为下一次重大事件做准备:我们准备好了吗?重大创伤中心与其他医院的比较
该研究于2016/2017年第四季度筛选英格兰急诊量超过30000人次的信托机构,联系各机构值班的麻醉、急诊、普外科及创伤骨科注册医师,用3个问题评估其对医院重大事件预案(MIP)的使用信心。比较重大创伤中心(MTC)与非MTC医师的回答,采用多项混合比例优势模型分析。结果显示仅第2问(是否知道MIP指南获取位置)MTC优于非MTC(OR=2.43,CI=1.03~5.73,p=0.04),第1问(是否读过MIP,OR=1.41,CI=0.55~3.63,p=0.47)与第3问(是否知道值班时角色,OR=1.78,CI=0.86~3.69,p=0.12)无差异证据;急诊与麻醉注册医师在各领域准备度和知识显著更高。作者认为英格兰专科注册医师使用MIP的信心仍低,并提出改进重大事件教育的建议。
要点
- 在英格兰,仅第2问(知道MIP指南获取位置)MTC医师优于非MTC(OR=2.43,CI=1.03~5.73,p=0.04),第1问与第3问无差异证据。
- 第1问是否读过医院MIP:MTC vs 非MTC OR=1.41(CI=0.55~3.63,p=0.47),无差异证据。
- 第3问是否知道值班时在MIP中的角色:OR=1.78(CI=0.86~3.69,p=0.12),无差异证据。
- 急诊与麻醉注册医师在所有领域的准备度和知识显著高于其他专科。
- 未发现MTC与非MTC在专科应答上存在系统性差异的证据。
适用人群与场景
- 英格兰2016/2017年第四季度急诊量超过30000人次的信托机构中,值班的麻醉、急诊、普外科及创伤骨科注册医师。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为调查比较,评估英格兰医院关键人员对重大事件预案(MIP)的准备度和知识。
- 第2问(知道MIP指南获取位置)MTC vs 非MTC:OR=2.43(CI=1.03~5.73,p=0.04)。
- 第1问(读过医院MIP)MTC vs 非MTC:OR=1.41(CI=0.55~3.63,p=0.47)。
- 第3问(知道值班时角色)MTC vs 非MTC:OR=1.78(CI=0.86~3.69,p=0.12)。
- 急诊与麻醉注册医师在所有领域的准备度和知识显著更高。
- 未发现MTC与非MTC在专科应答上存在系统性差异的证据。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:调查比较研究(横断面调查)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为英格兰专科注册医师使用MIP的信心仍低,并提出若干改进重大事件教育的建议。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: A major incident is any emergency requiring special arrangements by the emergency services. All hospitals are required by law to keep a major incident plan (MIP) detailing the response to such events. In 2006 and 2019, we assessed the preparedness and knowledge of key individuals in hospitals across England and found a substantial gap in responding to the MIP. In this report, we compare responses from doctors at major trauma centres (MTCs) and other hospitals (non-MTCs).
METHODS: We identified trusts in England that received over 30 000 patients through the ED in the fourth quarter of 2016/2017. We contacted the on-call anaesthetic, emergency, general surgery and trauma and orthopaedic registrar at each location and asked three questions assessing their confidence in using their hospital's MIP: (1) Have you read your hospital's MIP? (2) Do you know where you can access your hospital's MIP guidelines? (3) Do you know what role you would play if an MIP came into effect while you are on call?We compared data from MTCs and non-MTCs using multinomial mixed proportional odds models.
RESULTS: There was a modest difference between responses from individuals at MTCs and non-MTCs for question 2 (OR=2.43, CI=1.03 to 5.73, p=0.04) but no evidence of a difference between question 1 (OR=1.41, CI=0.55 to 3.63, p=0.47) and question 3 (OR=1.78, CI=0.86 to 3.69, p=0.12). Emergency medicine and anaesthetic registrars showed significantly higher preparedness and knowledge across all domains. No evidence of a systematic difference in specialty response by MTC or otherwise was identified.
CONCLUSIONS: Confidence in using MIPs among specialty registrars in England remains low. Doctors at MTCs tended to be better prepared and more knowledgeable, but this effect was only marginally significant. We make several recommendations to improve education on major incidents.
参考来源
- Mawhinney JA, Roscoe HW, Stannard GAJ, et al. Preparation for the next major incident: are we ready? Comparing major trauma centres and other hospitals. Emerg Med J. 2021. PMID: 34039644. doi:10.1136/emermed-2020-209767
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。