外科医生最大化医疗偏好与低风险甲状腺癌更广泛手术推荐相关
该混合模式横断面调查于2020年9月向222名甲状腺外科医生发放问卷,评估其对健康45岁女性单发2.0cm甲状腺乳头状癌的手术推荐及最大化-最小化医疗偏好。149名应答者(应答率67.1%)中34.9%推荐全甲状腺切除伴或不伴中央颈淋巴结清扫,65.1%推荐腺叶切除;
要点
- 149名外科医生中34.9%推荐全甲状腺切除伴或不伴中央颈淋巴结清扫,65.1%推荐腺叶切除。
- 推荐全切者最大化-最小化评分显著高于推荐腺叶切除者(25.9±7.2 vs 23.8±6.4,p=0.03)。
核心结论
- 医学最大化-最小化倾向可能是解释过度诊断、过度治疗和过度筛查持续存在的众多未测量外科医生特征之一。
- 外科医生可能受益于意识到自身倾向如何影响其对低风险甲状腺癌患者的手术推荐。
研究设计与样本
- 混合模式横断面调查,于2020年9月通过邮件和电子邮件向222名在医疗保险和医疗补助服务中心提供者利用与支付医师及其他从业者数据集中识别的甲状腺外科医生发放问卷。
- 参与者被询问对一名健康45岁女性单发2.0cm甲状腺乳头状癌的治疗推荐。
- 外科医生接受简明担忧量表和经过验证的癌症相关担忧单项测量评估,并使用临床医生最大化-最小化量表评估其倾向于为患者提供医疗服务的程度。
- 参与者根据对最大化-最小化量表的反应被分为三分位数,最高评分三分位(最大化者)与两个较低三分位通过Student t检验、卡方检验、方差分析和逻辑回归进行比较。
主要发现
- 149名外科医生应答(应答率67.1%),34.9%推荐全甲状腺切除伴或不伴中央颈淋巴结清扫,65.1%推荐腺叶切除。
- 最大化-最小化量表平均得分为24.6(SD 6.8)。
- 外科医生的年龄、种族、年甲状腺切除量或执业场所按最大化-最小化分类无差异。
- 推荐全甲状腺切除伴或不伴中央颈淋巴结清扫者最大化-最小化评分显著高于推荐腺叶切除者(25.9±7.2 vs 23.8±6.4,p=0.03)。
- 被归类为最大化者在单项和简明担忧量表上均有更多癌症相关担忧(p=0.02)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Background: While patient-level determinants of total thyroidectomy use have been well described, surgeon-level drivers of more extensive surgery are present and less well described. This survey sought to examine the associations between surgeons' operative recommendations, their beliefs about cancer, and their attitudes about medical maximizing-minimizing. Methods: A mixed-mode, cross-sectional survey was administered in September 2020 via mail and email to 222 thyroid surgeons identified in the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Provider Utilization and Payment Physician and Other Practitioners dataset. Participants were asked their treatment recommendation for a healthy 45-year-old woman with a solitary 2.0-cm papillary thyroid cancer. Surgeons were assessed with the Brief Worry Scale and a validated, single-item measure of cancer-related worry. The Clinician Maximizer-Minimizer scale was used to assess the extent of medical care that physicians tend to favor with their patients. Participants were categorized into terciles based on their responses to the Maximizer-Minimizer scale. The highest scoring tercile ("Maximizers") was compared with the two lower terciles by Student's t-tests, chi-square, ANOVA, and logistic regression. Results: Of the 149 surgeons (response rate 67.1%), 34.9% recommended total thyroidectomy with or without central neck dissection (CND), and 65.1% recommended lobectomy. Overall, the medical Maximizer-Minimizer scale had an average score of 24.6 (SD 6.8). There were no differences between surgeons' age, race, annual thyroidectomy volume, or practice setting by their Maximizer-Minimizer classification. Participants who recommended total thyroidectomy with or without CND had significantly higher Maximizer-Minimizer scores than those recommending lobectomy (25.9 ± 7.2 vs. 23.8 ± 6.4, p = 0.03). Those classified as maximizers also had more cancer-related worry on both the single-item and Brief Worry Scales (p = 0.02). On logistic regression controlling for age, sex, race, specialty training, practice setting, and annual thyroidectomy volume, maximizers were still more likely to recommend total thyroidectomy with or without a CND (OR 2.4, [CI 1.01-5.55], p = 0.047). Conclusions: Medical maximizing-minimizing tendencies represent one of potentially many unmeasured surgeon characteristics that may explain persistent patterns of over-diagnosis, over-treatment, and over-screening. Surgeons may benefit from awareness of how their own tendencies influence their surgical recommendations in patients with low-risk thyroid cancer.
引用
- Antunez AG, Saucke MC, Bushaw KJ, et al. Surgeon Preference for Maximizing Medical Care Is Associated with Recommending More Extensive Surgery for Low-Risk Thyroid Cancer. Thyroid. 2024. PMID: 39030827. doi:10.1089/thy.2024.0170
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。