文献速递糖尿病

航空变化气压下1型糖尿病连续血糖监测与自我血糖监测的比较:低压飞行模拟研究

Comparison of continuous glucose monitoring with self-monitoring of blood glucose in type 1 diabetes in the changing atmospheric pressures in aviation: a hypobaric flight simulation.
PubMed 文献 · Diabetologia · 2025-01-31

研究在低压飞行模拟中比较1型糖尿病胰岛素泵使用者连续血糖监测(CGM)与自我血糖监测(SMBG)的准确性。12名参与者按两套方案测试,飞行与地面相比CGM与SMBG相关性均很强,CGM平均绝对相对差异(MARD)在飞行与地面间差异极小。结论认为飞行相关气压变化下CGM与SMBG表现相当,所有测试设备均适用于飞行模拟中的糖尿病管理决策。

要点

  • 飞行与地面相比,CGM与SMBG的Spearman相关性在方案A(飞行r=0.96 vs 地面r=0.94)和方案B(飞行r=0.85 vs 地面r=0.69)均很强。
  • CGM聚合MARD在飞行与地面间差异极小:方案A飞行11.85%(95%CI 9.78-13.92)vs 地面9.08%(95%CI 7.02-11.14)。
  • 方案B飞行MARD 12.01%(95%CI 3.34-20.69)vs 地面12.97%(95%CI 4.30-21.65),所有CGM与SMBG设备均适用于飞行模拟中的糖尿病管理决策。

核心结论

  • 飞行相关气压变化下CGM系统与SMBG表现相当。
  • 所有测试的CGM与SMBG设备均适用于飞行模拟中的糖尿病管理决策。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入12名1型糖尿病胰岛素泵使用者(方案A:6名男性;方案B:5名男性与1名女性),采用两套飞行模拟方案。
  • 方案A包括地面阶段、上升、190分钟巡航并进食液体餐、下降和地面;方案B包括地面、上升、60分钟禁食巡航、下降、20分钟地面、上升、120分钟进食第二段飞行、下降和地面。
  • 两方案中胰岛素根据参与者碳水化合物计数方案在餐时或餐前给予;方案A在飞行和地面测毛细血管、组织间液和血浆葡萄糖,方案B测葡萄糖和氧。
  • 记录三种CGM品牌和两种SMBG设备的数据,比较飞行舱压550 mmHg与地面750 mmHg的结果,用Spearman相关和MARD分析空腹与餐后血糖。

主要发现

  • 共记录1533个数据点。
  • 飞行与地面相比,CGM与SMBG的Spearman相关性在方案A为飞行r=0.96 vs 地面r=0.94,在方案B为飞行r=0.85 vs 地面r=0.69。
  • CGM聚合MARD在飞行与地面间差异极小:方案A飞行11.85%(95%CI 9.78, 13.92)vs 地面9.08%(95%CI 7.02, 11.14)。
  • 方案B飞行MARD 12.01%(95%CI 3.34, 20.69)vs 地面12.97%(95%CI 4.30, 21.65)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者结论认为,所有测试的CGM与SMBG设备均适用于飞行模拟中的糖尿病管理决策。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM/HYPOTHESIS: Pilots with type 1 diabetes are required to perform capillary glucose monitoring regularly during flights. Continuous glucose monitoring (CGM) may be an effective and more practical alternative. This study aimed to assess the accuracy of CGM systems against self-monitoring of blood glucose (SMBG) during a hypobaric flight simulation. METHODS: Twelve insulin pump users with type 1 diabetes were studied using two simulation protocols. Protocol A consisted of a ground phase, ascent, a 190 min cruise with ingestion of a liquid meal, descent and then ground. Protocol B consisted of a ground phase, ascent, a 60 min cruise while fasting, descent, a 20 min ground phase, ascent, a second flight of 120 min with ingestion of a meal, followed by descent and ground. Insulin was administered with or before the meal according to the participants' carbohydrate-counting regimen during both protocols. In Protocol A, capillary, interstitial and plasma glucose were measured during flight and at ground, while in Protocol B, glucose and oxygen were measured. Measurements from three CGM brands and two SMBG devices were recorded during the flight simulations. Findings at cabin pressures during flight (550 mmHg) and ground (750 mmHg) were compared. Fasted and postprandial glucose measurements were analysed using Spearman's correlations and mean absolute relative differences (MARDs). RESULTS: Eleven men and one woman (n=6 men in Protocol A; n=5 men and n=1 woman in Protocol B) were studied. A total of 1533 data points were recorded. During flight vs ground level, Spearman's correlations for CGM system- and SMBG-derived glucose values were very strong in both Protocol A (r=0.96 during flight vs r=0.94 at ground) and Protocol B (r=0.85 during flight vs r=0.69 at ground). The differences in aggregated CGM MARDs during flight vs ground level were minimal across Protocol A (11.85%; 95% CI [9.78, 13.92] vs 9.08%; 95% CI [7.02, 11.14]) and Protocol B (12.01%; 95% CI [3.34, 20.69] vs 12.97%; 95% CI [4.30, 21.65]). CONCLUSIONS/INTERPRETATION: The performance of CGM systems and SMBG are comparable during flight-associated atmospheric pressure changes. All tested measurement devices for CGM and SMBG were suitable for diabetes-care-based decisions during flight simulation.

来源:Diabetologia,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fan KS, Manoli A, Baumann PM, et al. Comparison of continuous glucose monitoring with self-monitoring of blood glucose in type 1 diabetes in the changing atmospheric pressures in aviation: a hypobaric flight simulation. Diabetologia. 2025. PMID: 39888427. doi:10.1007/s00125-025-06364-z

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。