持续与常规标准化脑电图对危重成人结局预测:一项随机试验分析
该研究为随机对照试验的回顾性分析,纳入364例急性意识障碍成人ICU患者,随机分为持续EEG组(30-48小时,n=182)和重复20分钟常规EEG组(n=182)。评估脑电特征与6个月死亡率及改良Rankin量表(良好0-2分)的相关性。背景连续性、较高频率和反应性与生存及良好mRS相关;侧化周期性放电与死亡率和不良mRS相关;广泛节律性δ活动与生存、良好mRS及较低癫痫持续状态发生率相关。常规EEG组联合模型预测死亡率PPV为70.91%(95%CI 59.62-80.10%),持续EEG组为84.62%(95%CI 75.02-90.97%)。
要点
- 持续EEG组联合背景连续性、反应性、广泛节律性δ活动和侧化周期性放电的模型预测死亡率PPV为84.62%(95%CI 75.02-90.97),NPV为74.77%(95%CI 68.50-80.16%)。
- 常规EEG组联合背景频率、连续性、反应性、睡眠纺锤和侧化周期性放电的模型预测死亡率PPV为70.91%(95%CI 59.62-80.10%),NPV为63.93%(95%CI 58.67-68.89%)。
- 侧化周期性放电与死亡率和不良改良Rankin量表(3-6分)相关;广泛节律性δ活动与生存、良好改良Rankin量表(0-2分)及较低癫痫持续状态发生率相关。
- 背景连续性、较高频率和反应性与生存及良好改良Rankin量表(0-2分)相关;睡眠纺锤和持续EEG背景与持续EEG亚组良好结局相关。
- 持续EEG(30-48小时)较重复20分钟常规EEG提供更多预后信息,标准化EEG解读可提供可靠预后信息。
适用人群与场景
- 成人ICU急性意识障碍患者,来自多个成人ICU,随机接受持续EEG(30-48小时)或重复20分钟常规EEG。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 采用改良Rankin量表评估6个月功能结局,0-2分定义为良好结局。
- 脑电特征包括背景连续性、频率、反应性、睡眠纺锤、侧化周期性放电、广泛节律性δ活动等。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 原文未提及
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 侧化周期性放电与死亡率和不良改良Rankin量表(3-6分)相关,需警惕。
- 广泛节律性δ活动与较低癫痫持续状态发生率相关,但癫痫持续状态本身需关注。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:随机对照试验的回顾性分析;样本量364例,多中心成人ICU;人群为急性意识障碍成人;干预为持续EEG(30-48小时,n=182) vs 重复20分钟常规EEG(n=182)。
- 主要终点:脑电特征与6个月死亡率和改良Rankin量表(良好0-2分)的相关性。
- 常规EEG组联合模型(背景频率、连续性、反应性、睡眠纺锤、侧化周期性放电)预测死亡率PPV 70.91%(95%CI 59.62-80.10%),NPV 63.93%(95%CI 58.67-68.89%)。
- 持续EEG组联合模型(背景连续性、反应性、广泛节律性δ活动、侧化周期性放电)预测死亡率PPV 84.62%(95%CI 75.02-90.97%),NPV 74.77%(95%CI 68.50-80.16%)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:随机对照试验的回顾性分析;局限包括回顾性分析、样本量有限(364例)。
对床旁实践的改变
- 在成人ICU急性意识障碍患者中,持续EEG(30-48小时)较常规EEG提供更多预后信息,可考虑用于预后评估。
- 标准化EEG解读特征(背景连续性、反应性、侧化周期性放电、广泛节律性δ活动等)可用于预后判断,但需注意模型预测值来自特定人群和分析。
指南或共识出处
- Crit Care Med
以上提炼依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取,或许可不允许翻译转载);全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To investigate electroencephalogram (EEG) features' relation with mortality or functional outcome after disorder of consciousness, stratifying patients between continuous EEG and routine EEG.
DESIGN: Retrospective analysis of data from a randomized controlled trial.
SETTING: Multiple adult ICUs.
PATIENTS: Data from 364 adults with acute disorder of consciousness, randomized to continuous EEG (30-48 hr; n = 182) or repeated 20-minute routine electroencephalogram (n = 182).
INTERVENTIONS: None.
MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Correlations between electrographic features and mortality and modified Rankin scale at 6 months (good 0-2) were assessed. Background continuity, higher frequency, and reactivity correlated with survival and good modified Rankin scale. Rhythmic and periodic patterns carried dual prognostic information: lateralized periodic discharges were associated with mortality and bad modified Rankin scale. Generalized rhythmic delta activity correlated with survival, good modified Rankin scale, and lower occurrence of status epilepticus. Presence of sleep-spindles and continuous EEG background was associated with good outcome in the continuous EEG subgroup. In the routine EEG group, a model combining background frequency, continuity, reactivity, sleep-spindles, and lateralized periodic discharges was associated with mortality at 70.91% (95% CI, 59.62-80.10%) positive predictive value and 63.93% (95% CI, 58.67-68.89%) negative predictive value. In the continuous EEG group, a model combining background continuity, reactivity, generalized rhythmic delta activity, and lateralized periodic discharges was associated with mortality at 84.62% (95%CI, 75.02-90.97) positive predictive value and 74.77% (95% CI, 68.50-80.16) negative predictive value.
CONCLUSIONS: Standardized EEG interpretation provides reliable prognostic information. Continuous EEG provides more information than routine EEG.
参考来源
- Beuchat I, Rossetti AO, Novy J, et al. Continuous Versus Routine Standardized Electroencephalogram for Outcome Prediction in Critically Ill Adults: Analysis From a Randomized Trial. Crit Care Med. 2022. PMID: 34582427. doi:10.1097/CCM.0000000000005311
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。