm. Part B evaluated intra-physician variability by comparing the recommendations made by the same physician over time based on an identical dataset to part A. RESULTS: In part A, the agreement rate (mean [SD]) on the direction of weekly adjustments between the algorithm and physicians was non-inferior to the agreement rate between physicians for prandial bolus (55% [5] vs 56% [7], respectively; p=0.006) and basal insulin (48% [6] vs 51% [11], respectively; p=0.037). Low full disagreement rates on weekly adjustments were also comparable between the pairs for prandial bolus (3.9% [2.3] vs 4.1% [2.3], respectively; p=0.006) and basal insulin (10.6% [4.6] vs 9.2% [7.1], respectively; p=0.23). Similar rates were observed for biweekly insulin adjustments in part C. When comparing intra-physician decisions in part A with those in part B, on average, physicians fully agreed with themselves 66% (SD 7) and 67% (SD 7) of the time for prandial bolus and basal insulin adjustments, respectively. CONCLUSIONS/INTERPRETATION: The direction of insulin adjustments was comparable between physicians and the McGill algorithm. The large intra-physician variability further emphasises the subjective nature of insulin management.

来源:Diabetologia,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kobayati A, Tsoukas MA, Garfield N, et al. Inter- and intra-physician variability in insulin injection adjustments compared with Bayesian algorithm recommendations in type 1 diabetes. Diabetologia. 2025. PMID: 41396299. doi:10.1007/s00125-025-06627-9

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。