文献速递重症综合管理与镇静镇痛消化、代谢与肾脏急症

大流行期间按年龄配给医疗资源:各州大流行防范计划的比较分析

Rationing With Respect to Age During a Pandemic: A Comparative Analysis of State Pandemic Preparedness Plans.
PubMed 文献 · Chest · 2021-09-08

该研究对2020年4月至6月美国50个州及华盛顿特区的大流行防范计划进行文本分析,评估其如何纳入按年龄和/或生命年配给资源的标准。各计划在术语和使用上差异很大,许多计划因争议而修改。这对大流行期间老年人等脆弱人群的照护具有伦理意义。

要点

  • 7个州考虑短期预后(≤1年生存),7个州考虑预期生命年1至5年,13个州按总生命年配给,1个州采用「公平一局」原则(特定年龄 cutoff)。
  • 7个州仅提供一般伦理考虑,未涉及年龄/生命年标准。
  • 多个计划大量借鉴少数常见模型,但术语使用不一致,许多文件因争议而修改。
  • 各州在按年龄/生命年配给方面的指导差异很大,超过半数的计划将年龄/生命年作为明确配给标准。

适用人群与场景

  • 美国50个州及华盛顿特区的大流行防范计划(PPP)和大流行危机护理标准(CSC)文件,涉及重症资源(特别是呼吸机)配给。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 计划分类标准:A=按短期生存(≤1年)配给;B=按预期生命年1至5年配给;C=按总生命年配给;D=按「公平一局」原则(特定年龄 cutoff)配给;O=其他。
  • 主要衡量指标:是否使用年龄和/或生命年作为配给标准,并进一步分类是否作为主要考虑因素。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 原文未提及

红旗征与不能漏的情况

  • 原文未提及

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究设计:研究者发起的文本分析,2020年4月至6月进行,查询在线资源和州内联系人,识别50个州及华盛顿特区发布的大流行防范计划,分析截至2020年6月的最新版本CSC文件和官方PPP(包含分诊指导)。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:文本分析(研究者发起),非系统评价或RCT;局限包括:仅分析在线可获取的文件和州内联系人提供的资料,可能未覆盖所有计划版本;术语不一致影响分类;计划可能随时间变化;未评估实际实施情况。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 原文未提及

指南或共识出处

  • 原文未提及具体指南或共识名称;研究分析的是美国各州的大流行防范计划(PPP)和危机护理标准(CSC)文件,截至2020年6月。

以上提炼依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取,或许可不允许翻译转载);全文请点「阅读原文」。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Faced with possible shortages due to COVID-19, many states updated or rapidly developed crisis standards of care (CSCs) and other pandemic preparedness plans (PPPs) for rationing resources, particularly ventilators.

RESEARCH QUESTION: How have US states incorporated the controversial standard of rationing by age and/or life-years into their pandemic preparedness plans?

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: This was an investigator-initiated, textual analysis conducted from April to June 2020, querying online resources and in-state contacts to identify PPPs published by each of the 50 states and for Washington, DC. Analysis included the most recent versions of CSC documents and official state PPPs containing triage guidance as of June 2020. Plans were categorized as rationing by (A) short-term survival (≤ 1 year), (B) 1 to 5 expected life-years, (C) total life-years, (D) "fair innings," that is, specific age cutoffs, or (O) other. The primary measure was any use of age and/or life-years. Plans were further categorized on the basis of whether age/life-years was a primary consideration.

RESULTS: Thirty-five states promulgated PPPs addressing the rationing of critical care resources. Seven states considered short-term prognosis, seven considered whether a patient had 1 to 5 expected life-years, 13 rationed by total life-years, and one used the fair innings principle. Seven states provided only general ethical considerations. Seventeen of the 21 plans considering age/life-years made it a primary consideration. Several plans borrowed heavily from a few common sources, although use of terminology was inconsistent. Many documents were modified in light of controversy.

INTERPRETATION: Guidance with respect to rationing by age and/or life-years varied widely. More than one-half of PPPs, many following a few common models, included age/life-years as an explicit rationing criterion; the majority of these made it a primary consideration. Terminology was often vague, and many plans evolved in response to pushback. These findings have ethical implications for the care of older adults and other vulnerable populations during a pandemic.

来源:Chest,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Scire E, Jeong KY, Gaurke M, et al. Rationing With Respect to Age During a Pandemic: A Comparative Analysis of State Pandemic Preparedness Plans. Chest. 2021. PMID: 34506791. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2021.08.070

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。