文献速递重症综合管理与镇静镇痛消化、代谢与肾脏急症

广西地区重症感染诊断临床思维的问卷调查与分析

[Investigation and analysis of questionnaire on clinical thinking in the diagnosis of severe infection in Guangxi].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue · 2020-01-01
一句话结论广西重症相关医务人员对发热、低血压等感染相关症状可信度高,但29.3%-42.6%不了解NGS,病原培养与NGS结果解读不足,综合诊断能力需提高。

该研究于2019年9月26日至28日在广西医师协会重症医学医师分会学术年会上对临床医务人员进行问卷调查,了解其在重症感染诊断中的临床思维。共540人参与(参与率约90.0%),回收有效问卷466份(有效率86.3%),包括医生280人、临床护士155人、临床药师10人、医学研究生21人。四组人员对发热、低血压、意识障碍、呼吸、尿量减少等感染相关症状的认可度和可信度相似,但对病原培养和NGS结果解读不足,29.3%-42.6%的医务人员不了解NGS,且四组对部分传统感染相关实验室指标的判读存在显著差异。结论认为不同岗位医务人员重症感染诊断临床思维存在差异,综合诊断能力需提高。

要点

  • 调查共540人参与(参与率约90.0%),回收有效问卷466份(有效率86.3%),其中医生280人、护士155人、临床药师10人、医学研究生21人。
  • 医生与护士主要来自综合ICU(分别为73.2%和51.0%);医生组以中级职称居多(43.2%),护士、临床药师、医学研究生组以初级职称居多(分别为53.5%、80.0%、81.0%)。
  • 四组对感染相关症状可信度相似:发热80.0%-91.1%、低血压76.2%-90.0%、意识障碍80.0%-85.0%、呼吸81.0%-100.0%、尿量减少81.9%-90.0%。
  • 29.3%-42.6%的医务人员不了解NGS,对病原培养和NGS结果解读不足;对「标本培养阳性可诊断感染」的认同率医生93.6% vs 护士85.2% vs 临床药师90.0% vs 医学研究生85.7%(P=0.021)。
  • 四组对WBC升高(χ2=8.542,P=0.026)、CRP升高(χ2=8.826,P=0.024)、IL-6升高(χ2=13.944,P=0.002)、G试验阳性(χ2=10.988,P=0.009)、GM试验阳性(χ2=12.306,P=0.004)的判读存在显著差异。

适用人群与场景

  • 参加2019年9月26日至28日广西医师协会重症医学医师分会学术年会的临床医务人员,包括医生、护士、临床药师和医学研究生,排除非临床人员。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 可信度分级:高可信度51%-100%,低可信度0%-50%。
  • 临床诊断感染的依据因素包括临床症状、特异性生化检查、微生物学检查和二代测序技术(NGS)。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型为问卷调查;540人参与(参与率约90.0%),回收有效问卷466份(有效率86.3%),包括医生280人、临床护士155人、临床药师10人、医学研究生21人。
  • 医生、护士、临床药师、医学研究生工作年限分别为(8.2±6.0)、(6.4±6.3)、(4.5±4.0)、(3.8±2.6)年。
  • 医生组中级职称占43.2%;护士组、临床药师组、医学研究生组初级职称分别占53.5%、80.0%、81.0%。
  • 医生和护士主要来自综合ICU,分别占73.2%和51.0%。
  • 四组对感染相关症状的认可度和可信度相似:发热可信度80.0%-91.1%,低血压76.2%-90.0%,意识障碍80.0%-85.0%,呼吸81.0%-100.0%,尿量减少81.9%-90.0%。
  • 29.3%-42.6%的医务人员不了解NGS,对病原培养和NGS结果解读不足。
  • 对「标本培养阳性可诊断感染」的认同率:医生93.6% vs 护士85.2% vs 临床药师90.0% vs 医学研究生85.7%,P=0.021。
  • 四组对WBC升高(χ2=8.542,P=0.026)、CRP升高(χ2=8.826,P=0.024)、IL-6升高(χ2=13.944,P=0.002)、G试验阳性(χ2=10.988,P=0.009)、GM试验阳性(χ2=12.306,P=0.004)的判读存在显著差异。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:问卷调查。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 调查显示29.3%-42.6%的医务人员不了解NGS,对病原培养和NGS结果解读不足,提示需提升相关解读能力。
  • 不同岗位医务人员对WBC、CRP、IL-6、G试验、GM试验等传统感染相关实验室指标的判读存在显著差异(P=0.026、P=0.024、P=0.002、P=0.009、P=0.004),综合诊断能力需提高。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: To understand the clinical thinking of clinical staff in the diagnosis of severe infection and evaluate their ability to recognize severe infection in the early stage.

METHODS: A questionnaire survey was conducted to investigate the clinical thinking of clinical staff attending the academic annual meeting of critical care physicians of Guangxi Medical Doctors Association from September 26 to September 28, 2019. The objects of investigation included doctors, nurses, clinical pharmacists and medical graduate students, except for non-clinical personnel. The basis factors of clinical diagnosis of infection included clinical symptoms, specific biochemical examination, microorganism examination and Next-generation sequencing technology (NGS). The credibility level of each indicator was summarized as high (credibility of 51%-100%) and low (credibility of 0%-50%).

RESULTS: Among the more than 600 participants, 540 people participated in the questionnaire survey (participation rate of about 90.0%), and 466 qualified questionnaires (effective rate of 86.3%) were collected, including 280 from doctors, 155 from clinical nurses, 10 from clinical pharmacists and 21 from clinical graduate students. The working years of doctors, nurses, clinical pharmacists and medical graduate students were (8.2±6.0), (6.4±6.3), (4.5±4.0) and (3.8±2.6) years, respectively. The intermediate title (43.2%) dominated in the doctors group, while junior title dominated in the nurses group, clinical pharmacists group and medical postgraduate group (53.5%, 80.0% and 81.0% respectively). Doctors and nurses were mainly from the general intensive care unit (ICU; 73.2% and 51.0% respectively). According to the results of investigation of clinical thinking on the diagnosis of severe infection, there was similar degree of recognition and credibility for infection-related symptoms in the four groups of doctors, nurses, clinical pharmacists and medical graduate students (the credibility of fever was 80.0%-91.1%, low blood pressure 76.2%-90.0%, disturbance of consciousness 80.0%-85.0%, breathing 81.0%-100.0%, reduced of urine 81.9%-90.0%). The interpretation for pathogen culture and NGS results was insufficient because 29.3%-42.6% of the medical staff did not understand NGS. There were differences in the interpretation of the results of pathogen culture (positive specimen culture could diagnose infection; medical vs. nursing vs. pharmacists vs. student: 93.6% vs. 85.2% vs. 90.0% vs. 85.7%, P = 0.021). There were significant differences among the four groups in some traditional infection-related laboratory indexes which included increased white blood cell count (WBC; χ2 = 8.542, P = 0.026), increased C-reactive protein (CRP; χ2 = 8.826, P = 0.024), increased interleukin-6 (IL-6; χ2 = 13.944, P = 0.002), positive 1, 3-β-D glucan detection test (G test; χ2 = 10.988, P = 0.009) and positive galactomannan antigen detection test (GM test; χ2 = 12.306, P = 0.004).

CONCLUSIONS: There is difference in clinical thinking of diagnosis of severe infection among clinical medical staff in different positions, and the comprehensive diagnostic ability needs to be improved.

来源:Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Pan Y, Jiang C, Hu J, et al. [Investigation and analysis of questionnaire on clinical thinking in the diagnosis of severe infection in Guangxi]. Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue. 2020. PMID: 33541508. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn121430-20200810-00569

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。