文献速递呼吸衰竭与机械通气重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

在明尼苏达州将呼吸机分配伦理指南付诸实施:拯救最多生命,还是加剧健康不平等?

Operationalizing Ethical Guidance for Ventilator Allocation in Minnesota: Saving the Most Lives or Exacerbating Health Disparities?
PubMed 文献 · Crit Care Explor · 2021-06-11
一句话结论呼吸机分配评分可识别短期死亡率高的患者,但那些患者只占全部死亡者的27%,且纳入年龄和终末期肾病可能加剧健康不平等。

明尼苏达州一个全州工作组建立了呼吸机分配评分系统,拟在危机照护标准状态下使用,适用于新冠与非新冠患者。该多医院回顾性队列纳入504例急诊插管并入住ICU的患者,评分与住院及3个月死亡率正相关(p<0.0001)。评分≥6分者3个月死亡率为96%(42/44例),≥80岁且评分≥4分者为93%(40/43例)。但高死亡率患者仅占全部死亡者的27%,限制了该评分分配稀缺资源的效用;作者认为评分可能不公平地优先考虑老年患者,并因纳入终末期肾病等特定合并症而无意中加剧种族健康差异。

要点

  • 呼吸机分配评分与更高死亡率正相关(p<0.0001),评分≥6分者3个月死亡率为96%(42/44例)
  • 年龄与死亡率正相关,≥80岁且评分≥4分者3个月死亡率为93%(40/43例)
  • 高死亡率患者仅占全部死亡者的27%,限制评分用于稀缺资源分配的效用
  • 评分5分者中,终末期肾病患者死亡率25% vs 无终末期肾病患者58%(n=27;p=0.2),差异未达统计学显著
  • 作者认为评分可能不公平地优先考虑老年患者,并因纳入终末期肾病等特定合并症而无意中加剧种族健康差异

适用人群与场景

  • 明尼苏达州单一医疗系统内多医院急诊插管并入住ICU的患者,共504例
  • 评分系统拟在危机照护标准声明下使用,适用于新冠与非新冠患者

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 呼吸机分配评分:评分≥6分者3个月死亡率为96%(42/44例);≥80岁且评分≥4分者3个月死亡率为93%(40/43例)

研究设计与关键结果

  • 回顾性队列研究,纳入单一医疗系统内多医院504例急诊插管并入住ICU的患者,无干预
  • 呼吸机分配评分与更高死亡率正相关(p<0.0001)
  • 评分≥6分者3个月死亡率为96%(42/44例)
  • ≥80岁且评分≥4分者3个月死亡率为93%(40/43例)
  • 评分5分者中,终末期肾病患者死亡率25% vs 无终末期肾病患者58%(n=27;p=0.2),差异未达统计学显著
  • 高死亡率患者仅占全部死亡者的27%

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 回顾性队列研究
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,该评分可准确识别短期死亡率高的患者,但这些患者仅占全部死亡者的27%,限制了该评分在稀缺资源分配中的效用
  • 作者认为,该评分可能不公平地优先考虑老年患者,并因纳入终末期肾病等特定合并症而无意中加剧种族健康差异
  • 作者认为,应考虑纳入年龄的分诊框架;必须做出有目的的努力,确保分诊方案不会延续或加剧现有的不平等
  • 作者认为,重症监护环境中稀缺资源分配的进一步工作将受益于对主要伦理目标的共识

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

UNLABELLED: A statewide working group in Minnesota created a ventilator allocation scoring system in anticipation of functioning under a Crisis Standards of Care declaration. The scoring system was intended for patients with and without coronavirus disease 2019. There was disagreement about whether the scoring system might exacerbate health disparities and about whether the score should include age. We measured the relationship of ventilator scores to in-hospital and 3-month mortality. We analyzed our findings in the context of ethical and legal guidance for the triage of scarce resources.

DESIGN: Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING: Multihospital within a single healthcare system.

PATIENTS: Five-hundred four patients emergently intubated and admitted to the ICU.

INTERVENTIONS: None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: The Ventilator Allocation Score was positively associated with higher mortality (p < 0.0001). The 3-month mortality rate for patients with a score of 6 or higher was 96% (42/44 patients). Age was positively associated with mortality. The 3-month mortality rate for patients 80 and older with scores of 4 or greater was 93% (40/43 patients). Of patients assigned a score of 5, those with end stage renal disease had lower mortality than patients without end stage renal disease although the difference did not achieve statistical significance (n = 27; 25% vs 58%; p = 0.2).

CONCLUSIONS: The Ventilator Allocation Score can accurately identify patients with high rates of short-term mortality. However, these high mortality patients only represent 27% of all the patients who died, limiting the utility of the score for allocation of scarce resources. The score may unfairly prioritize older patients and inadvertently exacerbate racial health disparities through the inclusion of specific comorbidities such as end stage renal disease. Triage frameworks that include age should be considered. Purposeful efforts must be taken to ensure that triage protocols do not perpetuate or exacerbate prevailing inequities. Further work on the allocation of scarce resources in critical care settings would benefit from consensus on the primary ethical objective.

来源:Crit Care Explor,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Kesler SM, Wu JT, Kalland KR, et al. Operationalizing Ethical Guidance for Ventilator Allocation in Minnesota: Saving the Most Lives or Exacerbating Health Disparities? Crit Care Explor. 2021. PMID: 34136826. doi:10.1097/CCE.0000000000000455

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。