指南与共识重症综合管理与镇静镇痛创伤与烧伤

儿童外科最佳资源2:按卫生系统层级划分的最低必需儿童外科手术分级建议

Optimal Resources for Children's Surgery 2: Tiered Recommendations for Minimum Essential Children's Surgical Procedures Across Health System Levels.
指南 / 共识 · World J Surg · 2026-10-20
一句话结论全球儿童外科倡议组织(GICS)发布OReCS 2,按卫生中心、一级、二级、三级及转诊医院五个层级,为12个亚专科列出最低必需手术能力框架,供资源规划参考。

世界卫生大会2015年通过68:15号决议强化急诊与基本外科及麻醉,但儿童外科代表性不足;GICS于2019年发布OReCS,现发布OReCS 2。方法为文献综述加迭代德尔菲式流程,GICS全体成员参与,覆盖21个工作组、50余个低中收入及高收入国家,收集12个专科组的基本手术数据,执行委员会根据低级别机构实际能力修改建议,最终推荐需>75%受访者同意并经执行委员会审核。结果按层级列出手术能力:卫生中心仅限无需麻醉或镇静的操作,主要用于分诊和稳定后转运;一级医院多数专科以稳定和转运为主,眼科和牙科则有可在低级别机构完成的确定性手术;国家儿童医院级别包括需专科人员和设备的移植、先天性心脏病修复及复杂创伤、先天畸形和烧伤的重建手术。OReCS 2为低中收入国家各层级医院的最低必需物资、设备和人员配置提供定义框架,清单并非穷尽。

要点

  • 卫生中心层级仅限无需麻醉或镇静的操作,主要用于分诊和稳定后转运至高级别机构。
  • 一级医院多数专科以稳定和转运至转诊医院为主;眼科和牙科可在低级别机构完成确定性手术。
  • 国家儿童医院层级包括需专科人员和设备的移植、先天性心脏病修复及复杂创伤、先天畸形和烧伤的重建手术。
  • 最终推荐基于>75%受访者同意并经GICS执行委员会审核,覆盖12个专科组、21个工作组。
  • 清单并非穷尽,旨在为低中收入国家各层级医院最低必需物资、设备和人员提供定义框架。

适用人群与场景

  • 低中收入国家(LMICs)的卫生中心、一级、二级、三级及转诊层级医院中接受外科治疗的儿童。
  • 参与制定者来自21个工作组、50余个低中收入国家及高收入国家。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 卫生中心层级:仅限无需麻醉或镇静的操作,主要用于分诊和稳定后转运至高级别机构。
  • 一级医院层级:多数专科以稳定和转运至转诊医院为主;眼科和牙科可在低级别机构完成确定性手术。
  • 国家儿童医院层级:包括需专科人员和设备的移植、先天性心脏病修复及复杂创伤、先天畸形和烧伤的重建手术。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 制定方法为文献综述加迭代德尔菲式流程,GICS全体成员开放参与,覆盖21个工作组、50余个低中收入及高收入国家,收集12个专科组基本手术数据。
  • 执行委员会根据低级别机构实际能力修改工作组建议,最终推荐需>75%受访者同意并经GICS执行委员会审核。
  • 卫生中心手术限于无需麻醉或镇静的操作,主要用于分诊和稳定后转运。
  • 一级医院多数专科以稳定和转运为主;眼科和牙科可在低级别机构完成确定性手术。
  • 国家儿童医院层级包括需专科人员和设备的移植、先天性心脏病修复及复杂创伤、先天畸形和烧伤的重建手术。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:指南(GICS OReCS 2),基于文献综述与迭代德尔菲式流程制定,最终推荐需>75%同意并经执行委员会审核。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 为低中收入国家各层级医院规划儿童外科最低必需物资、设备和人员提供分层框架。
  • 卫生中心和一级医院以分诊、稳定和转运为核心能力,眼科和牙科可在低级别机构完成确定性手术。
  • 移植、先天性心脏病修复及复杂创伤、先天畸形和烧伤的重建手术需在国家儿童医院层级完成。

指南或共识出处

  • Optimal Resources for Children's Surgery 2: Tiered Recommendations for Minimum Essential Children's Surgical Procedures Across Health System Levels(World J Surg),Global Initiative for Children's Surgery(GICS)。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: In 2015 the World Health Assembly (WHO), based on recommendations by the Lancet Commission on Global Surgery, passed resolution (68:15) on strengthening emergency and essential surgical care and anesthesia as a component of universal health coverage. However, children's surgery was not adequately represented and in response, the Global Initiative for Children's Surgery (GICS) published the Optimal Resources for Children's Surgical Care (OReCS) in 2019 providing insight into procedures which should be performed at different facility types. OReCS 2 addresses a gap in both policy and published literature to further define surgical conditions and procedural capabilities by hospital level.

METHODS: We performed a review of the literature to identify procedures routinely performed in a variety of settings. We then used an iterative Delphi like approach to identify specialty-specific procedures and nursing skills by hospital level. Participation was open to all members of GICS with representation from 21 working groups and more than 50 low-middle income countries (LMICs) and high-income countries (HICs). Data on essential procedures were collected for twelve specialty groups. Modifications of the recommendations provided by the working groups were made by the executive board based on firsthand knowledge of capabilities at lower-level facilities where subspecialists have less experience. Final recommendations were made based on greater than 75% agreement by respondents and review of the executive board of GICS.

RESULTS: Procedures performed at health centers were limited to those not requiring anesthesia or sedation and were largely identified to help triage and stabilize patients for transfer to higher level care. Similarly, first level hospital procedures focused on stabilization and transfer to referral level hospitals for most specialties. Alternatively, specialties such as ophthalmology and dental surgery have identified definitive procedures for lower-level facilities. Procedures performed at the National Children's Hospital level include those requiring specialty providers and equipment such as transplantation, repair of congenital heart disease, and reconstructive surgery for complex trauma, congenital anomalies, and burns.

CONCLUSIONS: This updated version of OReCS provides specific examples of procedural capabilities for twelve subspecialties at the health center, first, second, third, and referral level hospitals in LMICs. Whereas the list is not meant to be all inclusive, it provides a framework within which to define the minimum essential material resources, equipment, and personnel by hospital level.

来源:World J Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Biswangree, Ameh, Lakhoo, et al. Optimal Resources for Children's Surgery 2: Tiered Recommendations for Minimum Essential Children's Surgical Procedures Across Health System Levels. World J Surg. 2026. PMID: 42902539. doi:10.1002/wjs.70630

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。